<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?>

<!--XBRL Document Created with the Workiva Platform-->
<!--Copyright 2024 Workiva-->
<!--r:71ccf5d5-ed4b-4694-b229-a0eae90c3cdd,g:2c2f46d3-c517-4770-a96a-6825b1236314-->
<link:linkbase xmlns:link="http://www.xbrl.org/2003/linkbase" xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink" xmlns:xsi="http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema-instance" xmlns:xbrldt="http://xbrl.org/2005/xbrldt" xsi:schemaLocation="http://www.xbrl.org/2003/linkbase http://www.xbrl.org/2003/xbrl-linkbase-2003-12-31.xsd">
  <link:arcroleRef arcroleURI="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/all" xlink:type="simple" xlink:href="http://www.xbrl.org/2005/xbrldt-2005.xsd#all"/>
  <link:arcroleRef arcroleURI="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/hypercube-dimension" xlink:type="simple" xlink:href="http://www.xbrl.org/2005/xbrldt-2005.xsd#hypercube-dimension"/>
  <link:arcroleRef arcroleURI="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-default" xlink:type="simple" xlink:href="http://www.xbrl.org/2005/xbrldt-2005.xsd#dimension-default"/>
  <link:arcroleRef arcroleURI="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-domain" xlink:type="simple" xlink:href="http://www.xbrl.org/2005/xbrldt-2005.xsd#dimension-domain"/>
  <link:arcroleRef arcroleURI="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:type="simple" xlink:href="http://www.xbrl.org/2005/xbrldt-2005.xsd#domain-member"/>
  <link:roleRef roleURI="http://www.afginc.com/role/Cover" xlink:type="simple" xlink:href="afg-20240930.xsd#Cover"/>
  <link:definitionLink xlink:role="http://www.afginc.com/role/Cover" xlink:type="extended">
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_dei_EntityInformationLineItems_ac9f5aed-94ba-4cf6-8d91-ed8ebf40601b" xlink:href="https://xbrl.sec.gov/dei/2024/dei-2024.xsd#dei_EntityInformationLineItems"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_dei_EntitiesTable_93aea895-7d3e-41f2-bacc-61bb2b591fe4" xlink:href="https://xbrl.sec.gov/dei/2024/dei-2024.xsd#dei_EntitiesTable"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/all" xlink:from="loc_dei_EntityInformationLineItems_ac9f5aed-94ba-4cf6-8d91-ed8ebf40601b" xlink:to="loc_dei_EntitiesTable_93aea895-7d3e-41f2-bacc-61bb2b591fe4" xlink:type="arc" order="1" xbrldt:closed="true" xbrldt:contextElement="segment"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_StatementClassOfStockAxis_78022192-00a4-414a-b610-65827cdde306" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_StatementClassOfStockAxis"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/hypercube-dimension" xlink:from="loc_dei_EntitiesTable_93aea895-7d3e-41f2-bacc-61bb2b591fe4" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_StatementClassOfStockAxis_78022192-00a4-414a-b610-65827cdde306" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_ClassOfStockDomain_78022192-00a4-414a-b610-65827cdde306_default" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_ClassOfStockDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-default" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_StatementClassOfStockAxis_78022192-00a4-414a-b610-65827cdde306" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_ClassOfStockDomain_78022192-00a4-414a-b610-65827cdde306_default" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_ClassOfStockDomain_6c228a8f-eb90-4edb-a7c6-1c218aa5cf78" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_ClassOfStockDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-domain" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_StatementClassOfStockAxis_78022192-00a4-414a-b610-65827cdde306" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_ClassOfStockDomain_6c228a8f-eb90-4edb-a7c6-1c218aa5cf78" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_CommonStockMember_f83aa1e2-9ab1-4469-a31b-2c989887c624" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_CommonStockMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ClassOfStockDomain_6c228a8f-eb90-4edb-a7c6-1c218aa5cf78" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_CommonStockMember_f83aa1e2-9ab1-4469-a31b-2c989887c624" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_SubordinatedDebenturesDueInMarch2059Member_e57dd981-7e14-49bd-ad04-43bed1c60939" xlink:href="afg-20240930.xsd#afg_SubordinatedDebenturesDueInMarch2059Member"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ClassOfStockDomain_6c228a8f-eb90-4edb-a7c6-1c218aa5cf78" xlink:to="loc_afg_SubordinatedDebenturesDueInMarch2059Member_e57dd981-7e14-49bd-ad04-43bed1c60939" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_SubordinatedDebenturesDueInJune2060Member_f2e48019-cc4e-4e96-a0bd-b8406956a2ac" xlink:href="afg-20240930.xsd#afg_SubordinatedDebenturesDueInJune2060Member"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ClassOfStockDomain_6c228a8f-eb90-4edb-a7c6-1c218aa5cf78" xlink:to="loc_afg_SubordinatedDebenturesDueInJune2060Member_f2e48019-cc4e-4e96-a0bd-b8406956a2ac" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_SubordinatedDebenturesdueinDecember2059Member_f3176e05-787d-45f0-a1ce-87a3300ea75c" xlink:href="afg-20240930.xsd#afg_SubordinatedDebenturesdueinDecember2059Member"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ClassOfStockDomain_6c228a8f-eb90-4edb-a7c6-1c218aa5cf78" xlink:to="loc_afg_SubordinatedDebenturesdueinDecember2059Member_f3176e05-787d-45f0-a1ce-87a3300ea75c" xlink:type="arc" order="3"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_SubordinatedDebenturesDueInSeptember2060Member_a20fe487-a7c8-4c94-9d33-869887b22ed4" xlink:href="afg-20240930.xsd#afg_SubordinatedDebenturesDueInSeptember2060Member"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ClassOfStockDomain_6c228a8f-eb90-4edb-a7c6-1c218aa5cf78" xlink:to="loc_afg_SubordinatedDebenturesDueInSeptember2060Member_a20fe487-a7c8-4c94-9d33-869887b22ed4" xlink:type="arc" order="4"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_dei_DocumentType_67f256e2-5884-4fff-9149-c7905ac73dc4" xlink:href="https://xbrl.sec.gov/dei/2024/dei-2024.xsd#dei_DocumentType"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_dei_EntityInformationLineItems_ac9f5aed-94ba-4cf6-8d91-ed8ebf40601b" xlink:to="loc_dei_DocumentType_67f256e2-5884-4fff-9149-c7905ac73dc4" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_dei_DocumentQuarterlyReport_8aaaf58c-05aa-4193-9da8-0984086ff73d" xlink:href="https://xbrl.sec.gov/dei/2024/dei-2024.xsd#dei_DocumentQuarterlyReport"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_dei_EntityInformationLineItems_ac9f5aed-94ba-4cf6-8d91-ed8ebf40601b" xlink:to="loc_dei_DocumentQuarterlyReport_8aaaf58c-05aa-4193-9da8-0984086ff73d" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_dei_DocumentPeriodEndDate_1bf50d17-3ab0-495a-801c-deab839074ff" xlink:href="https://xbrl.sec.gov/dei/2024/dei-2024.xsd#dei_DocumentPeriodEndDate"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_dei_EntityInformationLineItems_ac9f5aed-94ba-4cf6-8d91-ed8ebf40601b" xlink:to="loc_dei_DocumentPeriodEndDate_1bf50d17-3ab0-495a-801c-deab839074ff" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_dei_DocumentTransitionReport_b9657aee-3c2e-44eb-ada1-6346b6550a0a" xlink:href="https://xbrl.sec.gov/dei/2024/dei-2024.xsd#dei_DocumentTransitionReport"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_dei_EntityInformationLineItems_ac9f5aed-94ba-4cf6-8d91-ed8ebf40601b" xlink:to="loc_dei_DocumentTransitionReport_b9657aee-3c2e-44eb-ada1-6346b6550a0a" xlink:type="arc" order="3"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_dei_EntityFileNumber_8c50ad50-a36d-48a2-b4fd-2e34b71aeb29" xlink:href="https://xbrl.sec.gov/dei/2024/dei-2024.xsd#dei_EntityFileNumber"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_dei_EntityInformationLineItems_ac9f5aed-94ba-4cf6-8d91-ed8ebf40601b" xlink:to="loc_dei_EntityFileNumber_8c50ad50-a36d-48a2-b4fd-2e34b71aeb29" xlink:type="arc" order="4"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_dei_EntityRegistrantName_9f39b8db-7885-4938-8bd3-273061020d5f" xlink:href="https://xbrl.sec.gov/dei/2024/dei-2024.xsd#dei_EntityRegistrantName"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_dei_EntityInformationLineItems_ac9f5aed-94ba-4cf6-8d91-ed8ebf40601b" xlink:to="loc_dei_EntityRegistrantName_9f39b8db-7885-4938-8bd3-273061020d5f" xlink:type="arc" order="5"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_dei_EntityIncorporationStateCountryCode_3648f53e-e932-4de4-aaa5-71d8d8ad7b84" xlink:href="https://xbrl.sec.gov/dei/2024/dei-2024.xsd#dei_EntityIncorporationStateCountryCode"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_dei_EntityInformationLineItems_ac9f5aed-94ba-4cf6-8d91-ed8ebf40601b" xlink:to="loc_dei_EntityIncorporationStateCountryCode_3648f53e-e932-4de4-aaa5-71d8d8ad7b84" xlink:type="arc" order="6"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_dei_EntityTaxIdentificationNumber_3b72cd46-1e55-46db-918a-fb1eeaa44eef" xlink:href="https://xbrl.sec.gov/dei/2024/dei-2024.xsd#dei_EntityTaxIdentificationNumber"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_dei_EntityInformationLineItems_ac9f5aed-94ba-4cf6-8d91-ed8ebf40601b" xlink:to="loc_dei_EntityTaxIdentificationNumber_3b72cd46-1e55-46db-918a-fb1eeaa44eef" xlink:type="arc" order="7"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_dei_EntityAddressAddressLine1_19e932a0-e7b2-4c2f-b343-1b67ad462b1a" xlink:href="https://xbrl.sec.gov/dei/2024/dei-2024.xsd#dei_EntityAddressAddressLine1"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_dei_EntityInformationLineItems_ac9f5aed-94ba-4cf6-8d91-ed8ebf40601b" xlink:to="loc_dei_EntityAddressAddressLine1_19e932a0-e7b2-4c2f-b343-1b67ad462b1a" xlink:type="arc" order="8"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_dei_EntityAddressCityOrTown_1c593a1c-6ca3-4421-9878-7f3e484c183a" xlink:href="https://xbrl.sec.gov/dei/2024/dei-2024.xsd#dei_EntityAddressCityOrTown"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_dei_EntityInformationLineItems_ac9f5aed-94ba-4cf6-8d91-ed8ebf40601b" xlink:to="loc_dei_EntityAddressCityOrTown_1c593a1c-6ca3-4421-9878-7f3e484c183a" xlink:type="arc" order="9"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_dei_EntityAddressStateOrProvince_0c756416-6c8f-4e18-bda1-be35f55308c8" xlink:href="https://xbrl.sec.gov/dei/2024/dei-2024.xsd#dei_EntityAddressStateOrProvince"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_dei_EntityInformationLineItems_ac9f5aed-94ba-4cf6-8d91-ed8ebf40601b" xlink:to="loc_dei_EntityAddressStateOrProvince_0c756416-6c8f-4e18-bda1-be35f55308c8" xlink:type="arc" order="10"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_dei_EntityAddressPostalZipCode_88d892f6-12f1-4ff5-996b-26c8e86d6a23" xlink:href="https://xbrl.sec.gov/dei/2024/dei-2024.xsd#dei_EntityAddressPostalZipCode"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_dei_EntityInformationLineItems_ac9f5aed-94ba-4cf6-8d91-ed8ebf40601b" xlink:to="loc_dei_EntityAddressPostalZipCode_88d892f6-12f1-4ff5-996b-26c8e86d6a23" xlink:type="arc" order="11"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_dei_CityAreaCode_106662ea-6e24-4232-a661-b1fd21fb3701" xlink:href="https://xbrl.sec.gov/dei/2024/dei-2024.xsd#dei_CityAreaCode"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_dei_EntityInformationLineItems_ac9f5aed-94ba-4cf6-8d91-ed8ebf40601b" xlink:to="loc_dei_CityAreaCode_106662ea-6e24-4232-a661-b1fd21fb3701" xlink:type="arc" order="12"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_dei_LocalPhoneNumber_02e344d7-26bc-4ca4-bef5-b68d88de86ce" xlink:href="https://xbrl.sec.gov/dei/2024/dei-2024.xsd#dei_LocalPhoneNumber"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_dei_EntityInformationLineItems_ac9f5aed-94ba-4cf6-8d91-ed8ebf40601b" xlink:to="loc_dei_LocalPhoneNumber_02e344d7-26bc-4ca4-bef5-b68d88de86ce" xlink:type="arc" order="13"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_dei_Security12bTitle_5e69e6f8-d555-4307-9b9e-5fc806b8aba8" xlink:href="https://xbrl.sec.gov/dei/2024/dei-2024.xsd#dei_Security12bTitle"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_dei_EntityInformationLineItems_ac9f5aed-94ba-4cf6-8d91-ed8ebf40601b" xlink:to="loc_dei_Security12bTitle_5e69e6f8-d555-4307-9b9e-5fc806b8aba8" xlink:type="arc" order="14"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_dei_TradingSymbol_280f1ade-2b07-42e1-8d6f-8c20787e9bb3" xlink:href="https://xbrl.sec.gov/dei/2024/dei-2024.xsd#dei_TradingSymbol"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_dei_EntityInformationLineItems_ac9f5aed-94ba-4cf6-8d91-ed8ebf40601b" xlink:to="loc_dei_TradingSymbol_280f1ade-2b07-42e1-8d6f-8c20787e9bb3" xlink:type="arc" order="15"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_dei_SecurityExchangeName_987a5b61-36c6-474e-8015-1182cff6554a" xlink:href="https://xbrl.sec.gov/dei/2024/dei-2024.xsd#dei_SecurityExchangeName"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_dei_EntityInformationLineItems_ac9f5aed-94ba-4cf6-8d91-ed8ebf40601b" xlink:to="loc_dei_SecurityExchangeName_987a5b61-36c6-474e-8015-1182cff6554a" xlink:type="arc" order="16"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_dei_EntityCurrentReportingStatus_448d43f7-7c15-417b-b9f6-41abc0b26f29" xlink:href="https://xbrl.sec.gov/dei/2024/dei-2024.xsd#dei_EntityCurrentReportingStatus"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_dei_EntityInformationLineItems_ac9f5aed-94ba-4cf6-8d91-ed8ebf40601b" xlink:to="loc_dei_EntityCurrentReportingStatus_448d43f7-7c15-417b-b9f6-41abc0b26f29" xlink:type="arc" order="17"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_dei_EntityInteractiveDataCurrent_c3cfb8e1-d6f7-4527-a581-39a7e0fd0200" xlink:href="https://xbrl.sec.gov/dei/2024/dei-2024.xsd#dei_EntityInteractiveDataCurrent"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_dei_EntityInformationLineItems_ac9f5aed-94ba-4cf6-8d91-ed8ebf40601b" xlink:to="loc_dei_EntityInteractiveDataCurrent_c3cfb8e1-d6f7-4527-a581-39a7e0fd0200" xlink:type="arc" order="18"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_dei_EntityFilerCategory_e1cc9868-6d28-40e3-abf0-f7965eb2c094" xlink:href="https://xbrl.sec.gov/dei/2024/dei-2024.xsd#dei_EntityFilerCategory"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_dei_EntityInformationLineItems_ac9f5aed-94ba-4cf6-8d91-ed8ebf40601b" xlink:to="loc_dei_EntityFilerCategory_e1cc9868-6d28-40e3-abf0-f7965eb2c094" xlink:type="arc" order="19"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_dei_EntitySmallBusiness_1e6f82b6-5672-493a-b678-bf287dbaeaac" xlink:href="https://xbrl.sec.gov/dei/2024/dei-2024.xsd#dei_EntitySmallBusiness"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_dei_EntityInformationLineItems_ac9f5aed-94ba-4cf6-8d91-ed8ebf40601b" xlink:to="loc_dei_EntitySmallBusiness_1e6f82b6-5672-493a-b678-bf287dbaeaac" xlink:type="arc" order="20"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_dei_EntityEmergingGrowthCompany_2bd2a1e1-d660-4d49-b33e-f494febd66a0" xlink:href="https://xbrl.sec.gov/dei/2024/dei-2024.xsd#dei_EntityEmergingGrowthCompany"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_dei_EntityInformationLineItems_ac9f5aed-94ba-4cf6-8d91-ed8ebf40601b" xlink:to="loc_dei_EntityEmergingGrowthCompany_2bd2a1e1-d660-4d49-b33e-f494febd66a0" xlink:type="arc" order="21"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_dei_EntityShellCompany_ef19c6e2-3d88-4b14-8cff-efcf4e2ea58b" xlink:href="https://xbrl.sec.gov/dei/2024/dei-2024.xsd#dei_EntityShellCompany"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_dei_EntityInformationLineItems_ac9f5aed-94ba-4cf6-8d91-ed8ebf40601b" xlink:to="loc_dei_EntityShellCompany_ef19c6e2-3d88-4b14-8cff-efcf4e2ea58b" xlink:type="arc" order="22"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_dei_EntityCommonStockSharesOutstanding_9a4df8af-4d32-4fb7-b894-79a1dd290662" xlink:href="https://xbrl.sec.gov/dei/2024/dei-2024.xsd#dei_EntityCommonStockSharesOutstanding"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_dei_EntityInformationLineItems_ac9f5aed-94ba-4cf6-8d91-ed8ebf40601b" xlink:to="loc_dei_EntityCommonStockSharesOutstanding_9a4df8af-4d32-4fb7-b894-79a1dd290662" xlink:type="arc" order="23"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_dei_EntityCentralIndexKey_6bf8d65b-53eb-4ee4-9e9a-5a1c124b4380" xlink:href="https://xbrl.sec.gov/dei/2024/dei-2024.xsd#dei_EntityCentralIndexKey"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_dei_EntityInformationLineItems_ac9f5aed-94ba-4cf6-8d91-ed8ebf40601b" xlink:to="loc_dei_EntityCentralIndexKey_6bf8d65b-53eb-4ee4-9e9a-5a1c124b4380" xlink:type="arc" order="24"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_dei_AmendmentFlag_1e011b27-5765-4918-897e-6444a6c649e2" xlink:href="https://xbrl.sec.gov/dei/2024/dei-2024.xsd#dei_AmendmentFlag"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_dei_EntityInformationLineItems_ac9f5aed-94ba-4cf6-8d91-ed8ebf40601b" xlink:to="loc_dei_AmendmentFlag_1e011b27-5765-4918-897e-6444a6c649e2" xlink:type="arc" order="25"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_dei_DocumentFiscalYearFocus_33f6b6f6-ce30-45b0-af1b-13e5bb8a95aa" xlink:href="https://xbrl.sec.gov/dei/2024/dei-2024.xsd#dei_DocumentFiscalYearFocus"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_dei_EntityInformationLineItems_ac9f5aed-94ba-4cf6-8d91-ed8ebf40601b" xlink:to="loc_dei_DocumentFiscalYearFocus_33f6b6f6-ce30-45b0-af1b-13e5bb8a95aa" xlink:type="arc" order="26"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_dei_DocumentFiscalPeriodFocus_a78b8be2-d75c-4798-9729-4c7b8b419c14" xlink:href="https://xbrl.sec.gov/dei/2024/dei-2024.xsd#dei_DocumentFiscalPeriodFocus"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_dei_EntityInformationLineItems_ac9f5aed-94ba-4cf6-8d91-ed8ebf40601b" xlink:to="loc_dei_DocumentFiscalPeriodFocus_a78b8be2-d75c-4798-9729-4c7b8b419c14" xlink:type="arc" order="27"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_dei_CurrentFiscalYearEndDate_e1cb134b-4e3f-4d86-be68-6611d0a340d1" xlink:href="https://xbrl.sec.gov/dei/2024/dei-2024.xsd#dei_CurrentFiscalYearEndDate"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_dei_EntityInformationLineItems_ac9f5aed-94ba-4cf6-8d91-ed8ebf40601b" xlink:to="loc_dei_CurrentFiscalYearEndDate_e1cb134b-4e3f-4d86-be68-6611d0a340d1" xlink:type="arc" order="28"/>
  </link:definitionLink>
  <link:roleRef roleURI="http://www.afginc.com/role/ConsolidatedBalanceSheetUnaudited" xlink:type="simple" xlink:href="afg-20240930.xsd#ConsolidatedBalanceSheetUnaudited"/>
  <link:definitionLink xlink:role="http://www.afginc.com/role/ConsolidatedBalanceSheetUnaudited" xlink:type="extended">
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_StatementLineItems_f72e51d8-8089-4d3c-bdb2-15b560ec8c38" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_StatementLineItems"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_StatementTable_03621028-4b85-41d1-b5bc-42b86cecaa44" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_StatementTable"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/all" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_StatementLineItems_f72e51d8-8089-4d3c-bdb2-15b560ec8c38" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_StatementTable_03621028-4b85-41d1-b5bc-42b86cecaa44" xlink:type="arc" order="1" xbrldt:closed="true" xbrldt:contextElement="segment"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_srt_ProductOrServiceAxis_d4fb0ae2-376e-4d49-b858-67e8243281db" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/srt/2024/elts/srt-2024.xsd#srt_ProductOrServiceAxis"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/hypercube-dimension" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_StatementTable_03621028-4b85-41d1-b5bc-42b86cecaa44" xlink:to="loc_srt_ProductOrServiceAxis_d4fb0ae2-376e-4d49-b858-67e8243281db" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_srt_ProductsAndServicesDomain_d4fb0ae2-376e-4d49-b858-67e8243281db_default" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/srt/2024/elts/srt-2024.xsd#srt_ProductsAndServicesDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-default" xlink:from="loc_srt_ProductOrServiceAxis_d4fb0ae2-376e-4d49-b858-67e8243281db" xlink:to="loc_srt_ProductsAndServicesDomain_d4fb0ae2-376e-4d49-b858-67e8243281db_default" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_srt_ProductsAndServicesDomain_71aadc4d-1646-43f2-a326-74054f9da6ff" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/srt/2024/elts/srt-2024.xsd#srt_ProductsAndServicesDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-domain" xlink:from="loc_srt_ProductOrServiceAxis_d4fb0ae2-376e-4d49-b858-67e8243281db" xlink:to="loc_srt_ProductsAndServicesDomain_71aadc4d-1646-43f2-a326-74054f9da6ff" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_PropertyLiabilityAndCasualtyInsuranceSegmentMember_dd719bac-0a64-40c8-9cb2-c9d1ed46412f" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_PropertyLiabilityAndCasualtyInsuranceSegmentMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_srt_ProductsAndServicesDomain_71aadc4d-1646-43f2-a326-74054f9da6ff" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_PropertyLiabilityAndCasualtyInsuranceSegmentMember_dd719bac-0a64-40c8-9cb2-c9d1ed46412f" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_AssetsAbstract_d6a9d4d5-0b3f-487e-8fe5-ca3bce2cf807" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_AssetsAbstract"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_StatementLineItems_f72e51d8-8089-4d3c-bdb2-15b560ec8c38" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_AssetsAbstract_d6a9d4d5-0b3f-487e-8fe5-ca3bce2cf807" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_CashAndCashEquivalentsAtCarryingValue_e47aace6-c8e9-41e6-9b26-fecb5dcb99cc" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_CashAndCashEquivalentsAtCarryingValue"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_AssetsAbstract_d6a9d4d5-0b3f-487e-8fe5-ca3bce2cf807" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_CashAndCashEquivalentsAtCarryingValue_e47aace6-c8e9-41e6-9b26-fecb5dcb99cc" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_InvestmentsAbstract_b35b5507-15c4-4f68-a0f0-5e5d25780cbf" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_InvestmentsAbstract"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_AssetsAbstract_d6a9d4d5-0b3f-487e-8fe5-ca3bce2cf807" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_InvestmentsAbstract_b35b5507-15c4-4f68-a0f0-5e5d25780cbf" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtSecurities_a11a4206-4fa1-4ed5-8476-0fcc378a5db6" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtSecurities"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_InvestmentsAbstract_b35b5507-15c4-4f68-a0f0-5e5d25780cbf" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtSecurities_a11a4206-4fa1-4ed5-8476-0fcc378a5db6" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_TradingSecuritiesDebt_8ece7894-8908-40a5-af5a-e1424ea10c41" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_TradingSecuritiesDebt"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_InvestmentsAbstract_b35b5507-15c4-4f68-a0f0-5e5d25780cbf" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_TradingSecuritiesDebt_8ece7894-8908-40a5-af5a-e1424ea10c41" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_EquitySecuritiesFvNi_4a1ffbd6-cf08-4fdd-8e1c-ed4da240733d" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_EquitySecuritiesFvNi"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_InvestmentsAbstract_b35b5507-15c4-4f68-a0f0-5e5d25780cbf" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_EquitySecuritiesFvNi_4a1ffbd6-cf08-4fdd-8e1c-ed4da240733d" xlink:type="arc" order="3"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_EquityMethodInvestments_030c757b-fcb8-45aa-b911-0903b6296200" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_EquityMethodInvestments"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_InvestmentsAbstract_b35b5507-15c4-4f68-a0f0-5e5d25780cbf" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_EquityMethodInvestments_030c757b-fcb8-45aa-b911-0903b6296200" xlink:type="arc" order="4"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_MortgageLoansOnRealEstateCommercialAndConsumerNet_535707c8-e522-4e17-b837-d759ba8d061a" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_MortgageLoansOnRealEstateCommercialAndConsumerNet"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_InvestmentsAbstract_b35b5507-15c4-4f68-a0f0-5e5d25780cbf" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_MortgageLoansOnRealEstateCommercialAndConsumerNet_535707c8-e522-4e17-b837-d759ba8d061a" xlink:type="arc" order="5"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_OtherInvestments_9984c144-5986-44c6-b708-3a75723c0fbf" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_OtherInvestments"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_InvestmentsAbstract_b35b5507-15c4-4f68-a0f0-5e5d25780cbf" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_OtherInvestments_9984c144-5986-44c6-b708-3a75723c0fbf" xlink:type="arc" order="6"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_InvestmentsAndCash_7f4778aa-1807-4e9f-9c19-6ff375fc7a8d" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_InvestmentsAndCash"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_AssetsAbstract_d6a9d4d5-0b3f-487e-8fe5-ca3bce2cf807" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_InvestmentsAndCash_7f4778aa-1807-4e9f-9c19-6ff375fc7a8d" xlink:type="arc" order="3"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_ReinsuranceRecoverablesOnPaidAndUnpaidLosses_5c30bbdf-f184-4ced-a08f-edf994b01808" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_ReinsuranceRecoverablesOnPaidAndUnpaidLosses"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_AssetsAbstract_d6a9d4d5-0b3f-487e-8fe5-ca3bce2cf807" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_ReinsuranceRecoverablesOnPaidAndUnpaidLosses_5c30bbdf-f184-4ced-a08f-edf994b01808" xlink:type="arc" order="4"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_PrepaidReinsurancePremiums_2a96af3c-876c-4b43-b3b3-9aafafaa25a7" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_PrepaidReinsurancePremiums"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_AssetsAbstract_d6a9d4d5-0b3f-487e-8fe5-ca3bce2cf807" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_PrepaidReinsurancePremiums_2a96af3c-876c-4b43-b3b3-9aafafaa25a7" xlink:type="arc" order="5"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_PremiumsReceivableAtCarryingValue_b0be7a5c-2baf-4bb7-ace5-20dd90dacc52" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_PremiumsReceivableAtCarryingValue"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_AssetsAbstract_d6a9d4d5-0b3f-487e-8fe5-ca3bce2cf807" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_PremiumsReceivableAtCarryingValue_b0be7a5c-2baf-4bb7-ace5-20dd90dacc52" xlink:type="arc" order="6"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_DeferredPolicyAcquisitionCostsAndValueOfBusinessAcquired_663eeb00-50d3-4b96-8c8b-b5e266921ff2" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_DeferredPolicyAcquisitionCostsAndValueOfBusinessAcquired"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_AssetsAbstract_d6a9d4d5-0b3f-487e-8fe5-ca3bce2cf807" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_DeferredPolicyAcquisitionCostsAndValueOfBusinessAcquired_663eeb00-50d3-4b96-8c8b-b5e266921ff2" xlink:type="arc" order="7"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_VariableInterestEntityAssets_d52d3bde-c94b-4d39-9f28-f10fe6183f5a" xlink:href="afg-20240930.xsd#afg_VariableInterestEntityAssets"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_AssetsAbstract_d6a9d4d5-0b3f-487e-8fe5-ca3bce2cf807" xlink:to="loc_afg_VariableInterestEntityAssets_d52d3bde-c94b-4d39-9f28-f10fe6183f5a" xlink:type="arc" order="8"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_OtherReceivables_4e48b370-d637-420e-8a30-c52d0c3d667a" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_OtherReceivables"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_AssetsAbstract_d6a9d4d5-0b3f-487e-8fe5-ca3bce2cf807" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_OtherReceivables_4e48b370-d637-420e-8a30-c52d0c3d667a" xlink:type="arc" order="9"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_OtherAssets_0ba3004c-382c-439d-821d-9c23ab87c46a" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_OtherAssets"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_AssetsAbstract_d6a9d4d5-0b3f-487e-8fe5-ca3bce2cf807" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_OtherAssets_0ba3004c-382c-439d-821d-9c23ab87c46a" xlink:type="arc" order="10"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_Goodwill_633d15b5-f492-4f3b-b3e7-dbbf688bfc41" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_Goodwill"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_AssetsAbstract_d6a9d4d5-0b3f-487e-8fe5-ca3bce2cf807" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_Goodwill_633d15b5-f492-4f3b-b3e7-dbbf688bfc41" xlink:type="arc" order="11"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_Assets_e4515678-02bc-4198-b0cf-4b5f9b647ffa" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_Assets"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_AssetsAbstract_d6a9d4d5-0b3f-487e-8fe5-ca3bce2cf807" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_Assets_e4515678-02bc-4198-b0cf-4b5f9b647ffa" xlink:type="arc" order="12"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_LiabilitiesAndStockholdersEquityAbstract_82e2023d-abfc-4721-96d3-da7d872c76f5" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_LiabilitiesAndStockholdersEquityAbstract"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_StatementLineItems_f72e51d8-8089-4d3c-bdb2-15b560ec8c38" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_LiabilitiesAndStockholdersEquityAbstract_82e2023d-abfc-4721-96d3-da7d872c76f5" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_LiabilityForClaimsAndClaimsAdjustmentExpense_418f2144-1a78-4cb9-b4f4-b36763fcf60c" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_LiabilityForClaimsAndClaimsAdjustmentExpense"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_LiabilitiesAndStockholdersEquityAbstract_82e2023d-abfc-4721-96d3-da7d872c76f5" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_LiabilityForClaimsAndClaimsAdjustmentExpense_418f2144-1a78-4cb9-b4f4-b36763fcf60c" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_UnearnedPremiums_b9c67eef-e4eb-483b-9596-81acc93eb59a" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_UnearnedPremiums"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_LiabilitiesAndStockholdersEquityAbstract_82e2023d-abfc-4721-96d3-da7d872c76f5" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_UnearnedPremiums_b9c67eef-e4eb-483b-9596-81acc93eb59a" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_ReinsurancePayable_7821ec00-5bf0-4c7f-ac08-d768204813ff" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_ReinsurancePayable"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_LiabilitiesAndStockholdersEquityAbstract_82e2023d-abfc-4721-96d3-da7d872c76f5" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_ReinsurancePayable_7821ec00-5bf0-4c7f-ac08-d768204813ff" xlink:type="arc" order="3"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_VariableInterestEntityLiabilities_bbf0786a-29dd-48ab-a17c-669bca8e40a9" xlink:href="afg-20240930.xsd#afg_VariableInterestEntityLiabilities"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_LiabilitiesAndStockholdersEquityAbstract_82e2023d-abfc-4721-96d3-da7d872c76f5" xlink:to="loc_afg_VariableInterestEntityLiabilities_bbf0786a-29dd-48ab-a17c-669bca8e40a9" xlink:type="arc" order="4"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_LongTermDebt_9039f546-35ca-4262-91d8-e5374d7f6b35" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_LongTermDebt"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_LiabilitiesAndStockholdersEquityAbstract_82e2023d-abfc-4721-96d3-da7d872c76f5" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_LongTermDebt_9039f546-35ca-4262-91d8-e5374d7f6b35" xlink:type="arc" order="5"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_OtherLiabilities_0b211da5-e061-44f8-85c2-542547bae18e" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_OtherLiabilities"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_LiabilitiesAndStockholdersEquityAbstract_82e2023d-abfc-4721-96d3-da7d872c76f5" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_OtherLiabilities_0b211da5-e061-44f8-85c2-542547bae18e" xlink:type="arc" order="6"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_Liabilities_47a38642-1ad6-4b5b-ba52-be082c9eec68" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_Liabilities"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_LiabilitiesAndStockholdersEquityAbstract_82e2023d-abfc-4721-96d3-da7d872c76f5" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_Liabilities_47a38642-1ad6-4b5b-ba52-be082c9eec68" xlink:type="arc" order="7"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_StockholdersEquityAbstract_551e78c8-806f-4cc7-ba4c-5e5f54978b1e" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_StockholdersEquityAbstract"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_LiabilitiesAndStockholdersEquityAbstract_82e2023d-abfc-4721-96d3-da7d872c76f5" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_StockholdersEquityAbstract_551e78c8-806f-4cc7-ba4c-5e5f54978b1e" xlink:type="arc" order="8"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_CommonStockValue_98b3f962-fbc9-4f8e-8c5f-aff7443d9f70" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_CommonStockValue"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_StockholdersEquityAbstract_551e78c8-806f-4cc7-ba4c-5e5f54978b1e" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_CommonStockValue_98b3f962-fbc9-4f8e-8c5f-aff7443d9f70" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_AdditionalPaidInCapitalCommonStock_3a7fd8e1-0c9e-4249-a0ef-b32cf004d55c" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_AdditionalPaidInCapitalCommonStock"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_StockholdersEquityAbstract_551e78c8-806f-4cc7-ba4c-5e5f54978b1e" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_AdditionalPaidInCapitalCommonStock_3a7fd8e1-0c9e-4249-a0ef-b32cf004d55c" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_RetainedEarningsUnappropriated_1ce445ef-6c87-4454-8aa2-caf6d37754e6" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_RetainedEarningsUnappropriated"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_StockholdersEquityAbstract_551e78c8-806f-4cc7-ba4c-5e5f54978b1e" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_RetainedEarningsUnappropriated_1ce445ef-6c87-4454-8aa2-caf6d37754e6" xlink:type="arc" order="3"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_AccumulatedOtherComprehensiveIncomeLossNetOfTax_40d2135d-a5e3-4245-acfa-d7cf9a08051a" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_AccumulatedOtherComprehensiveIncomeLossNetOfTax"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_StockholdersEquityAbstract_551e78c8-806f-4cc7-ba4c-5e5f54978b1e" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_AccumulatedOtherComprehensiveIncomeLossNetOfTax_40d2135d-a5e3-4245-acfa-d7cf9a08051a" xlink:type="arc" order="4"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_StockholdersEquity_a4aeac4c-c9e8-43d5-ad57-599fb4df91be" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_StockholdersEquity"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_StockholdersEquityAbstract_551e78c8-806f-4cc7-ba4c-5e5f54978b1e" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_StockholdersEquity_a4aeac4c-c9e8-43d5-ad57-599fb4df91be" xlink:type="arc" order="5"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_LiabilitiesAndStockholdersEquity_6d8be3e6-eb82-421c-b261-79fa19d29954" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_LiabilitiesAndStockholdersEquity"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_LiabilitiesAndStockholdersEquityAbstract_82e2023d-abfc-4721-96d3-da7d872c76f5" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_LiabilitiesAndStockholdersEquity_6d8be3e6-eb82-421c-b261-79fa19d29954" xlink:type="arc" order="9"/>
  </link:definitionLink>
  <link:roleRef roleURI="http://www.afginc.com/role/ConsolidatedStatementofEarningsUnaudited" xlink:type="simple" xlink:href="afg-20240930.xsd#ConsolidatedStatementofEarningsUnaudited"/>
  <link:definitionLink xlink:role="http://www.afginc.com/role/ConsolidatedStatementofEarningsUnaudited" xlink:type="extended">
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_StatementLineItems_3dc1bc2a-9897-408e-99ba-9f33f759daf2" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_StatementLineItems"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_StatementTable_1026bbe0-ed89-474e-88ae-46ef1cbe7799" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_StatementTable"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/all" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_StatementLineItems_3dc1bc2a-9897-408e-99ba-9f33f759daf2" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_StatementTable_1026bbe0-ed89-474e-88ae-46ef1cbe7799" xlink:type="arc" order="1" xbrldt:closed="true" xbrldt:contextElement="segment"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_srt_ProductOrServiceAxis_630749d5-a630-48e2-8376-d75489e7c6fb" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/srt/2024/elts/srt-2024.xsd#srt_ProductOrServiceAxis"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/hypercube-dimension" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_StatementTable_1026bbe0-ed89-474e-88ae-46ef1cbe7799" xlink:to="loc_srt_ProductOrServiceAxis_630749d5-a630-48e2-8376-d75489e7c6fb" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_srt_ProductsAndServicesDomain_630749d5-a630-48e2-8376-d75489e7c6fb_default" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/srt/2024/elts/srt-2024.xsd#srt_ProductsAndServicesDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-default" xlink:from="loc_srt_ProductOrServiceAxis_630749d5-a630-48e2-8376-d75489e7c6fb" xlink:to="loc_srt_ProductsAndServicesDomain_630749d5-a630-48e2-8376-d75489e7c6fb_default" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_srt_ProductsAndServicesDomain_047568ac-529c-468c-95f6-58786e47e290" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/srt/2024/elts/srt-2024.xsd#srt_ProductsAndServicesDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-domain" xlink:from="loc_srt_ProductOrServiceAxis_630749d5-a630-48e2-8376-d75489e7c6fb" xlink:to="loc_srt_ProductsAndServicesDomain_047568ac-529c-468c-95f6-58786e47e290" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_PropertyLiabilityAndCasualtyInsuranceSegmentMember_4d59a93c-75f1-4b58-a3ef-70f6466cefdd" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_PropertyLiabilityAndCasualtyInsuranceSegmentMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_srt_ProductsAndServicesDomain_047568ac-529c-468c-95f6-58786e47e290" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_PropertyLiabilityAndCasualtyInsuranceSegmentMember_4d59a93c-75f1-4b58-a3ef-70f6466cefdd" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_RevenuesAbstract_acdb302a-3176-41f6-b64d-cb26b7bc8cf2" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_RevenuesAbstract"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_StatementLineItems_3dc1bc2a-9897-408e-99ba-9f33f759daf2" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_RevenuesAbstract_acdb302a-3176-41f6-b64d-cb26b7bc8cf2" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_PremiumsEarnedNetPropertyAndCasualty_22996021-ad3a-41fe-8f98-442458523d53" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_PremiumsEarnedNetPropertyAndCasualty"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_RevenuesAbstract_acdb302a-3176-41f6-b64d-cb26b7bc8cf2" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_PremiumsEarnedNetPropertyAndCasualty_22996021-ad3a-41fe-8f98-442458523d53" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_NetInvestmentIncome_b7247f54-62a5-4ad6-9437-8b06300a48e3" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_NetInvestmentIncome"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_RevenuesAbstract_acdb302a-3176-41f6-b64d-cb26b7bc8cf2" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_NetInvestmentIncome_b7247f54-62a5-4ad6-9437-8b06300a48e3" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_DebtAndEquitySecuritiesRealizedGainLoss_7c9b74f5-e3cd-44f9-bf75-9f9483db3f0f" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_DebtAndEquitySecuritiesRealizedGainLoss"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_RevenuesAbstract_acdb302a-3176-41f6-b64d-cb26b7bc8cf2" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_DebtAndEquitySecuritiesRealizedGainLoss_7c9b74f5-e3cd-44f9-bf75-9f9483db3f0f" xlink:type="arc" order="3"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_RealizedGainsLossesOnSubsidiaries_e974509a-465b-4388-a0d6-d7379170b984" xlink:href="afg-20240930.xsd#afg_RealizedGainsLossesOnSubsidiaries"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_RevenuesAbstract_acdb302a-3176-41f6-b64d-cb26b7bc8cf2" xlink:to="loc_afg_RealizedGainsLossesOnSubsidiaries_e974509a-465b-4388-a0d6-d7379170b984" xlink:type="arc" order="4"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_IncomeLossOfManagedInvestmentEntitiesAbstract_17cbcd81-0880-4b89-b550-c5247ab2cb61" xlink:href="afg-20240930.xsd#afg_IncomeLossOfManagedInvestmentEntitiesAbstract"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_RevenuesAbstract_acdb302a-3176-41f6-b64d-cb26b7bc8cf2" xlink:to="loc_afg_IncomeLossOfManagedInvestmentEntitiesAbstract_17cbcd81-0880-4b89-b550-c5247ab2cb61" xlink:type="arc" order="5"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_InvestmentIncomeOfManagedInvestmentEntities_0d35a80a-95b5-4310-ba3c-fd1ad997e3a7" xlink:href="afg-20240930.xsd#afg_InvestmentIncomeOfManagedInvestmentEntities"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_afg_IncomeLossOfManagedInvestmentEntitiesAbstract_17cbcd81-0880-4b89-b550-c5247ab2cb61" xlink:to="loc_afg_InvestmentIncomeOfManagedInvestmentEntities_0d35a80a-95b5-4310-ba3c-fd1ad997e3a7" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_GainLossonChangeinFairValueofAssetsandLiabilitiesofManagedInvestmentEntities_56e41419-d53d-447c-938a-77f3309f417d" xlink:href="afg-20240930.xsd#afg_GainLossonChangeinFairValueofAssetsandLiabilitiesofManagedInvestmentEntities"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_afg_IncomeLossOfManagedInvestmentEntitiesAbstract_17cbcd81-0880-4b89-b550-c5247ab2cb61" xlink:to="loc_afg_GainLossonChangeinFairValueofAssetsandLiabilitiesofManagedInvestmentEntities_56e41419-d53d-447c-938a-77f3309f417d" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_OtherIncome_4f495695-0e51-4e45-980b-ede543b243e0" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_OtherIncome"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_RevenuesAbstract_acdb302a-3176-41f6-b64d-cb26b7bc8cf2" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_OtherIncome_4f495695-0e51-4e45-980b-ede543b243e0" xlink:type="arc" order="6"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_Revenues_e2a5f8f6-199e-4a31-83ee-d97dfd7810fc" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_Revenues"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_RevenuesAbstract_acdb302a-3176-41f6-b64d-cb26b7bc8cf2" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_Revenues_e2a5f8f6-199e-4a31-83ee-d97dfd7810fc" xlink:type="arc" order="7"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_BenefitsLossesAndExpensesAbstract_efe26469-205f-4e9c-9c29-71f83905c499" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_BenefitsLossesAndExpensesAbstract"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_StatementLineItems_3dc1bc2a-9897-408e-99ba-9f33f759daf2" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_BenefitsLossesAndExpensesAbstract_efe26469-205f-4e9c-9c29-71f83905c499" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_PropertyAndCasualtyInsuranceAbstract_73f73744-077f-4c1a-97cd-e2330db4650a" xlink:href="afg-20240930.xsd#afg_PropertyAndCasualtyInsuranceAbstract"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_BenefitsLossesAndExpensesAbstract_efe26469-205f-4e9c-9c29-71f83905c499" xlink:to="loc_afg_PropertyAndCasualtyInsuranceAbstract_73f73744-077f-4c1a-97cd-e2330db4650a" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_PolicyholderBenefitsAndClaimsIncurredNet_266ddf85-fd7b-40e8-a0f3-f3b566b89225" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_PolicyholderBenefitsAndClaimsIncurredNet"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_afg_PropertyAndCasualtyInsuranceAbstract_73f73744-077f-4c1a-97cd-e2330db4650a" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_PolicyholderBenefitsAndClaimsIncurredNet_266ddf85-fd7b-40e8-a0f3-f3b566b89225" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_SellingGeneralAndAdministrativeExpense_16cce822-8ff3-477a-81a8-0428d5fdc66b" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_SellingGeneralAndAdministrativeExpense"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_afg_PropertyAndCasualtyInsuranceAbstract_73f73744-077f-4c1a-97cd-e2330db4650a" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_SellingGeneralAndAdministrativeExpense_16cce822-8ff3-477a-81a8-0428d5fdc66b" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_InterestExpense_4cfdd457-3e56-4e9e-bf65-91fca8f79463" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_InterestExpense"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_BenefitsLossesAndExpensesAbstract_efe26469-205f-4e9c-9c29-71f83905c499" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_InterestExpense_4cfdd457-3e56-4e9e-bf65-91fca8f79463" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_ExpensesOfManagedInvestmentEntities_a79710c6-78a5-4dda-a1df-652afbc2de9d" xlink:href="afg-20240930.xsd#afg_ExpensesOfManagedInvestmentEntities"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_BenefitsLossesAndExpensesAbstract_efe26469-205f-4e9c-9c29-71f83905c499" xlink:to="loc_afg_ExpensesOfManagedInvestmentEntities_a79710c6-78a5-4dda-a1df-652afbc2de9d" xlink:type="arc" order="3"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_OtherCostAndExpenseOperating_3424189f-9bb5-4b53-a227-faa963a554c9" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_OtherCostAndExpenseOperating"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_BenefitsLossesAndExpensesAbstract_efe26469-205f-4e9c-9c29-71f83905c499" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_OtherCostAndExpenseOperating_3424189f-9bb5-4b53-a227-faa963a554c9" xlink:type="arc" order="4"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_BenefitsLossesAndExpenses_60ce3fca-6c60-4714-b946-de59ec85eb96" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_BenefitsLossesAndExpenses"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_BenefitsLossesAndExpensesAbstract_efe26469-205f-4e9c-9c29-71f83905c499" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_BenefitsLossesAndExpenses_60ce3fca-6c60-4714-b946-de59ec85eb96" xlink:type="arc" order="5"/>
  </link:definitionLink>
  <link:roleRef roleURI="http://www.afginc.com/role/ConsolidatedStatementofChangesinEquityUnaudited" xlink:type="simple" xlink:href="afg-20240930.xsd#ConsolidatedStatementofChangesinEquityUnaudited"/>
  <link:definitionLink xlink:role="http://www.afginc.com/role/ConsolidatedStatementofChangesinEquityUnaudited" xlink:type="extended">
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_StatementLineItems_8d751701-59ce-472d-a15e-f88958a9fad0" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_StatementLineItems"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_StatementTable_675744a3-9699-4883-b553-b8ef152eda11" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_StatementTable"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/all" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_StatementLineItems_8d751701-59ce-472d-a15e-f88958a9fad0" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_StatementTable_675744a3-9699-4883-b553-b8ef152eda11" xlink:type="arc" order="1" xbrldt:closed="true" xbrldt:contextElement="segment"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_StatementEquityComponentsAxis_17621599-78df-4a1c-b592-89cc19d3ca05" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_StatementEquityComponentsAxis"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/hypercube-dimension" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_StatementTable_675744a3-9699-4883-b553-b8ef152eda11" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_StatementEquityComponentsAxis_17621599-78df-4a1c-b592-89cc19d3ca05" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_EquityComponentDomain_17621599-78df-4a1c-b592-89cc19d3ca05_default" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_EquityComponentDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-default" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_StatementEquityComponentsAxis_17621599-78df-4a1c-b592-89cc19d3ca05" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_EquityComponentDomain_17621599-78df-4a1c-b592-89cc19d3ca05_default" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_EquityComponentDomain_dd62bb7c-110b-4a8f-9fed-1fce3cf2b3a2" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_EquityComponentDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-domain" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_StatementEquityComponentsAxis_17621599-78df-4a1c-b592-89cc19d3ca05" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_EquityComponentDomain_dd62bb7c-110b-4a8f-9fed-1fce3cf2b3a2" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_ParentMember_688e59a1-aebb-4f53-8335-2789f60a5c79" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_ParentMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_EquityComponentDomain_dd62bb7c-110b-4a8f-9fed-1fce3cf2b3a2" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_ParentMember_688e59a1-aebb-4f53-8335-2789f60a5c79" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_CommonStockMember_5b6efcba-b5f5-4602-a3ef-494553f7a3d2" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_CommonStockMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ParentMember_688e59a1-aebb-4f53-8335-2789f60a5c79" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_CommonStockMember_5b6efcba-b5f5-4602-a3ef-494553f7a3d2" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_CommonStockIncludingAdditionalPaidInCapitalMember_bf6a46be-1920-4e2a-9e27-934902283432" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_CommonStockIncludingAdditionalPaidInCapitalMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ParentMember_688e59a1-aebb-4f53-8335-2789f60a5c79" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_CommonStockIncludingAdditionalPaidInCapitalMember_bf6a46be-1920-4e2a-9e27-934902283432" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_RetainedEarningsMember_e036d213-3bba-44fe-b90e-a32841bd3390" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_RetainedEarningsMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ParentMember_688e59a1-aebb-4f53-8335-2789f60a5c79" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_RetainedEarningsMember_e036d213-3bba-44fe-b90e-a32841bd3390" xlink:type="arc" order="3"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_AccumulatedOtherComprehensiveIncomeMember_d2a8ef1d-3bda-49b7-a7f9-0d9ca8a1ab9c" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_AccumulatedOtherComprehensiveIncomeMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ParentMember_688e59a1-aebb-4f53-8335-2789f60a5c79" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_AccumulatedOtherComprehensiveIncomeMember_d2a8ef1d-3bda-49b7-a7f9-0d9ca8a1ab9c" xlink:type="arc" order="4"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_IncreaseDecreaseInStockholdersEquityRollForward_e51f3fb5-4861-4817-afe9-052a6669c894" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_IncreaseDecreaseInStockholdersEquityRollForward"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_StatementLineItems_8d751701-59ce-472d-a15e-f88958a9fad0" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_IncreaseDecreaseInStockholdersEquityRollForward_e51f3fb5-4861-4817-afe9-052a6669c894" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_CommonStockSharesOutstanding_832c0fdb-5f1c-4594-8add-da4ac79c40a1" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_CommonStockSharesOutstanding"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_IncreaseDecreaseInStockholdersEquityRollForward_e51f3fb5-4861-4817-afe9-052a6669c894" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_CommonStockSharesOutstanding_832c0fdb-5f1c-4594-8add-da4ac79c40a1" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_StockholdersEquityIncludingPortionAttributableToNoncontrollingInterest_8f745cd4-3477-4608-afd9-6130c11c2aae" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_StockholdersEquityIncludingPortionAttributableToNoncontrollingInterest"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_IncreaseDecreaseInStockholdersEquityRollForward_e51f3fb5-4861-4817-afe9-052a6669c894" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_StockholdersEquityIncludingPortionAttributableToNoncontrollingInterest_8f745cd4-3477-4608-afd9-6130c11c2aae" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_NetIncomeLoss_9dd028f4-fd8a-4292-a836-81086bab1a8d" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_NetIncomeLoss"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_IncreaseDecreaseInStockholdersEquityRollForward_e51f3fb5-4861-4817-afe9-052a6669c894" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_NetIncomeLoss_9dd028f4-fd8a-4292-a836-81086bab1a8d" xlink:type="arc" order="3"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_OtherComprehensiveIncomeLossNetOfTaxPortionAttributableToParent_2ad0e15e-fa13-49f5-9bd6-68cc5eeea105" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_OtherComprehensiveIncomeLossNetOfTaxPortionAttributableToParent"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_IncreaseDecreaseInStockholdersEquityRollForward_e51f3fb5-4861-4817-afe9-052a6669c894" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_OtherComprehensiveIncomeLossNetOfTaxPortionAttributableToParent_2ad0e15e-fa13-49f5-9bd6-68cc5eeea105" xlink:type="arc" order="4"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_DividendsCommonStockCash_9e69e30f-23c6-49d3-ad74-bf20a5c4d5d7" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_DividendsCommonStockCash"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_IncreaseDecreaseInStockholdersEquityRollForward_e51f3fb5-4861-4817-afe9-052a6669c894" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_DividendsCommonStockCash_9e69e30f-23c6-49d3-ad74-bf20a5c4d5d7" xlink:type="arc" order="5"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_SharesIssuedAbstract_784cd5ac-ebac-4bb5-be49-3ec4fcec46d8" xlink:href="afg-20240930.xsd#afg_SharesIssuedAbstract"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_IncreaseDecreaseInStockholdersEquityRollForward_e51f3fb5-4861-4817-afe9-052a6669c894" xlink:to="loc_afg_SharesIssuedAbstract_784cd5ac-ebac-4bb5-be49-3ec4fcec46d8" xlink:type="arc" order="6"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_StockIssuedDuringPeriodSharesStockOptionsExercised_4d1a6dd9-0afb-4fb6-a75d-a6c4fe522938" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_StockIssuedDuringPeriodSharesStockOptionsExercised"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_afg_SharesIssuedAbstract_784cd5ac-ebac-4bb5-be49-3ec4fcec46d8" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_StockIssuedDuringPeriodSharesStockOptionsExercised_4d1a6dd9-0afb-4fb6-a75d-a6c4fe522938" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_StockIssuedDuringPeriodValueStockOptionsExercised_9df97ec4-6879-4a1f-a021-c907ef108857" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_StockIssuedDuringPeriodValueStockOptionsExercised"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_afg_SharesIssuedAbstract_784cd5ac-ebac-4bb5-be49-3ec4fcec46d8" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_StockIssuedDuringPeriodValueStockOptionsExercised_9df97ec4-6879-4a1f-a021-c907ef108857" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_StockIssuedDuringPeriodSharesRestrictedStockAwardGross_1be35873-8b0e-42eb-a548-e4c37e8b0f90" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_StockIssuedDuringPeriodSharesRestrictedStockAwardGross"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_afg_SharesIssuedAbstract_784cd5ac-ebac-4bb5-be49-3ec4fcec46d8" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_StockIssuedDuringPeriodSharesRestrictedStockAwardGross_1be35873-8b0e-42eb-a548-e4c37e8b0f90" xlink:type="arc" order="3"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_StockIssuedDuringPeriodSharesEmployeeBenefitPlan_cf0e69ba-2eeb-4027-934f-32a321f331d7" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_StockIssuedDuringPeriodSharesEmployeeBenefitPlan"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_afg_SharesIssuedAbstract_784cd5ac-ebac-4bb5-be49-3ec4fcec46d8" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_StockIssuedDuringPeriodSharesEmployeeBenefitPlan_cf0e69ba-2eeb-4027-934f-32a321f331d7" xlink:type="arc" order="4"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_StockIssuedDuringPeriodValueEmployeeBenefitPlan_e881de9c-45e3-48a5-8629-c7e0c08393a5" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_StockIssuedDuringPeriodValueEmployeeBenefitPlan"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_afg_SharesIssuedAbstract_784cd5ac-ebac-4bb5-be49-3ec4fcec46d8" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_StockIssuedDuringPeriodValueEmployeeBenefitPlan_e881de9c-45e3-48a5-8629-c7e0c08393a5" xlink:type="arc" order="5"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_StockIssuedDuringPeriodSharesDividendReinvestmentPlan_098858ad-c19d-47c5-a97c-1d26767cf1b3" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_StockIssuedDuringPeriodSharesDividendReinvestmentPlan"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_afg_SharesIssuedAbstract_784cd5ac-ebac-4bb5-be49-3ec4fcec46d8" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_StockIssuedDuringPeriodSharesDividendReinvestmentPlan_098858ad-c19d-47c5-a97c-1d26767cf1b3" xlink:type="arc" order="6"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_StockIssuedDuringPeriodValueDividendReinvestmentPlan_0ece5c3f-63f8-4ed7-833c-f8c6938157ef" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_StockIssuedDuringPeriodValueDividendReinvestmentPlan"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_afg_SharesIssuedAbstract_784cd5ac-ebac-4bb5-be49-3ec4fcec46d8" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_StockIssuedDuringPeriodValueDividendReinvestmentPlan_0ece5c3f-63f8-4ed7-833c-f8c6938157ef" xlink:type="arc" order="7"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_AdjustmentsToAdditionalPaidInCapitalSharebasedCompensationRequisiteServicePeriodRecognitionValue_b1a296a9-3c5a-4526-934f-ca7a61177e04" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_AdjustmentsToAdditionalPaidInCapitalSharebasedCompensationRequisiteServicePeriodRecognitionValue"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_IncreaseDecreaseInStockholdersEquityRollForward_e51f3fb5-4861-4817-afe9-052a6669c894" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_AdjustmentsToAdditionalPaidInCapitalSharebasedCompensationRequisiteServicePeriodRecognitionValue_b1a296a9-3c5a-4526-934f-ca7a61177e04" xlink:type="arc" order="7"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_StockRepurchasedAndRetiredDuringPeriodShares_6a915dbd-c13a-4bd4-8364-6cc25a5ee310" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_StockRepurchasedAndRetiredDuringPeriodShares"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_IncreaseDecreaseInStockholdersEquityRollForward_e51f3fb5-4861-4817-afe9-052a6669c894" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_StockRepurchasedAndRetiredDuringPeriodShares_6a915dbd-c13a-4bd4-8364-6cc25a5ee310" xlink:type="arc" order="8"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_StockRepurchasedAndRetiredDuringPeriodValue_b8ccbf31-2f38-4417-932a-2a1ee82e6067" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_StockRepurchasedAndRetiredDuringPeriodValue"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_IncreaseDecreaseInStockholdersEquityRollForward_e51f3fb5-4861-4817-afe9-052a6669c894" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_StockRepurchasedAndRetiredDuringPeriodValue_b8ccbf31-2f38-4417-932a-2a1ee82e6067" xlink:type="arc" order="9"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_StockRepurchasedSharesExchangedInStockCompensationPlansShares_06be6b5d-a870-4971-a925-a7b4be830718" xlink:href="afg-20240930.xsd#afg_StockRepurchasedSharesExchangedInStockCompensationPlansShares"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_IncreaseDecreaseInStockholdersEquityRollForward_e51f3fb5-4861-4817-afe9-052a6669c894" xlink:to="loc_afg_StockRepurchasedSharesExchangedInStockCompensationPlansShares_06be6b5d-a870-4971-a925-a7b4be830718" xlink:type="arc" order="10"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_StockRepurchasedSharesExchangedInStockCompensationPlansValue_38733e0f-a583-4564-9aec-ce95d357a44a" xlink:href="afg-20240930.xsd#afg_StockRepurchasedSharesExchangedInStockCompensationPlansValue"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_IncreaseDecreaseInStockholdersEquityRollForward_e51f3fb5-4861-4817-afe9-052a6669c894" xlink:to="loc_afg_StockRepurchasedSharesExchangedInStockCompensationPlansValue_38733e0f-a583-4564-9aec-ce95d357a44a" xlink:type="arc" order="11"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_StockIssuedDuringPeriodSharesRestrictedStockAwardForfeited_5101e3a6-c8d7-48f4-9bd9-4177a01ec799" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_StockIssuedDuringPeriodSharesRestrictedStockAwardForfeited"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_IncreaseDecreaseInStockholdersEquityRollForward_e51f3fb5-4861-4817-afe9-052a6669c894" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_StockIssuedDuringPeriodSharesRestrictedStockAwardForfeited_5101e3a6-c8d7-48f4-9bd9-4177a01ec799" xlink:type="arc" order="12"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_CommonStockSharesOutstanding_34e38a70-1649-4070-b8e2-4af9b00f2dc8" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_CommonStockSharesOutstanding"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_StockholdersEquityIncludingPortionAttributableToNoncontrollingInterest_a62a388a-189e-4b94-96de-f81df7882ef7" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_StockholdersEquityIncludingPortionAttributableToNoncontrollingInterest"/>
  </link:definitionLink>
  <link:roleRef roleURI="http://www.afginc.com/role/AccountingPoliciesNarrativeDetails" xlink:type="simple" xlink:href="afg-20240930.xsd#AccountingPoliciesNarrativeDetails"/>
  <link:definitionLink xlink:role="http://www.afginc.com/role/AccountingPoliciesNarrativeDetails" xlink:type="extended">
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_VariableInterestEntityLineItems_d3f8b8d2-1b3f-44e4-ba97-4bb2b3539fb5" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_VariableInterestEntityLineItems"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfVariableInterestEntitiesTable_24fefabc-c822-47eb-9f89-a8dce07b1a9b" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_ScheduleOfVariableInterestEntitiesTable"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/all" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_VariableInterestEntityLineItems_d3f8b8d2-1b3f-44e4-ba97-4bb2b3539fb5" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfVariableInterestEntitiesTable_24fefabc-c822-47eb-9f89-a8dce07b1a9b" xlink:type="arc" order="1" xbrldt:closed="true" xbrldt:contextElement="segment"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesAxis_5ce48fc1-f4ad-40bd-a990-0077f810b763" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/srt/2024/elts/srt-2024.xsd#srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesAxis"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/hypercube-dimension" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfVariableInterestEntitiesTable_24fefabc-c822-47eb-9f89-a8dce07b1a9b" xlink:to="loc_srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesAxis_5ce48fc1-f4ad-40bd-a990-0077f810b763" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesDomain_5ce48fc1-f4ad-40bd-a990-0077f810b763_default" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/srt/2024/elts/srt-2024.xsd#srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-default" xlink:from="loc_srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesAxis_5ce48fc1-f4ad-40bd-a990-0077f810b763" xlink:to="loc_srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesDomain_5ce48fc1-f4ad-40bd-a990-0077f810b763_default" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesDomain_4801e687-aef1-4802-87ed-94bb81d6f1ac" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/srt/2024/elts/srt-2024.xsd#srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-domain" xlink:from="loc_srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesAxis_5ce48fc1-f4ad-40bd-a990-0077f810b763" xlink:to="loc_srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesDomain_4801e687-aef1-4802-87ed-94bb81d6f1ac" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_NewCollateralizedLoanObligationTemporaryWarehousingEntitiesMember_af35db4e-9430-44a8-8ae8-fc95bd93a24e" xlink:href="afg-20240930.xsd#afg_NewCollateralizedLoanObligationTemporaryWarehousingEntitiesMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesDomain_4801e687-aef1-4802-87ed-94bb81d6f1ac" xlink:to="loc_afg_NewCollateralizedLoanObligationTemporaryWarehousingEntitiesMember_af35db4e-9430-44a8-8ae8-fc95bd93a24e" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_VariableInterestEntityAssets_258eb523-8b8e-43a7-8911-233dbb5bc836" xlink:href="afg-20240930.xsd#afg_VariableInterestEntityAssets"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_VariableInterestEntityLineItems_d3f8b8d2-1b3f-44e4-ba97-4bb2b3539fb5" xlink:to="loc_afg_VariableInterestEntityAssets_258eb523-8b8e-43a7-8911-233dbb5bc836" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_VariableInterestEntityLiabilities_5678c8d1-b373-49a6-83f5-0c7658a5420f" xlink:href="afg-20240930.xsd#afg_VariableInterestEntityLiabilities"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_VariableInterestEntityLineItems_d3f8b8d2-1b3f-44e4-ba97-4bb2b3539fb5" xlink:to="loc_afg_VariableInterestEntityLiabilities_5678c8d1-b373-49a6-83f5-0c7658a5420f" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_OperatingLeaseLiability_cb106832-82df-4fec-8345-b7c703cb3c45" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_OperatingLeaseLiability"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_VariableInterestEntityLineItems_d3f8b8d2-1b3f-44e4-ba97-4bb2b3539fb5" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_OperatingLeaseLiability_cb106832-82df-4fec-8345-b7c703cb3c45" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_OperatingLeaseLiabilityCurrentStatementOfFinancialPositionExtensibleList_494d68bd-b483-423e-b126-56a61e029afa" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_OperatingLeaseLiabilityCurrentStatementOfFinancialPositionExtensibleList"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_VariableInterestEntityLineItems_d3f8b8d2-1b3f-44e4-ba97-4bb2b3539fb5" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_OperatingLeaseLiabilityCurrentStatementOfFinancialPositionExtensibleList_494d68bd-b483-423e-b126-56a61e029afa" xlink:type="arc" order="3"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_OperatingLeaseRightOfUseAsset_31ddc5f8-1dda-40ed-9e58-d3e5eee58bd7" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_OperatingLeaseRightOfUseAsset"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_VariableInterestEntityLineItems_d3f8b8d2-1b3f-44e4-ba97-4bb2b3539fb5" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_OperatingLeaseRightOfUseAsset_31ddc5f8-1dda-40ed-9e58-d3e5eee58bd7" xlink:type="arc" order="4"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_OperatingLeaseRightOfUseAssetStatementOfFinancialPositionExtensibleList_e2f01bd6-7961-4f34-a346-a613ae445199" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_OperatingLeaseRightOfUseAssetStatementOfFinancialPositionExtensibleList"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_VariableInterestEntityLineItems_d3f8b8d2-1b3f-44e4-ba97-4bb2b3539fb5" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_OperatingLeaseRightOfUseAssetStatementOfFinancialPositionExtensibleList_e2f01bd6-7961-4f34-a346-a613ae445199" xlink:type="arc" order="5"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_IncrementalCommonSharesAttributableToShareBasedPaymentArrangements_afa1da08-e390-422d-84bb-98cda671422d" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_IncrementalCommonSharesAttributableToShareBasedPaymentArrangements"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_VariableInterestEntityLineItems_d3f8b8d2-1b3f-44e4-ba97-4bb2b3539fb5" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_IncrementalCommonSharesAttributableToShareBasedPaymentArrangements_afa1da08-e390-422d-84bb-98cda671422d" xlink:type="arc" order="6"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_AntidilutiveSecuritiesExcludedFromComputationOfEarningsPerShareAmount_09341acd-19db-43e5-9a8c-607ab8bb2d41" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_AntidilutiveSecuritiesExcludedFromComputationOfEarningsPerShareAmount"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_VariableInterestEntityLineItems_d3f8b8d2-1b3f-44e4-ba97-4bb2b3539fb5" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_AntidilutiveSecuritiesExcludedFromComputationOfEarningsPerShareAmount_09341acd-19db-43e5-9a8c-607ab8bb2d41" xlink:type="arc" order="7"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_MaturityPeriodOfShortTermInvestmentMaximum_f4f8d596-7273-48ad-b4c7-26eb25b45d29" xlink:href="afg-20240930.xsd#afg_MaturityPeriodOfShortTermInvestmentMaximum"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_VariableInterestEntityLineItems_d3f8b8d2-1b3f-44e4-ba97-4bb2b3539fb5" xlink:to="loc_afg_MaturityPeriodOfShortTermInvestmentMaximum_f4f8d596-7273-48ad-b4c7-26eb25b45d29" xlink:type="arc" order="8"/>
  </link:definitionLink>
  <link:roleRef roleURI="http://www.afginc.com/role/AcquisitionofBusinessNarrativeDetails" xlink:type="simple" xlink:href="afg-20240930.xsd#AcquisitionofBusinessNarrativeDetails"/>
  <link:definitionLink xlink:role="http://www.afginc.com/role/AcquisitionofBusinessNarrativeDetails" xlink:type="extended">
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionLineItems_85409259-55e2-4797-8a9e-57bb9292ed68" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionLineItems"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfBusinessAcquisitionsByAcquisitionTable_d7b0bd78-729a-47d6-8fd5-e2df741886aa" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_ScheduleOfBusinessAcquisitionsByAcquisitionTable"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/all" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionLineItems_85409259-55e2-4797-8a9e-57bb9292ed68" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfBusinessAcquisitionsByAcquisitionTable_d7b0bd78-729a-47d6-8fd5-e2df741886aa" xlink:type="arc" order="1" xbrldt:closed="true" xbrldt:contextElement="segment"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionAxis_3ce80444-1d1a-41dd-861c-2a3c683e824e" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionAxis"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/hypercube-dimension" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfBusinessAcquisitionsByAcquisitionTable_d7b0bd78-729a-47d6-8fd5-e2df741886aa" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionAxis_3ce80444-1d1a-41dd-861c-2a3c683e824e" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionAcquireeDomain_3ce80444-1d1a-41dd-861c-2a3c683e824e_default" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionAcquireeDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-default" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionAxis_3ce80444-1d1a-41dd-861c-2a3c683e824e" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionAcquireeDomain_3ce80444-1d1a-41dd-861c-2a3c683e824e_default" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionAcquireeDomain_0c206987-3749-46eb-9f96-b40e78937714" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionAcquireeDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-domain" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionAxis_3ce80444-1d1a-41dd-861c-2a3c683e824e" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionAcquireeDomain_0c206987-3749-46eb-9f96-b40e78937714" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_CropRiskServicesMember_0595b7c2-7ffe-4cf9-ae05-606ebc7919b9" xlink:href="afg-20240930.xsd#afg_CropRiskServicesMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionAcquireeDomain_0c206987-3749-46eb-9f96-b40e78937714" xlink:to="loc_afg_CropRiskServicesMember_0595b7c2-7ffe-4cf9-ae05-606ebc7919b9" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_CropInsuranceContractsCropYearAxis_4d658ab4-991e-4ecd-a9ec-eb1cc37e1989" xlink:href="afg-20240930.xsd#afg_CropInsuranceContractsCropYearAxis"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/hypercube-dimension" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfBusinessAcquisitionsByAcquisitionTable_d7b0bd78-729a-47d6-8fd5-e2df741886aa" xlink:to="loc_afg_CropInsuranceContractsCropYearAxis_4d658ab4-991e-4ecd-a9ec-eb1cc37e1989" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_CropInsuranceContractsCropYearDomain_4d658ab4-991e-4ecd-a9ec-eb1cc37e1989_default" xlink:href="afg-20240930.xsd#afg_CropInsuranceContractsCropYearDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-default" xlink:from="loc_afg_CropInsuranceContractsCropYearAxis_4d658ab4-991e-4ecd-a9ec-eb1cc37e1989" xlink:to="loc_afg_CropInsuranceContractsCropYearDomain_4d658ab4-991e-4ecd-a9ec-eb1cc37e1989_default" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_CropInsuranceContractsCropYearDomain_07a109d6-d1d4-4536-aed2-ab98c31349ec" xlink:href="afg-20240930.xsd#afg_CropInsuranceContractsCropYearDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-domain" xlink:from="loc_afg_CropInsuranceContractsCropYearAxis_4d658ab4-991e-4ecd-a9ec-eb1cc37e1989" xlink:to="loc_afg_CropInsuranceContractsCropYearDomain_07a109d6-d1d4-4536-aed2-ab98c31349ec" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_CropInsuranceContractCropYear2022Member_dba022f4-9700-4936-89ec-d82bf4a27dc2" xlink:href="afg-20240930.xsd#afg_CropInsuranceContractCropYear2022Member"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_afg_CropInsuranceContractsCropYearDomain_07a109d6-d1d4-4536-aed2-ab98c31349ec" xlink:to="loc_afg_CropInsuranceContractCropYear2022Member_dba022f4-9700-4936-89ec-d82bf4a27dc2" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_FiniteLivedIntangibleAssetsByMajorClassAxis_5413d474-529e-4222-b57b-fb4e63207b3d" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_FiniteLivedIntangibleAssetsByMajorClassAxis"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/hypercube-dimension" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfBusinessAcquisitionsByAcquisitionTable_d7b0bd78-729a-47d6-8fd5-e2df741886aa" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_FiniteLivedIntangibleAssetsByMajorClassAxis_5413d474-529e-4222-b57b-fb4e63207b3d" xlink:type="arc" order="3"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_FiniteLivedIntangibleAssetsMajorClassNameDomain_5413d474-529e-4222-b57b-fb4e63207b3d_default" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_FiniteLivedIntangibleAssetsMajorClassNameDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-default" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FiniteLivedIntangibleAssetsByMajorClassAxis_5413d474-529e-4222-b57b-fb4e63207b3d" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_FiniteLivedIntangibleAssetsMajorClassNameDomain_5413d474-529e-4222-b57b-fb4e63207b3d_default" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_FiniteLivedIntangibleAssetsMajorClassNameDomain_9a9a1805-da29-445f-b946-aebd42d4d8a6" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_FiniteLivedIntangibleAssetsMajorClassNameDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-domain" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FiniteLivedIntangibleAssetsByMajorClassAxis_5413d474-529e-4222-b57b-fb4e63207b3d" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_FiniteLivedIntangibleAssetsMajorClassNameDomain_9a9a1805-da29-445f-b946-aebd42d4d8a6" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_CustomerRelationshipsMember_3b0cdc67-ec55-4c08-9d2a-d9c096d1963b" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_CustomerRelationshipsMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FiniteLivedIntangibleAssetsMajorClassNameDomain_9a9a1805-da29-445f-b946-aebd42d4d8a6" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_CustomerRelationshipsMember_3b0cdc67-ec55-4c08-9d2a-d9c096d1963b" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_PremiumsWrittenGross_a5073443-c82c-4c6e-8fc4-a9b51051116b" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_PremiumsWrittenGross"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionLineItems_85409259-55e2-4797-8a9e-57bb9292ed68" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_PremiumsWrittenGross_a5073443-c82c-4c6e-8fc4-a9b51051116b" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_PaymentsToAcquireBusinessesGross_13221da8-1487-4075-ad85-6e2bc3885a2a" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_PaymentsToAcquireBusinessesGross"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionLineItems_85409259-55e2-4797-8a9e-57bb9292ed68" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_PaymentsToAcquireBusinessesGross_13221da8-1487-4075-ad85-6e2bc3885a2a" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_BusinessCombinationRecognizedIdentifiableAssetsAcquiredAndLiabilitiesAssumedNet_c8d4781d-ef97-4b38-b7f1-8bf86410f7b3" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_BusinessCombinationRecognizedIdentifiableAssetsAcquiredAndLiabilitiesAssumedNet"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionLineItems_85409259-55e2-4797-8a9e-57bb9292ed68" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_BusinessCombinationRecognizedIdentifiableAssetsAcquiredAndLiabilitiesAssumedNet_c8d4781d-ef97-4b38-b7f1-8bf86410f7b3" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionCostOfAcquiredEntityTransactionCosts_d59959ce-f587-4f9e-93b3-69a4518df0a2" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionCostOfAcquiredEntityTransactionCosts"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionLineItems_85409259-55e2-4797-8a9e-57bb9292ed68" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionCostOfAcquiredEntityTransactionCosts_d59959ce-f587-4f9e-93b3-69a4518df0a2" xlink:type="arc" order="3"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_BusinessCombinationRecognizedIdentifiableAssetsAcquiredAndLiabilitiesAssumedIntangibles_1afd5d44-d898-4fba-9222-b0a6bbd88632" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_BusinessCombinationRecognizedIdentifiableAssetsAcquiredAndLiabilitiesAssumedIntangibles"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionLineItems_85409259-55e2-4797-8a9e-57bb9292ed68" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_BusinessCombinationRecognizedIdentifiableAssetsAcquiredAndLiabilitiesAssumedIntangibles_1afd5d44-d898-4fba-9222-b0a6bbd88632" xlink:type="arc" order="4"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_FiniteLivedIntangibleAssetUsefulLife_86c56182-ba0e-40c1-9fb6-c92ff3c1e94c" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_FiniteLivedIntangibleAssetUsefulLife"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionLineItems_85409259-55e2-4797-8a9e-57bb9292ed68" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_FiniteLivedIntangibleAssetUsefulLife_86c56182-ba0e-40c1-9fb6-c92ff3c1e94c" xlink:type="arc" order="5"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_GoodwillAcquiredDuringPeriod_48682184-ade9-4d63-aac7-cb7aa74a289c" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_GoodwillAcquiredDuringPeriod"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionLineItems_85409259-55e2-4797-8a9e-57bb9292ed68" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_GoodwillAcquiredDuringPeriod_48682184-ade9-4d63-aac7-cb7aa74a289c" xlink:type="arc" order="6"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionPurchasePriceAllocationGoodwillExpectedTaxDeductibleAmount_26ff7c92-0e5f-4844-af08-e18fa4f0f473" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionPurchasePriceAllocationGoodwillExpectedTaxDeductibleAmount"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionLineItems_85409259-55e2-4797-8a9e-57bb9292ed68" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionPurchasePriceAllocationGoodwillExpectedTaxDeductibleAmount_26ff7c92-0e5f-4844-af08-e18fa4f0f473" xlink:type="arc" order="7"/>
  </link:definitionLink>
  <link:roleRef roleURI="http://www.afginc.com/role/AcquisitionofBusinessAllocationofpurchasepriceofsubsidiaryDetails" xlink:type="simple" xlink:href="afg-20240930.xsd#AcquisitionofBusinessAllocationofpurchasepriceofsubsidiaryDetails"/>
  <link:definitionLink xlink:role="http://www.afginc.com/role/AcquisitionofBusinessAllocationofpurchasepriceofsubsidiaryDetails" xlink:type="extended">
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionLineItems_beeaef46-d378-4536-8557-f4f6dffec860" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionLineItems"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfBusinessAcquisitionsByAcquisitionTable_f1362ab1-51d2-47b5-b9e9-905528f07859" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_ScheduleOfBusinessAcquisitionsByAcquisitionTable"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/all" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionLineItems_beeaef46-d378-4536-8557-f4f6dffec860" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfBusinessAcquisitionsByAcquisitionTable_f1362ab1-51d2-47b5-b9e9-905528f07859" xlink:type="arc" order="1" xbrldt:closed="true" xbrldt:contextElement="segment"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionAxis_c3da0f2d-b7c9-4b04-89cc-71b6598b115f" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionAxis"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/hypercube-dimension" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfBusinessAcquisitionsByAcquisitionTable_f1362ab1-51d2-47b5-b9e9-905528f07859" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionAxis_c3da0f2d-b7c9-4b04-89cc-71b6598b115f" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionAcquireeDomain_c3da0f2d-b7c9-4b04-89cc-71b6598b115f_default" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionAcquireeDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-default" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionAxis_c3da0f2d-b7c9-4b04-89cc-71b6598b115f" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionAcquireeDomain_c3da0f2d-b7c9-4b04-89cc-71b6598b115f_default" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionAcquireeDomain_29781dca-bc06-4d9e-90ab-322b36c55f86" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionAcquireeDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-domain" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionAxis_c3da0f2d-b7c9-4b04-89cc-71b6598b115f" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionAcquireeDomain_29781dca-bc06-4d9e-90ab-322b36c55f86" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_CropRiskServicesMember_cbaaa962-6699-4bd4-8eef-94f574f9a02c" xlink:href="afg-20240930.xsd#afg_CropRiskServicesMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionAcquireeDomain_29781dca-bc06-4d9e-90ab-322b36c55f86" xlink:to="loc_afg_CropRiskServicesMember_cbaaa962-6699-4bd4-8eef-94f574f9a02c" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_FiniteLivedIntangibleAssetsByMajorClassAxis_12074f1d-2d57-4ff2-8a2f-f7477efcdd28" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_FiniteLivedIntangibleAssetsByMajorClassAxis"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/hypercube-dimension" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfBusinessAcquisitionsByAcquisitionTable_f1362ab1-51d2-47b5-b9e9-905528f07859" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_FiniteLivedIntangibleAssetsByMajorClassAxis_12074f1d-2d57-4ff2-8a2f-f7477efcdd28" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_FiniteLivedIntangibleAssetsMajorClassNameDomain_12074f1d-2d57-4ff2-8a2f-f7477efcdd28_default" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_FiniteLivedIntangibleAssetsMajorClassNameDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-default" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FiniteLivedIntangibleAssetsByMajorClassAxis_12074f1d-2d57-4ff2-8a2f-f7477efcdd28" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_FiniteLivedIntangibleAssetsMajorClassNameDomain_12074f1d-2d57-4ff2-8a2f-f7477efcdd28_default" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_FiniteLivedIntangibleAssetsMajorClassNameDomain_efedf2d5-0979-4256-b688-b7ac140541f9" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_FiniteLivedIntangibleAssetsMajorClassNameDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-domain" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FiniteLivedIntangibleAssetsByMajorClassAxis_12074f1d-2d57-4ff2-8a2f-f7477efcdd28" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_FiniteLivedIntangibleAssetsMajorClassNameDomain_efedf2d5-0979-4256-b688-b7ac140541f9" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_CustomerRelationshipsMember_21d420d8-9e68-46e8-bb33-d57c88f6f58e" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_CustomerRelationshipsMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FiniteLivedIntangibleAssetsMajorClassNameDomain_efedf2d5-0979-4256-b688-b7ac140541f9" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_CustomerRelationshipsMember_21d420d8-9e68-46e8-bb33-d57c88f6f58e" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_PaymentsToAcquireBusinessesGross_ccaeb192-5c5e-4f06-8509-29eafbb824c0" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_PaymentsToAcquireBusinessesGross"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionLineItems_beeaef46-d378-4536-8557-f4f6dffec860" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_PaymentsToAcquireBusinessesGross_ccaeb192-5c5e-4f06-8509-29eafbb824c0" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_BusinessCombinationRecognizedIdentifiableAssetsAcquiredAndLiabilitiesAssumedAssetsAbstract_d6f079a5-a418-41df-aad6-1ec9a8cf6bf0" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_BusinessCombinationRecognizedIdentifiableAssetsAcquiredAndLiabilitiesAssumedAssetsAbstract"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionLineItems_beeaef46-d378-4536-8557-f4f6dffec860" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_BusinessCombinationRecognizedIdentifiableAssetsAcquiredAndLiabilitiesAssumedAssetsAbstract_d6f079a5-a418-41df-aad6-1ec9a8cf6bf0" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_BusinessCombinationRecognizedIdentifiableAssetsAcquiredAndLiabilitiesAssumedCashAndEquivalents_31ba3093-d31f-4868-b2a2-4ce00ad7af5c" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_BusinessCombinationRecognizedIdentifiableAssetsAcquiredAndLiabilitiesAssumedCashAndEquivalents"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_BusinessCombinationRecognizedIdentifiableAssetsAcquiredAndLiabilitiesAssumedAssetsAbstract_d6f079a5-a418-41df-aad6-1ec9a8cf6bf0" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_BusinessCombinationRecognizedIdentifiableAssetsAcquiredAndLiabilitiesAssumedCashAndEquivalents_31ba3093-d31f-4868-b2a2-4ce00ad7af5c" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_BusinessCombinationRecognizedIdentifiableAssetsAcquiredAndLiabilitiesAssumedAgentsBalancesAndPremiumsReceivable_579b1626-ce9e-4afc-b55f-f962941ff46a" xlink:href="afg-20240930.xsd#afg_BusinessCombinationRecognizedIdentifiableAssetsAcquiredAndLiabilitiesAssumedAgentsBalancesAndPremiumsReceivable"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_BusinessCombinationRecognizedIdentifiableAssetsAcquiredAndLiabilitiesAssumedAssetsAbstract_d6f079a5-a418-41df-aad6-1ec9a8cf6bf0" xlink:to="loc_afg_BusinessCombinationRecognizedIdentifiableAssetsAcquiredAndLiabilitiesAssumedAgentsBalancesAndPremiumsReceivable_579b1626-ce9e-4afc-b55f-f962941ff46a" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_BusinessCombinationRecognizedIdentifiableAssetsAcquiredAndLiabilitiesAssumedOtherNoncurrentAssets_8b6671e9-8ca8-4d7d-b0d3-cc87a884232b" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_BusinessCombinationRecognizedIdentifiableAssetsAcquiredAndLiabilitiesAssumedOtherNoncurrentAssets"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_BusinessCombinationRecognizedIdentifiableAssetsAcquiredAndLiabilitiesAssumedAssetsAbstract_d6f079a5-a418-41df-aad6-1ec9a8cf6bf0" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_BusinessCombinationRecognizedIdentifiableAssetsAcquiredAndLiabilitiesAssumedOtherNoncurrentAssets_8b6671e9-8ca8-4d7d-b0d3-cc87a884232b" xlink:type="arc" order="3"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_BusinessCombinationRecognizedIdentifiableAssetsAcquiredAndLiabilitiesAssumedAssets_0fac6c81-aa42-40d2-8653-b69e1dcc672f" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_BusinessCombinationRecognizedIdentifiableAssetsAcquiredAndLiabilitiesAssumedAssets"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_BusinessCombinationRecognizedIdentifiableAssetsAcquiredAndLiabilitiesAssumedAssetsAbstract_d6f079a5-a418-41df-aad6-1ec9a8cf6bf0" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_BusinessCombinationRecognizedIdentifiableAssetsAcquiredAndLiabilitiesAssumedAssets_0fac6c81-aa42-40d2-8653-b69e1dcc672f" xlink:type="arc" order="4"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_BusinessCombinationRecognizedIdentifiableAssetsAcquiredAndLiabilitiesAssumedLiabilitiesAbstract_520e3856-5932-4928-841c-65d4000add8f" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_BusinessCombinationRecognizedIdentifiableAssetsAcquiredAndLiabilitiesAssumedLiabilitiesAbstract"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionLineItems_beeaef46-d378-4536-8557-f4f6dffec860" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_BusinessCombinationRecognizedIdentifiableAssetsAcquiredAndLiabilitiesAssumedLiabilitiesAbstract_520e3856-5932-4928-841c-65d4000add8f" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_BusinessCombinationRecognizedIdentifiableAssetsAcquiredAndLiabilitiesAssumedNoncurrentLiabilitiesOther_d982b79b-38cb-48a0-965a-3d7df329afcc" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_BusinessCombinationRecognizedIdentifiableAssetsAcquiredAndLiabilitiesAssumedNoncurrentLiabilitiesOther"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_BusinessCombinationRecognizedIdentifiableAssetsAcquiredAndLiabilitiesAssumedLiabilitiesAbstract_520e3856-5932-4928-841c-65d4000add8f" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_BusinessCombinationRecognizedIdentifiableAssetsAcquiredAndLiabilitiesAssumedNoncurrentLiabilitiesOther_d982b79b-38cb-48a0-965a-3d7df329afcc" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_BusinessCombinationRecognizedIdentifiableAssetsAcquiredAndLiabilitiesAssumedLiabilities_d855e92e-8109-4dda-ac15-60b86dea91b1" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_BusinessCombinationRecognizedIdentifiableAssetsAcquiredAndLiabilitiesAssumedLiabilities"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_BusinessCombinationRecognizedIdentifiableAssetsAcquiredAndLiabilitiesAssumedLiabilitiesAbstract_520e3856-5932-4928-841c-65d4000add8f" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_BusinessCombinationRecognizedIdentifiableAssetsAcquiredAndLiabilitiesAssumedLiabilities_d855e92e-8109-4dda-ac15-60b86dea91b1" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_BusinessCombinationRecognizedIdentifiableAssetsAcquiredAndLiabilitiesAssumedNet_2329a135-0518-430b-9243-7313f3006db4" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_BusinessCombinationRecognizedIdentifiableAssetsAcquiredAndLiabilitiesAssumedNet"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionLineItems_beeaef46-d378-4536-8557-f4f6dffec860" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_BusinessCombinationRecognizedIdentifiableAssetsAcquiredAndLiabilitiesAssumedNet_2329a135-0518-430b-9243-7313f3006db4" xlink:type="arc" order="3"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_BusinessCombinationRecognizedIdentifiableAssetsAcquiredandLiabilitiesAssumedExcessPurchasePriceOverNetTangibleAssetsAcquired_e05a9b15-06cd-43bd-a6d0-c5ad0556d2c6" xlink:href="afg-20240930.xsd#afg_BusinessCombinationRecognizedIdentifiableAssetsAcquiredandLiabilitiesAssumedExcessPurchasePriceOverNetTangibleAssetsAcquired"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionLineItems_beeaef46-d378-4536-8557-f4f6dffec860" xlink:to="loc_afg_BusinessCombinationRecognizedIdentifiableAssetsAcquiredandLiabilitiesAssumedExcessPurchasePriceOverNetTangibleAssetsAcquired_e05a9b15-06cd-43bd-a6d0-c5ad0556d2c6" xlink:type="arc" order="4"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_BusinessCombinationRecognizedIdentifiableAssetsAcquiredAndLiabilitiesAssumedIntangibles_2c0bf3cf-618b-4814-a2fc-5afbc24aeee2" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_BusinessCombinationRecognizedIdentifiableAssetsAcquiredAndLiabilitiesAssumedIntangibles"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionLineItems_beeaef46-d378-4536-8557-f4f6dffec860" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_BusinessCombinationRecognizedIdentifiableAssetsAcquiredAndLiabilitiesAssumedIntangibles_2c0bf3cf-618b-4814-a2fc-5afbc24aeee2" xlink:type="arc" order="5"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_BusinessCombinationRecognizedIdentifiableAssetsAcquiredAndLiabilitiesAssumedDeferredTaxAssets_08b5a188-2e9f-4963-aba2-7a4c600304d7" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_BusinessCombinationRecognizedIdentifiableAssetsAcquiredAndLiabilitiesAssumedDeferredTaxAssets"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionLineItems_beeaef46-d378-4536-8557-f4f6dffec860" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_BusinessCombinationRecognizedIdentifiableAssetsAcquiredAndLiabilitiesAssumedDeferredTaxAssets_08b5a188-2e9f-4963-aba2-7a4c600304d7" xlink:type="arc" order="6"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_GoodwillAcquiredDuringPeriod_502ace7a-846a-4baf-9c2b-c3b4fce45c1f" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_GoodwillAcquiredDuringPeriod"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionLineItems_beeaef46-d378-4536-8557-f4f6dffec860" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_GoodwillAcquiredDuringPeriod_502ace7a-846a-4baf-9c2b-c3b4fce45c1f" xlink:type="arc" order="7"/>
  </link:definitionLink>
  <link:roleRef roleURI="http://www.afginc.com/role/SegmentsofOperationsNarrativeDetails" xlink:type="simple" xlink:href="afg-20240930.xsd#SegmentsofOperationsNarrativeDetails"/>
  <link:definitionLink xlink:role="http://www.afginc.com/role/SegmentsofOperationsNarrativeDetails" xlink:type="extended">
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_SegmentReportingInformationLineItems_80f54c7b-ecb4-4e18-8c7b-573ce2731ab3" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_SegmentReportingInformationLineItems"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfSegmentReportingInformationBySegmentTable_83bc8d04-1baf-4de1-b6f4-474db97408a7" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_ScheduleOfSegmentReportingInformationBySegmentTable"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/all" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_SegmentReportingInformationLineItems_80f54c7b-ecb4-4e18-8c7b-573ce2731ab3" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfSegmentReportingInformationBySegmentTable_83bc8d04-1baf-4de1-b6f4-474db97408a7" xlink:type="arc" order="1" xbrldt:closed="true" xbrldt:contextElement="segment"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_StatementBusinessSegmentsAxis_e2f36c1c-851d-46aa-be0f-be7f60f2a1ef" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_StatementBusinessSegmentsAxis"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/hypercube-dimension" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfSegmentReportingInformationBySegmentTable_83bc8d04-1baf-4de1-b6f4-474db97408a7" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_StatementBusinessSegmentsAxis_e2f36c1c-851d-46aa-be0f-be7f60f2a1ef" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_SegmentDomain_e2f36c1c-851d-46aa-be0f-be7f60f2a1ef_default" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_SegmentDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-default" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_StatementBusinessSegmentsAxis_e2f36c1c-851d-46aa-be0f-be7f60f2a1ef" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_SegmentDomain_e2f36c1c-851d-46aa-be0f-be7f60f2a1ef_default" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_SegmentDomain_f580246e-6f8f-4547-b4ad-8792e23531c7" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_SegmentDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-domain" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_StatementBusinessSegmentsAxis_e2f36c1c-851d-46aa-be0f-be7f60f2a1ef" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_SegmentDomain_f580246e-6f8f-4547-b4ad-8792e23531c7" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_CorporateAndOtherMember_cd3da5a3-0641-4a3b-bd6c-e88d0bfd5e04" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_CorporateAndOtherMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_SegmentDomain_f580246e-6f8f-4547-b4ad-8792e23531c7" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_CorporateAndOtherMember_cd3da5a3-0641-4a3b-bd6c-e88d0bfd5e04" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_srt_ConsolidationItemsAxis_92a6c2f4-a17a-4ee8-bd12-d136bb27c51c" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/srt/2024/elts/srt-2024.xsd#srt_ConsolidationItemsAxis"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/hypercube-dimension" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfSegmentReportingInformationBySegmentTable_83bc8d04-1baf-4de1-b6f4-474db97408a7" xlink:to="loc_srt_ConsolidationItemsAxis_92a6c2f4-a17a-4ee8-bd12-d136bb27c51c" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_srt_ConsolidationItemsDomain_92a6c2f4-a17a-4ee8-bd12-d136bb27c51c_default" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/srt/2024/elts/srt-2024.xsd#srt_ConsolidationItemsDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-default" xlink:from="loc_srt_ConsolidationItemsAxis_92a6c2f4-a17a-4ee8-bd12-d136bb27c51c" xlink:to="loc_srt_ConsolidationItemsDomain_92a6c2f4-a17a-4ee8-bd12-d136bb27c51c_default" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_srt_ConsolidationItemsDomain_8e53ce9c-5018-4928-9c62-a47d8f4d108d" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/srt/2024/elts/srt-2024.xsd#srt_ConsolidationItemsDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-domain" xlink:from="loc_srt_ConsolidationItemsAxis_92a6c2f4-a17a-4ee8-bd12-d136bb27c51c" xlink:to="loc_srt_ConsolidationItemsDomain_8e53ce9c-5018-4928-9c62-a47d8f4d108d" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_OperatingSegmentsMember_833ed224-955f-47f2-a1b9-837be5f14a1b" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_OperatingSegmentsMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_srt_ConsolidationItemsDomain_8e53ce9c-5018-4928-9c62-a47d8f4d108d" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_OperatingSegmentsMember_833ed224-955f-47f2-a1b9-837be5f14a1b" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_NumberOfReportableSegments_d9aac0c9-40b2-47f9-a67a-8bc43310d97f" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_NumberOfReportableSegments"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_SegmentReportingInformationLineItems_80f54c7b-ecb4-4e18-8c7b-573ce2731ab3" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_NumberOfReportableSegments_d9aac0c9-40b2-47f9-a67a-8bc43310d97f" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_GainsLossesOnExtinguishmentOfDebt_9b0e4ed1-b1ad-4b77-92fa-d2d3d3f25444" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_GainsLossesOnExtinguishmentOfDebt"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_SegmentReportingInformationLineItems_80f54c7b-ecb4-4e18-8c7b-573ce2731ab3" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_GainsLossesOnExtinguishmentOfDebt_9b0e4ed1-b1ad-4b77-92fa-d2d3d3f25444" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_LiabilityForAsbestosAndEnvironmentalClaimsNetPeriodIncreaseDecrease_e92b8962-60f7-4f32-b8b2-6d598ebe9624" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_LiabilityForAsbestosAndEnvironmentalClaimsNetPeriodIncreaseDecrease"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_SegmentReportingInformationLineItems_80f54c7b-ecb4-4e18-8c7b-573ce2731ab3" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_LiabilityForAsbestosAndEnvironmentalClaimsNetPeriodIncreaseDecrease_e92b8962-60f7-4f32-b8b2-6d598ebe9624" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
  </link:definitionLink>
  <link:roleRef roleURI="http://www.afginc.com/role/SegmentsofOperationsRevenuesbysegmentandsubsegmentDetails" xlink:type="simple" xlink:href="afg-20240930.xsd#SegmentsofOperationsRevenuesbysegmentandsubsegmentDetails"/>
  <link:definitionLink xlink:role="http://www.afginc.com/role/SegmentsofOperationsRevenuesbysegmentandsubsegmentDetails" xlink:type="extended">
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_SegmentReportingInformationLineItems_730a318d-9439-4577-8b6c-2603e43aef91" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_SegmentReportingInformationLineItems"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfSegmentReportingInformationBySegmentTable_a0a08dbc-c5e9-4cb4-81fe-35f19c5e53fa" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_ScheduleOfSegmentReportingInformationBySegmentTable"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/all" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_SegmentReportingInformationLineItems_730a318d-9439-4577-8b6c-2603e43aef91" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfSegmentReportingInformationBySegmentTable_a0a08dbc-c5e9-4cb4-81fe-35f19c5e53fa" xlink:type="arc" order="1" xbrldt:closed="true" xbrldt:contextElement="segment"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_srt_ConsolidationItemsAxis_a9ef1d7d-0082-4c18-b90d-07aeb58cbd6d" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/srt/2024/elts/srt-2024.xsd#srt_ConsolidationItemsAxis"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/hypercube-dimension" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfSegmentReportingInformationBySegmentTable_a0a08dbc-c5e9-4cb4-81fe-35f19c5e53fa" xlink:to="loc_srt_ConsolidationItemsAxis_a9ef1d7d-0082-4c18-b90d-07aeb58cbd6d" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_srt_ConsolidationItemsDomain_a9ef1d7d-0082-4c18-b90d-07aeb58cbd6d_default" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/srt/2024/elts/srt-2024.xsd#srt_ConsolidationItemsDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-default" xlink:from="loc_srt_ConsolidationItemsAxis_a9ef1d7d-0082-4c18-b90d-07aeb58cbd6d" xlink:to="loc_srt_ConsolidationItemsDomain_a9ef1d7d-0082-4c18-b90d-07aeb58cbd6d_default" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_srt_ConsolidationItemsDomain_df9350ab-b4f6-4a9d-a7f3-7a4502984e32" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/srt/2024/elts/srt-2024.xsd#srt_ConsolidationItemsDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-domain" xlink:from="loc_srt_ConsolidationItemsAxis_a9ef1d7d-0082-4c18-b90d-07aeb58cbd6d" xlink:to="loc_srt_ConsolidationItemsDomain_df9350ab-b4f6-4a9d-a7f3-7a4502984e32" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_OperatingSegmentsMember_01a3b6f6-6efa-418b-a27d-7870f78cae3d" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_OperatingSegmentsMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_srt_ConsolidationItemsDomain_df9350ab-b4f6-4a9d-a7f3-7a4502984e32" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_OperatingSegmentsMember_01a3b6f6-6efa-418b-a27d-7870f78cae3d" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_StatementBusinessSegmentsAxis_85935e69-1715-4fb1-a0cb-40bb28975f1e" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_StatementBusinessSegmentsAxis"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/hypercube-dimension" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfSegmentReportingInformationBySegmentTable_a0a08dbc-c5e9-4cb4-81fe-35f19c5e53fa" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_StatementBusinessSegmentsAxis_85935e69-1715-4fb1-a0cb-40bb28975f1e" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_SegmentDomain_85935e69-1715-4fb1-a0cb-40bb28975f1e_default" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_SegmentDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-default" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_StatementBusinessSegmentsAxis_85935e69-1715-4fb1-a0cb-40bb28975f1e" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_SegmentDomain_85935e69-1715-4fb1-a0cb-40bb28975f1e_default" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_SegmentDomain_c68fafd3-899b-43d6-a1e5-be9ad695cd4b" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_SegmentDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-domain" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_StatementBusinessSegmentsAxis_85935e69-1715-4fb1-a0cb-40bb28975f1e" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_SegmentDomain_c68fafd3-899b-43d6-a1e5-be9ad695cd4b" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_PropertyAndCasualtyInsuranceMember_85ff260c-a6ce-4a09-b9af-dab6a2f4e9e4" xlink:href="afg-20240930.xsd#afg_PropertyAndCasualtyInsuranceMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_SegmentDomain_c68fafd3-899b-43d6-a1e5-be9ad695cd4b" xlink:to="loc_afg_PropertyAndCasualtyInsuranceMember_85ff260c-a6ce-4a09-b9af-dab6a2f4e9e4" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_CorporateAndOtherMember_fc0dd419-454b-48c0-82ac-7a90c1d3f2b6" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_CorporateAndOtherMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_SegmentDomain_c68fafd3-899b-43d6-a1e5-be9ad695cd4b" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_CorporateAndOtherMember_fc0dd419-454b-48c0-82ac-7a90c1d3f2b6" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_SubsegmentsAxis_51423a09-a7c7-4169-ae0d-3f884ff76994" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_SubsegmentsAxis"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/hypercube-dimension" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfSegmentReportingInformationBySegmentTable_a0a08dbc-c5e9-4cb4-81fe-35f19c5e53fa" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_SubsegmentsAxis_51423a09-a7c7-4169-ae0d-3f884ff76994" xlink:type="arc" order="3"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_SubsegmentsDomain_51423a09-a7c7-4169-ae0d-3f884ff76994_default" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_SubsegmentsDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-default" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_SubsegmentsAxis_51423a09-a7c7-4169-ae0d-3f884ff76994" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_SubsegmentsDomain_51423a09-a7c7-4169-ae0d-3f884ff76994_default" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_SubsegmentsDomain_1a4f314a-235e-462a-be96-ee75c47651cb" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_SubsegmentsDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-domain" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_SubsegmentsAxis_51423a09-a7c7-4169-ae0d-3f884ff76994" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_SubsegmentsDomain_1a4f314a-235e-462a-be96-ee75c47651cb" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_SpecialtyPropertyAndTransportationInsuranceMember_d00e15da-7ebe-4b5a-87a5-8aab32557ebc" xlink:href="afg-20240930.xsd#afg_SpecialtyPropertyAndTransportationInsuranceMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_SubsegmentsDomain_1a4f314a-235e-462a-be96-ee75c47651cb" xlink:to="loc_afg_SpecialtyPropertyAndTransportationInsuranceMember_d00e15da-7ebe-4b5a-87a5-8aab32557ebc" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_SpecialtyCasualtyInsuranceMember_d2f75a79-73a8-45eb-ac02-f33f9c8f47c9" xlink:href="afg-20240930.xsd#afg_SpecialtyCasualtyInsuranceMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_SubsegmentsDomain_1a4f314a-235e-462a-be96-ee75c47651cb" xlink:to="loc_afg_SpecialtyCasualtyInsuranceMember_d2f75a79-73a8-45eb-ac02-f33f9c8f47c9" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_SpecialtyFinancialInsuranceMember_723a7acb-1866-456f-9e1b-f52a7e3f43e4" xlink:href="afg-20240930.xsd#afg_SpecialtyFinancialInsuranceMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_SubsegmentsDomain_1a4f314a-235e-462a-be96-ee75c47651cb" xlink:to="loc_afg_SpecialtyFinancialInsuranceMember_723a7acb-1866-456f-9e1b-f52a7e3f43e4" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_SpecialtyOtherInsuranceMember_bead3639-d8ca-4105-ac85-77fa244096b1" xlink:href="afg-20240930.xsd#afg_SpecialtyOtherInsuranceMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_SubsegmentsDomain_1a4f314a-235e-462a-be96-ee75c47651cb" xlink:to="loc_afg_SpecialtyOtherInsuranceMember_bead3639-d8ca-4105-ac85-77fa244096b1" xlink:type="arc" order="3"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_PremiumsEarnedNetPropertyAndCasualty_ebb17a9c-8a29-40bb-b2cc-ace641a5ff7f" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_PremiumsEarnedNetPropertyAndCasualty"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_SegmentReportingInformationLineItems_730a318d-9439-4577-8b6c-2603e43aef91" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_PremiumsEarnedNetPropertyAndCasualty_ebb17a9c-8a29-40bb-b2cc-ace641a5ff7f" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_NetInvestmentIncome_f255712a-c6cb-41b3-b9ef-bca220ab1ea1" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_NetInvestmentIncome"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_SegmentReportingInformationLineItems_730a318d-9439-4577-8b6c-2603e43aef91" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_NetInvestmentIncome_f255712a-c6cb-41b3-b9ef-bca220ab1ea1" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_OtherIncome_ffa16c9c-d8a0-45c1-a883-4e5d35910a67" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_OtherIncome"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_SegmentReportingInformationLineItems_730a318d-9439-4577-8b6c-2603e43aef91" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_OtherIncome_ffa16c9c-d8a0-45c1-a883-4e5d35910a67" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_RevenuesBeforeRealizedGainsLosses_815b4dce-6646-4877-b7bb-2537fa68b40c" xlink:href="afg-20240930.xsd#afg_RevenuesBeforeRealizedGainsLosses"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_SegmentReportingInformationLineItems_730a318d-9439-4577-8b6c-2603e43aef91" xlink:to="loc_afg_RevenuesBeforeRealizedGainsLosses_815b4dce-6646-4877-b7bb-2537fa68b40c" xlink:type="arc" order="3"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_DebtAndEquitySecuritiesRealizedGainLoss_e924adbb-b7e8-42e5-b88a-189a8eb8f019" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_DebtAndEquitySecuritiesRealizedGainLoss"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_SegmentReportingInformationLineItems_730a318d-9439-4577-8b6c-2603e43aef91" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_DebtAndEquitySecuritiesRealizedGainLoss_e924adbb-b7e8-42e5-b88a-189a8eb8f019" xlink:type="arc" order="4"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_RealizedGainsLossesOnSubsidiaries_e7837da9-10b7-4406-8cc7-76bfdf82a7a1" xlink:href="afg-20240930.xsd#afg_RealizedGainsLossesOnSubsidiaries"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_SegmentReportingInformationLineItems_730a318d-9439-4577-8b6c-2603e43aef91" xlink:to="loc_afg_RealizedGainsLossesOnSubsidiaries_e7837da9-10b7-4406-8cc7-76bfdf82a7a1" xlink:type="arc" order="5"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_Revenues_933d6435-f2da-4ce7-87ba-edc3a3f93337" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_Revenues"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_SegmentReportingInformationLineItems_730a318d-9439-4577-8b6c-2603e43aef91" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_Revenues_933d6435-f2da-4ce7-87ba-edc3a3f93337" xlink:type="arc" order="6"/>
  </link:definitionLink>
  <link:roleRef roleURI="http://www.afginc.com/role/SegmentsofOperationsEarningsbeforeincometaxesbysegmentandsubsegmentDetails" xlink:type="simple" xlink:href="afg-20240930.xsd#SegmentsofOperationsEarningsbeforeincometaxesbysegmentandsubsegmentDetails"/>
  <link:definitionLink xlink:role="http://www.afginc.com/role/SegmentsofOperationsEarningsbeforeincometaxesbysegmentandsubsegmentDetails" xlink:type="extended">
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_SegmentReportingInformationLineItems_516560ac-0a74-4140-a53b-fc50edbe1476" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_SegmentReportingInformationLineItems"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfSegmentReportingInformationBySegmentTable_94f1d28a-347a-4fe2-9cc2-fc334ce12c8c" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_ScheduleOfSegmentReportingInformationBySegmentTable"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/all" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_SegmentReportingInformationLineItems_516560ac-0a74-4140-a53b-fc50edbe1476" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfSegmentReportingInformationBySegmentTable_94f1d28a-347a-4fe2-9cc2-fc334ce12c8c" xlink:type="arc" order="1" xbrldt:closed="true" xbrldt:contextElement="segment"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_srt_ConsolidationItemsAxis_a35c481c-de31-4022-9c1e-f7910c8984fa" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/srt/2024/elts/srt-2024.xsd#srt_ConsolidationItemsAxis"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/hypercube-dimension" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfSegmentReportingInformationBySegmentTable_94f1d28a-347a-4fe2-9cc2-fc334ce12c8c" xlink:to="loc_srt_ConsolidationItemsAxis_a35c481c-de31-4022-9c1e-f7910c8984fa" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_srt_ConsolidationItemsDomain_a35c481c-de31-4022-9c1e-f7910c8984fa_default" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/srt/2024/elts/srt-2024.xsd#srt_ConsolidationItemsDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-default" xlink:from="loc_srt_ConsolidationItemsAxis_a35c481c-de31-4022-9c1e-f7910c8984fa" xlink:to="loc_srt_ConsolidationItemsDomain_a35c481c-de31-4022-9c1e-f7910c8984fa_default" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_srt_ConsolidationItemsDomain_2ce09495-487f-4d34-9bcf-4598264e8ddc" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/srt/2024/elts/srt-2024.xsd#srt_ConsolidationItemsDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-domain" xlink:from="loc_srt_ConsolidationItemsAxis_a35c481c-de31-4022-9c1e-f7910c8984fa" xlink:to="loc_srt_ConsolidationItemsDomain_2ce09495-487f-4d34-9bcf-4598264e8ddc" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_OperatingSegmentsMember_3cce517c-4d42-4cad-b2d7-51fb4e663db7" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_OperatingSegmentsMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_srt_ConsolidationItemsDomain_2ce09495-487f-4d34-9bcf-4598264e8ddc" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_OperatingSegmentsMember_3cce517c-4d42-4cad-b2d7-51fb4e663db7" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_StatementBusinessSegmentsAxis_05b7012a-290a-4803-acf9-3e57db9f6451" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_StatementBusinessSegmentsAxis"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/hypercube-dimension" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfSegmentReportingInformationBySegmentTable_94f1d28a-347a-4fe2-9cc2-fc334ce12c8c" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_StatementBusinessSegmentsAxis_05b7012a-290a-4803-acf9-3e57db9f6451" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_SegmentDomain_05b7012a-290a-4803-acf9-3e57db9f6451_default" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_SegmentDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-default" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_StatementBusinessSegmentsAxis_05b7012a-290a-4803-acf9-3e57db9f6451" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_SegmentDomain_05b7012a-290a-4803-acf9-3e57db9f6451_default" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_SegmentDomain_636ece72-4211-4264-8a1b-673dc162575b" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_SegmentDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-domain" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_StatementBusinessSegmentsAxis_05b7012a-290a-4803-acf9-3e57db9f6451" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_SegmentDomain_636ece72-4211-4264-8a1b-673dc162575b" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_PropertyAndCasualtyInsuranceMember_83013e8e-c1b6-4a53-8e17-df0335a47ca1" xlink:href="afg-20240930.xsd#afg_PropertyAndCasualtyInsuranceMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_SegmentDomain_636ece72-4211-4264-8a1b-673dc162575b" xlink:to="loc_afg_PropertyAndCasualtyInsuranceMember_83013e8e-c1b6-4a53-8e17-df0335a47ca1" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_CorporateAndOtherMember_48c1105d-04d2-451d-b006-b8751b081a17" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_CorporateAndOtherMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_SegmentDomain_636ece72-4211-4264-8a1b-673dc162575b" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_CorporateAndOtherMember_48c1105d-04d2-451d-b006-b8751b081a17" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_SubsegmentsAxis_a1cedb74-c456-4902-a61d-538f4f99f1f8" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_SubsegmentsAxis"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/hypercube-dimension" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfSegmentReportingInformationBySegmentTable_94f1d28a-347a-4fe2-9cc2-fc334ce12c8c" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_SubsegmentsAxis_a1cedb74-c456-4902-a61d-538f4f99f1f8" xlink:type="arc" order="3"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_SubsegmentsDomain_a1cedb74-c456-4902-a61d-538f4f99f1f8_default" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_SubsegmentsDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-default" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_SubsegmentsAxis_a1cedb74-c456-4902-a61d-538f4f99f1f8" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_SubsegmentsDomain_a1cedb74-c456-4902-a61d-538f4f99f1f8_default" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_SubsegmentsDomain_b13e8f67-9190-46c9-b4f3-2144ec4d005a" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_SubsegmentsDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-domain" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_SubsegmentsAxis_a1cedb74-c456-4902-a61d-538f4f99f1f8" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_SubsegmentsDomain_b13e8f67-9190-46c9-b4f3-2144ec4d005a" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_SpecialtyPropertyAndTransportationInsuranceMember_e9abcb4f-02eb-453c-84a9-72d1a95be84f" xlink:href="afg-20240930.xsd#afg_SpecialtyPropertyAndTransportationInsuranceMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_SubsegmentsDomain_b13e8f67-9190-46c9-b4f3-2144ec4d005a" xlink:to="loc_afg_SpecialtyPropertyAndTransportationInsuranceMember_e9abcb4f-02eb-453c-84a9-72d1a95be84f" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_SpecialtyCasualtyInsuranceMember_53117a2b-47ff-4356-99eb-6ede910a9c64" xlink:href="afg-20240930.xsd#afg_SpecialtyCasualtyInsuranceMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_SubsegmentsDomain_b13e8f67-9190-46c9-b4f3-2144ec4d005a" xlink:to="loc_afg_SpecialtyCasualtyInsuranceMember_53117a2b-47ff-4356-99eb-6ede910a9c64" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_SpecialtyFinancialInsuranceMember_3384a7c4-2077-4616-8a32-a10bb96a7832" xlink:href="afg-20240930.xsd#afg_SpecialtyFinancialInsuranceMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_SubsegmentsDomain_b13e8f67-9190-46c9-b4f3-2144ec4d005a" xlink:to="loc_afg_SpecialtyFinancialInsuranceMember_3384a7c4-2077-4616-8a32-a10bb96a7832" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_SpecialtyOtherInsuranceMember_6c2df376-0f60-43de-993e-07a4ba928bfb" xlink:href="afg-20240930.xsd#afg_SpecialtyOtherInsuranceMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_SubsegmentsDomain_b13e8f67-9190-46c9-b4f3-2144ec4d005a" xlink:to="loc_afg_SpecialtyOtherInsuranceMember_6c2df376-0f60-43de-993e-07a4ba928bfb" xlink:type="arc" order="3"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_OtherLinesMember_9ba3b714-dd4c-4733-beff-23226d0bd972" xlink:href="afg-20240930.xsd#afg_OtherLinesMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_SubsegmentsDomain_b13e8f67-9190-46c9-b4f3-2144ec4d005a" xlink:to="loc_afg_OtherLinesMember_9ba3b714-dd4c-4733-beff-23226d0bd972" xlink:type="arc" order="4"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_PropertyAndCasualtyInsuranceUnderwritingIncomeLoss_e25f1eb8-ef86-4170-af94-d69fdc3726d2" xlink:href="afg-20240930.xsd#afg_PropertyAndCasualtyInsuranceUnderwritingIncomeLoss"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_SegmentReportingInformationLineItems_516560ac-0a74-4140-a53b-fc50edbe1476" xlink:to="loc_afg_PropertyAndCasualtyInsuranceUnderwritingIncomeLoss_e25f1eb8-ef86-4170-af94-d69fdc3726d2" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_InvestmentAndOtherIncomeNet_1b8c4f85-4f93-4236-90d9-54a6ec9fc030" xlink:href="afg-20240930.xsd#afg_InvestmentAndOtherIncomeNet"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_SegmentReportingInformationLineItems_516560ac-0a74-4140-a53b-fc50edbe1476" xlink:to="loc_afg_InvestmentAndOtherIncomeNet_1b8c4f85-4f93-4236-90d9-54a6ec9fc030" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_OperatingIncomeLossBeforeRealizedGainsLossesAndIncomeTaxes_bed8e8a3-2390-45c9-a9ee-2c091fc63133" xlink:href="afg-20240930.xsd#afg_OperatingIncomeLossBeforeRealizedGainsLossesAndIncomeTaxes"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_SegmentReportingInformationLineItems_516560ac-0a74-4140-a53b-fc50edbe1476" xlink:to="loc_afg_OperatingIncomeLossBeforeRealizedGainsLossesAndIncomeTaxes_bed8e8a3-2390-45c9-a9ee-2c091fc63133" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_DebtAndEquitySecuritiesRealizedGainLoss_60174d5f-06b1-47f3-b6dd-1238814b6a3f" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_DebtAndEquitySecuritiesRealizedGainLoss"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_SegmentReportingInformationLineItems_516560ac-0a74-4140-a53b-fc50edbe1476" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_DebtAndEquitySecuritiesRealizedGainLoss_60174d5f-06b1-47f3-b6dd-1238814b6a3f" xlink:type="arc" order="3"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_RealizedGainsLossesOnSubsidiaries_5fefaff4-dc56-4007-a23c-452b4a2c2366" xlink:href="afg-20240930.xsd#afg_RealizedGainsLossesOnSubsidiaries"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_SegmentReportingInformationLineItems_516560ac-0a74-4140-a53b-fc50edbe1476" xlink:to="loc_afg_RealizedGainsLossesOnSubsidiaries_5fefaff4-dc56-4007-a23c-452b4a2c2366" xlink:type="arc" order="4"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_OperatingIncomeLoss_fc0f7c6a-f3eb-4c73-ae0d-4feed840814d" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_OperatingIncomeLoss"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_SegmentReportingInformationLineItems_516560ac-0a74-4140-a53b-fc50edbe1476" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_OperatingIncomeLoss_fc0f7c6a-f3eb-4c73-ae0d-4feed840814d" xlink:type="arc" order="5"/>
  </link:definitionLink>
  <link:roleRef roleURI="http://www.afginc.com/role/FairValueMeasurementsAssetsandliabilitiesmeasuredandcarriedatfairvalueinthefinancialstatementsDetails" xlink:type="simple" xlink:href="afg-20240930.xsd#FairValueMeasurementsAssetsandliabilitiesmeasuredandcarriedatfairvalueinthefinancialstatementsDetails"/>
  <link:definitionLink xlink:role="http://www.afginc.com/role/FairValueMeasurementsAssetsandliabilitiesmeasuredandcarriedatfairvalueinthefinancialstatementsDetails" xlink:type="extended">
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_FairValueAssetsAndLiabilitiesMeasuredOnRecurringAndNonrecurringBasisLineItems_bcdbbb7e-18b6-4a5f-b9e3-f11fa13f46d8" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_FairValueAssetsAndLiabilitiesMeasuredOnRecurringAndNonrecurringBasisLineItems"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_FairValueAssetsAndLiabilitiesMeasuredOnRecurringAndNonrecurringBasisTable_fe42befe-fa81-4e77-9b15-3b68370b16f8" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_FairValueAssetsAndLiabilitiesMeasuredOnRecurringAndNonrecurringBasisTable"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/all" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FairValueAssetsAndLiabilitiesMeasuredOnRecurringAndNonrecurringBasisLineItems_bcdbbb7e-18b6-4a5f-b9e3-f11fa13f46d8" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_FairValueAssetsAndLiabilitiesMeasuredOnRecurringAndNonrecurringBasisTable_fe42befe-fa81-4e77-9b15-3b68370b16f8" xlink:type="arc" order="1" xbrldt:closed="true" xbrldt:contextElement="segment"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_FairValueByFairValueHierarchyLevelAxis_e27a0196-fedc-4924-bf3c-622248425818" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_FairValueByFairValueHierarchyLevelAxis"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/hypercube-dimension" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FairValueAssetsAndLiabilitiesMeasuredOnRecurringAndNonrecurringBasisTable_fe42befe-fa81-4e77-9b15-3b68370b16f8" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_FairValueByFairValueHierarchyLevelAxis_e27a0196-fedc-4924-bf3c-622248425818" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_FairValueMeasurementsFairValueHierarchyDomain_e27a0196-fedc-4924-bf3c-622248425818_default" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_FairValueMeasurementsFairValueHierarchyDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-default" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FairValueByFairValueHierarchyLevelAxis_e27a0196-fedc-4924-bf3c-622248425818" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_FairValueMeasurementsFairValueHierarchyDomain_e27a0196-fedc-4924-bf3c-622248425818_default" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_FairValueMeasurementsFairValueHierarchyDomain_be7ef0d0-d7bb-4731-8d62-7388aa926a87" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_FairValueMeasurementsFairValueHierarchyDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-domain" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FairValueByFairValueHierarchyLevelAxis_e27a0196-fedc-4924-bf3c-622248425818" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_FairValueMeasurementsFairValueHierarchyDomain_be7ef0d0-d7bb-4731-8d62-7388aa926a87" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_FairValueInputsLevel1Member_0c154720-b709-4402-8674-3716e33ce8e5" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_FairValueInputsLevel1Member"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FairValueMeasurementsFairValueHierarchyDomain_be7ef0d0-d7bb-4731-8d62-7388aa926a87" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_FairValueInputsLevel1Member_0c154720-b709-4402-8674-3716e33ce8e5" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_FairValueInputsLevel2Member_a5967809-c837-4aad-a0c5-bf9a2dbe9ab0" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_FairValueInputsLevel2Member"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FairValueMeasurementsFairValueHierarchyDomain_be7ef0d0-d7bb-4731-8d62-7388aa926a87" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_FairValueInputsLevel2Member_a5967809-c837-4aad-a0c5-bf9a2dbe9ab0" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_FairValueInputsLevel3Member_8a50509c-2d63-4c60-8684-5ca585114af4" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_FairValueInputsLevel3Member"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FairValueMeasurementsFairValueHierarchyDomain_be7ef0d0-d7bb-4731-8d62-7388aa926a87" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_FairValueInputsLevel3Member_8a50509c-2d63-4c60-8684-5ca585114af4" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_FairValueByAssetClassAxis_d2a8ab64-c33f-4a9e-884f-123d26e9855f" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_FairValueByAssetClassAxis"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/hypercube-dimension" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FairValueAssetsAndLiabilitiesMeasuredOnRecurringAndNonrecurringBasisTable_fe42befe-fa81-4e77-9b15-3b68370b16f8" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_FairValueByAssetClassAxis_d2a8ab64-c33f-4a9e-884f-123d26e9855f" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_FairValueAssetsMeasuredOnRecurringBasisUnobservableInputReconciliationByAssetClassDomain_d2a8ab64-c33f-4a9e-884f-123d26e9855f_default" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_FairValueAssetsMeasuredOnRecurringBasisUnobservableInputReconciliationByAssetClassDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-default" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FairValueByAssetClassAxis_d2a8ab64-c33f-4a9e-884f-123d26e9855f" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_FairValueAssetsMeasuredOnRecurringBasisUnobservableInputReconciliationByAssetClassDomain_d2a8ab64-c33f-4a9e-884f-123d26e9855f_default" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_FairValueAssetsMeasuredOnRecurringBasisUnobservableInputReconciliationByAssetClassDomain_8ed118c2-8a82-4ebc-8028-da396f510d73" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_FairValueAssetsMeasuredOnRecurringBasisUnobservableInputReconciliationByAssetClassDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-domain" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FairValueByAssetClassAxis_d2a8ab64-c33f-4a9e-884f-123d26e9855f" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_FairValueAssetsMeasuredOnRecurringBasisUnobservableInputReconciliationByAssetClassDomain_8ed118c2-8a82-4ebc-8028-da396f510d73" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_FixedMaturitiesMember_220a889d-428e-4017-bdec-a00f788644fe" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_FixedMaturitiesMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FairValueAssetsMeasuredOnRecurringBasisUnobservableInputReconciliationByAssetClassDomain_8ed118c2-8a82-4ebc-8028-da396f510d73" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_FixedMaturitiesMember_220a889d-428e-4017-bdec-a00f788644fe" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_USTreasuryAndGovernmentMember_b712efd2-79d1-439d-92c6-8ac0f55bad73" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_USTreasuryAndGovernmentMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FixedMaturitiesMember_220a889d-428e-4017-bdec-a00f788644fe" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_USTreasuryAndGovernmentMember_b712efd2-79d1-439d-92c6-8ac0f55bad73" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_USStatesAndPoliticalSubdivisionsMember_88da6697-bb41-4d5e-a421-a8b923dcb509" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_USStatesAndPoliticalSubdivisionsMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FixedMaturitiesMember_220a889d-428e-4017-bdec-a00f788644fe" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_USStatesAndPoliticalSubdivisionsMember_88da6697-bb41-4d5e-a421-a8b923dcb509" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_ForeignGovernmentDebtSecuritiesMember_7a1d6907-15d7-4140-a734-0e359ae2a953" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_ForeignGovernmentDebtSecuritiesMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FixedMaturitiesMember_220a889d-428e-4017-bdec-a00f788644fe" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_ForeignGovernmentDebtSecuritiesMember_7a1d6907-15d7-4140-a734-0e359ae2a953" xlink:type="arc" order="3"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_ResidentialMortgageBackedSecuritiesMember_b82138bb-f256-4eab-8a6b-d3145672379c" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_ResidentialMortgageBackedSecuritiesMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FixedMaturitiesMember_220a889d-428e-4017-bdec-a00f788644fe" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_ResidentialMortgageBackedSecuritiesMember_b82138bb-f256-4eab-8a6b-d3145672379c" xlink:type="arc" order="4"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_CommercialMortgageBackedSecuritiesMember_1cc69f9b-a1fd-4740-af44-e44645ce897a" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_CommercialMortgageBackedSecuritiesMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FixedMaturitiesMember_220a889d-428e-4017-bdec-a00f788644fe" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_CommercialMortgageBackedSecuritiesMember_1cc69f9b-a1fd-4740-af44-e44645ce897a" xlink:type="arc" order="5"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_CollateralizedLoanObligationsMember_ff893aa1-9228-4d4e-b91e-b037dc1add3d" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_CollateralizedLoanObligationsMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FixedMaturitiesMember_220a889d-428e-4017-bdec-a00f788644fe" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_CollateralizedLoanObligationsMember_ff893aa1-9228-4d4e-b91e-b037dc1add3d" xlink:type="arc" order="6"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_AssetBackedSecuritiesMember_a21ecb6f-7856-4229-b687-68ec7564d0bb" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_AssetBackedSecuritiesMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FixedMaturitiesMember_220a889d-428e-4017-bdec-a00f788644fe" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_AssetBackedSecuritiesMember_a21ecb6f-7856-4229-b687-68ec7564d0bb" xlink:type="arc" order="7"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_CorporateDebtSecuritiesMember_d62a1834-f4bb-4698-bf75-dab861d8e73b" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_CorporateDebtSecuritiesMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FixedMaturitiesMember_220a889d-428e-4017-bdec-a00f788644fe" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_CorporateDebtSecuritiesMember_d62a1834-f4bb-4698-bf75-dab861d8e73b" xlink:type="arc" order="8"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_EquitySecuritiesMember_920876a0-1cfb-4e08-8c1a-ece6a88ebff6" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_EquitySecuritiesMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FairValueAssetsMeasuredOnRecurringBasisUnobservableInputReconciliationByAssetClassDomain_8ed118c2-8a82-4ebc-8028-da396f510d73" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_EquitySecuritiesMember_920876a0-1cfb-4e08-8c1a-ece6a88ebff6" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_OtherAssetsMember_7d7d135a-5d27-413a-a11b-6acac7479a97" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_OtherAssetsMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FairValueAssetsMeasuredOnRecurringBasisUnobservableInputReconciliationByAssetClassDomain_8ed118c2-8a82-4ebc-8028-da396f510d73" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_OtherAssetsMember_7d7d135a-5d27-413a-a11b-6acac7479a97" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_FairValueByLiabilityClassAxis_7d0a2bcb-d187-4b8c-b758-ead8fa565519" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_FairValueByLiabilityClassAxis"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/hypercube-dimension" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FairValueAssetsAndLiabilitiesMeasuredOnRecurringAndNonrecurringBasisTable_fe42befe-fa81-4e77-9b15-3b68370b16f8" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_FairValueByLiabilityClassAxis_7d0a2bcb-d187-4b8c-b758-ead8fa565519" xlink:type="arc" order="3"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_FairValueLiabilitiesMeasuredOnRecurringBasisUnobservableInputReconciliationByLiabilityClassDomain_7d0a2bcb-d187-4b8c-b758-ead8fa565519_default" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_FairValueLiabilitiesMeasuredOnRecurringBasisUnobservableInputReconciliationByLiabilityClassDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-default" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FairValueByLiabilityClassAxis_7d0a2bcb-d187-4b8c-b758-ead8fa565519" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_FairValueLiabilitiesMeasuredOnRecurringBasisUnobservableInputReconciliationByLiabilityClassDomain_7d0a2bcb-d187-4b8c-b758-ead8fa565519_default" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_FairValueLiabilitiesMeasuredOnRecurringBasisUnobservableInputReconciliationByLiabilityClassDomain_6ed7ecdb-dd21-46c9-a983-73cb9ab9b3ec" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_FairValueLiabilitiesMeasuredOnRecurringBasisUnobservableInputReconciliationByLiabilityClassDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-domain" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FairValueByLiabilityClassAxis_7d0a2bcb-d187-4b8c-b758-ead8fa565519" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_FairValueLiabilitiesMeasuredOnRecurringBasisUnobservableInputReconciliationByLiabilityClassDomain_6ed7ecdb-dd21-46c9-a983-73cb9ab9b3ec" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_ContingentConsiderationAcquisitionsMember_8e07c285-339e-411b-ae24-4adb84972dec" xlink:href="afg-20240930.xsd#afg_ContingentConsiderationAcquisitionsMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FairValueLiabilitiesMeasuredOnRecurringBasisUnobservableInputReconciliationByLiabilityClassDomain_6ed7ecdb-dd21-46c9-a983-73cb9ab9b3ec" xlink:to="loc_afg_ContingentConsiderationAcquisitionsMember_8e07c285-339e-411b-ae24-4adb84972dec" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_OtherLiabilitiesMember_8ead5b65-a23b-48a9-ba21-067998eee4f8" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_OtherLiabilitiesMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FairValueLiabilitiesMeasuredOnRecurringBasisUnobservableInputReconciliationByLiabilityClassDomain_6ed7ecdb-dd21-46c9-a983-73cb9ab9b3ec" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_OtherLiabilitiesMember_8ead5b65-a23b-48a9-ba21-067998eee4f8" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_FairValueAssetsAndLiabilitiesMeasuredOnRecurringAndNonrecurringBasisAbstract_5a104bbe-1c8c-4cb3-a4d4-663daf2a2f0d" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_FairValueAssetsAndLiabilitiesMeasuredOnRecurringAndNonrecurringBasisAbstract"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FairValueAssetsAndLiabilitiesMeasuredOnRecurringAndNonrecurringBasisLineItems_bcdbbb7e-18b6-4a5f-b9e3-f11fa13f46d8" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_FairValueAssetsAndLiabilitiesMeasuredOnRecurringAndNonrecurringBasisAbstract_5a104bbe-1c8c-4cb3-a4d4-663daf2a2f0d" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_AssetsFairValueDisclosureAbstract_9339ac40-76c3-440c-9d9a-7b604bbe5dca" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_AssetsFairValueDisclosureAbstract"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FairValueAssetsAndLiabilitiesMeasuredOnRecurringAndNonrecurringBasisAbstract_5a104bbe-1c8c-4cb3-a4d4-663daf2a2f0d" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_AssetsFairValueDisclosureAbstract_9339ac40-76c3-440c-9d9a-7b604bbe5dca" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtSecurities_e258d2a0-1e82-41e5-81ee-8e2d06be6187" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtSecurities"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_AssetsFairValueDisclosureAbstract_9339ac40-76c3-440c-9d9a-7b604bbe5dca" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtSecurities_e258d2a0-1e82-41e5-81ee-8e2d06be6187" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_TradingSecuritiesDebt_c228f26f-a2ef-4176-b719-28b8f9525da4" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_TradingSecuritiesDebt"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_AssetsFairValueDisclosureAbstract_9339ac40-76c3-440c-9d9a-7b604bbe5dca" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_TradingSecuritiesDebt_c228f26f-a2ef-4176-b719-28b8f9525da4" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_EquitySecuritiesFvNi_ddfe09d1-5561-4453-adf9-d3fd2efa8400" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_EquitySecuritiesFvNi"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_AssetsFairValueDisclosureAbstract_9339ac40-76c3-440c-9d9a-7b604bbe5dca" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_EquitySecuritiesFvNi_ddfe09d1-5561-4453-adf9-d3fd2efa8400" xlink:type="arc" order="3"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_VariableInterestEntityAssets_89be62e9-64bd-4623-b81d-40686de49574" xlink:href="afg-20240930.xsd#afg_VariableInterestEntityAssets"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_AssetsFairValueDisclosureAbstract_9339ac40-76c3-440c-9d9a-7b604bbe5dca" xlink:to="loc_afg_VariableInterestEntityAssets_89be62e9-64bd-4623-b81d-40686de49574" xlink:type="arc" order="4"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_DerivativeAssets_a4b9ea20-006d-45d7-b082-9dcb2c536bb8" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_DerivativeAssets"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_AssetsFairValueDisclosureAbstract_9339ac40-76c3-440c-9d9a-7b604bbe5dca" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_DerivativeAssets_a4b9ea20-006d-45d7-b082-9dcb2c536bb8" xlink:type="arc" order="5"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_AssetsFairValueDisclosure_e6796593-5443-4e00-99bd-c149eb72a3a4" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_AssetsFairValueDisclosure"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_AssetsFairValueDisclosureAbstract_9339ac40-76c3-440c-9d9a-7b604bbe5dca" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_AssetsFairValueDisclosure_e6796593-5443-4e00-99bd-c149eb72a3a4" xlink:type="arc" order="6"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_LiabilitiesFairValueDisclosureAbstract_0b9b88c6-034f-486f-8d78-c6d99cb153ff" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_LiabilitiesFairValueDisclosureAbstract"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FairValueAssetsAndLiabilitiesMeasuredOnRecurringAndNonrecurringBasisAbstract_5a104bbe-1c8c-4cb3-a4d4-663daf2a2f0d" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_LiabilitiesFairValueDisclosureAbstract_0b9b88c6-034f-486f-8d78-c6d99cb153ff" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_BusinessCombinationContingentConsiderationLiability_3ded61db-f314-4e8d-8f8e-39934c173f19" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_BusinessCombinationContingentConsiderationLiability"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_LiabilitiesFairValueDisclosureAbstract_0b9b88c6-034f-486f-8d78-c6d99cb153ff" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_BusinessCombinationContingentConsiderationLiability_3ded61db-f314-4e8d-8f8e-39934c173f19" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_VariableInterestEntityLiabilities_f88666c9-a288-48a4-a508-65cd7359acb1" xlink:href="afg-20240930.xsd#afg_VariableInterestEntityLiabilities"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_LiabilitiesFairValueDisclosureAbstract_0b9b88c6-034f-486f-8d78-c6d99cb153ff" xlink:to="loc_afg_VariableInterestEntityLiabilities_f88666c9-a288-48a4-a508-65cd7359acb1" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_DerivativeLiabilities_75dabe97-fcb8-4dce-9d06-a5e80aabe63a" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_DerivativeLiabilities"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_LiabilitiesFairValueDisclosureAbstract_0b9b88c6-034f-486f-8d78-c6d99cb153ff" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_DerivativeLiabilities_75dabe97-fcb8-4dce-9d06-a5e80aabe63a" xlink:type="arc" order="3"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_LiabilitiesFairValueDisclosure_ac583799-8360-4fae-9f1b-b89a651eb23d" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_LiabilitiesFairValueDisclosure"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_LiabilitiesFairValueDisclosureAbstract_0b9b88c6-034f-486f-8d78-c6d99cb153ff" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_LiabilitiesFairValueDisclosure_ac583799-8360-4fae-9f1b-b89a651eb23d" xlink:type="arc" order="4"/>
  </link:definitionLink>
  <link:roleRef roleURI="http://www.afginc.com/role/FairValueMeasurementsChangesinbalancesofLevel3financialassetscarriedatfairvalueDetails" xlink:type="simple" xlink:href="afg-20240930.xsd#FairValueMeasurementsChangesinbalancesofLevel3financialassetscarriedatfairvalueDetails"/>
  <link:definitionLink xlink:role="http://www.afginc.com/role/FairValueMeasurementsChangesinbalancesofLevel3financialassetscarriedatfairvalueDetails" xlink:type="extended">
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_FairValueAssetsMeasuredOnRecurringBasisUnobservableInputReconciliationLineItems_6e1f2bb6-8f0b-4490-b679-f9ca0269bdfa" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_FairValueAssetsMeasuredOnRecurringBasisUnobservableInputReconciliationLineItems"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_FairValueAssetsMeasuredOnRecurringBasisUnobservableInputReconciliationTable_6bfcc426-de38-4670-8b8d-a28d9e98fd23" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_FairValueAssetsMeasuredOnRecurringBasisUnobservableInputReconciliationTable"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/all" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FairValueAssetsMeasuredOnRecurringBasisUnobservableInputReconciliationLineItems_6e1f2bb6-8f0b-4490-b679-f9ca0269bdfa" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_FairValueAssetsMeasuredOnRecurringBasisUnobservableInputReconciliationTable_6bfcc426-de38-4670-8b8d-a28d9e98fd23" xlink:type="arc" order="1" xbrldt:closed="true" xbrldt:contextElement="segment"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_FairValueByAssetClassAxis_0942725a-d4c3-4634-9404-8ea5087f04aa" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_FairValueByAssetClassAxis"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/hypercube-dimension" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FairValueAssetsMeasuredOnRecurringBasisUnobservableInputReconciliationTable_6bfcc426-de38-4670-8b8d-a28d9e98fd23" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_FairValueByAssetClassAxis_0942725a-d4c3-4634-9404-8ea5087f04aa" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_FairValueAssetsMeasuredOnRecurringBasisUnobservableInputReconciliationByAssetClassDomain_0942725a-d4c3-4634-9404-8ea5087f04aa_default" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_FairValueAssetsMeasuredOnRecurringBasisUnobservableInputReconciliationByAssetClassDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-default" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FairValueByAssetClassAxis_0942725a-d4c3-4634-9404-8ea5087f04aa" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_FairValueAssetsMeasuredOnRecurringBasisUnobservableInputReconciliationByAssetClassDomain_0942725a-d4c3-4634-9404-8ea5087f04aa_default" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_FairValueAssetsMeasuredOnRecurringBasisUnobservableInputReconciliationByAssetClassDomain_6d45039d-4832-438a-814c-658f85c8fb8d" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_FairValueAssetsMeasuredOnRecurringBasisUnobservableInputReconciliationByAssetClassDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-domain" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FairValueByAssetClassAxis_0942725a-d4c3-4634-9404-8ea5087f04aa" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_FairValueAssetsMeasuredOnRecurringBasisUnobservableInputReconciliationByAssetClassDomain_6d45039d-4832-438a-814c-658f85c8fb8d" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_FixedMaturitiesMember_6ea891d8-8795-4359-a220-3d8853b4ef8b" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_FixedMaturitiesMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FairValueAssetsMeasuredOnRecurringBasisUnobservableInputReconciliationByAssetClassDomain_6d45039d-4832-438a-814c-658f85c8fb8d" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_FixedMaturitiesMember_6ea891d8-8795-4359-a220-3d8853b4ef8b" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_USTreasuryAndGovernmentMember_c2a155d9-9cb9-4381-bd48-ac930ca66961" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_USTreasuryAndGovernmentMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FixedMaturitiesMember_6ea891d8-8795-4359-a220-3d8853b4ef8b" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_USTreasuryAndGovernmentMember_c2a155d9-9cb9-4381-bd48-ac930ca66961" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_USStatesAndPoliticalSubdivisionsMember_ae583d0f-f8d5-4339-b249-be8525263450" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_USStatesAndPoliticalSubdivisionsMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FixedMaturitiesMember_6ea891d8-8795-4359-a220-3d8853b4ef8b" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_USStatesAndPoliticalSubdivisionsMember_ae583d0f-f8d5-4339-b249-be8525263450" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_ResidentialMortgageBackedSecuritiesMember_1d39d18f-e6d5-4dd0-9082-f09be1f81fbc" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_ResidentialMortgageBackedSecuritiesMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FixedMaturitiesMember_6ea891d8-8795-4359-a220-3d8853b4ef8b" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_ResidentialMortgageBackedSecuritiesMember_1d39d18f-e6d5-4dd0-9082-f09be1f81fbc" xlink:type="arc" order="3"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_CommercialMortgageBackedSecuritiesMember_7f72d882-d072-4d08-a847-c500898440cf" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_CommercialMortgageBackedSecuritiesMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FixedMaturitiesMember_6ea891d8-8795-4359-a220-3d8853b4ef8b" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_CommercialMortgageBackedSecuritiesMember_7f72d882-d072-4d08-a847-c500898440cf" xlink:type="arc" order="4"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_CollateralizedLoanObligationsMember_0a827447-4a53-4a52-9eb2-1181825f8fcb" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_CollateralizedLoanObligationsMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FixedMaturitiesMember_6ea891d8-8795-4359-a220-3d8853b4ef8b" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_CollateralizedLoanObligationsMember_0a827447-4a53-4a52-9eb2-1181825f8fcb" xlink:type="arc" order="5"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_AssetBackedSecuritiesMember_c43234e8-d04b-429b-82fd-31506f237bc6" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_AssetBackedSecuritiesMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FixedMaturitiesMember_6ea891d8-8795-4359-a220-3d8853b4ef8b" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_AssetBackedSecuritiesMember_c43234e8-d04b-429b-82fd-31506f237bc6" xlink:type="arc" order="6"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_CorporateDebtSecuritiesMember_83241435-1c48-44dd-8263-44d5118f07a2" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_CorporateDebtSecuritiesMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FixedMaturitiesMember_6ea891d8-8795-4359-a220-3d8853b4ef8b" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_CorporateDebtSecuritiesMember_83241435-1c48-44dd-8263-44d5118f07a2" xlink:type="arc" order="7"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_TradingFixedMaturitiesMember_2f98c81f-cf8d-404b-8603-cecc4f439e87" xlink:href="afg-20240930.xsd#afg_TradingFixedMaturitiesMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FairValueAssetsMeasuredOnRecurringBasisUnobservableInputReconciliationByAssetClassDomain_6d45039d-4832-438a-814c-658f85c8fb8d" xlink:to="loc_afg_TradingFixedMaturitiesMember_2f98c81f-cf8d-404b-8603-cecc4f439e87" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_EquitySecuritiesMember_73761e4f-9616-4402-a4ab-3ddd57fc329a" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_EquitySecuritiesMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FairValueAssetsMeasuredOnRecurringBasisUnobservableInputReconciliationByAssetClassDomain_6d45039d-4832-438a-814c-658f85c8fb8d" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_EquitySecuritiesMember_73761e4f-9616-4402-a4ab-3ddd57fc329a" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_AssetsOfManagedInvestmentEntitiesMember_e3cca538-90fd-4c6b-ac97-03c27d1d27c8" xlink:href="afg-20240930.xsd#afg_AssetsOfManagedInvestmentEntitiesMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FairValueAssetsMeasuredOnRecurringBasisUnobservableInputReconciliationByAssetClassDomain_6d45039d-4832-438a-814c-658f85c8fb8d" xlink:to="loc_afg_AssetsOfManagedInvestmentEntitiesMember_e3cca538-90fd-4c6b-ac97-03c27d1d27c8" xlink:type="arc" order="3"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_FairValueAssetsMeasuredOnRecurringBasisUnobservableInputReconciliationCalculationRollForward_b643a992-24ab-4b29-a361-d23caf5c5914" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_FairValueAssetsMeasuredOnRecurringBasisUnobservableInputReconciliationCalculationRollForward"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FairValueAssetsMeasuredOnRecurringBasisUnobservableInputReconciliationLineItems_6e1f2bb6-8f0b-4490-b679-f9ca0269bdfa" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_FairValueAssetsMeasuredOnRecurringBasisUnobservableInputReconciliationCalculationRollForward_b643a992-24ab-4b29-a361-d23caf5c5914" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_FairValueMeasurementWithUnobservableInputsReconciliationRecurringBasisAssetValue_ce88585c-d653-445b-8b56-d2a3dfdbe3e0" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_FairValueMeasurementWithUnobservableInputsReconciliationRecurringBasisAssetValue"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FairValueAssetsMeasuredOnRecurringBasisUnobservableInputReconciliationCalculationRollForward_b643a992-24ab-4b29-a361-d23caf5c5914" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_FairValueMeasurementWithUnobservableInputsReconciliationRecurringBasisAssetValue_ce88585c-d653-445b-8b56-d2a3dfdbe3e0" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_FairValueMeasurementWithUnobservableInputsReconciliationRecurringBasisAssetGainLossIncludedInEarnings1_140dece4-59d0-4440-ad78-54e4fbfdd6d9" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_FairValueMeasurementWithUnobservableInputsReconciliationRecurringBasisAssetGainLossIncludedInEarnings1"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FairValueAssetsMeasuredOnRecurringBasisUnobservableInputReconciliationCalculationRollForward_b643a992-24ab-4b29-a361-d23caf5c5914" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_FairValueMeasurementWithUnobservableInputsReconciliationRecurringBasisAssetGainLossIncludedInEarnings1_140dece4-59d0-4440-ad78-54e4fbfdd6d9" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_FairValueMeasurementWithUnobservableInputsReconciliationRecurringBasisAssetGainLossIncludedInOtherComprehensiveIncomeLoss_33454d83-48b1-4cfc-a9da-281714d41d22" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_FairValueMeasurementWithUnobservableInputsReconciliationRecurringBasisAssetGainLossIncludedInOtherComprehensiveIncomeLoss"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FairValueAssetsMeasuredOnRecurringBasisUnobservableInputReconciliationCalculationRollForward_b643a992-24ab-4b29-a361-d23caf5c5914" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_FairValueMeasurementWithUnobservableInputsReconciliationRecurringBasisAssetGainLossIncludedInOtherComprehensiveIncomeLoss_33454d83-48b1-4cfc-a9da-281714d41d22" xlink:type="arc" order="3"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_FairValueMeasurementWithUnobservableInputsReconciliationRecurringBasisAssetPurchases_1ce8112c-4f88-46b4-89d1-96544384f8fd" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_FairValueMeasurementWithUnobservableInputsReconciliationRecurringBasisAssetPurchases"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FairValueAssetsMeasuredOnRecurringBasisUnobservableInputReconciliationCalculationRollForward_b643a992-24ab-4b29-a361-d23caf5c5914" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_FairValueMeasurementWithUnobservableInputsReconciliationRecurringBasisAssetPurchases_1ce8112c-4f88-46b4-89d1-96544384f8fd" xlink:type="arc" order="4"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_FairValueMeasurementWithUnobservableInputsReconciliationRecurringBasisAssetSales_8828d438-8f1a-485a-93d1-55c63dabdd4a" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_FairValueMeasurementWithUnobservableInputsReconciliationRecurringBasisAssetSales"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FairValueAssetsMeasuredOnRecurringBasisUnobservableInputReconciliationCalculationRollForward_b643a992-24ab-4b29-a361-d23caf5c5914" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_FairValueMeasurementWithUnobservableInputsReconciliationRecurringBasisAssetSales_8828d438-8f1a-485a-93d1-55c63dabdd4a" xlink:type="arc" order="5"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_FairValueMeasurementWithUnobservableInputsReconciliationRecurringBasisAssetTransfersIntoLevel3_4ab41018-aa30-4441-9c6d-f1c6e1a59c0a" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_FairValueMeasurementWithUnobservableInputsReconciliationRecurringBasisAssetTransfersIntoLevel3"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FairValueAssetsMeasuredOnRecurringBasisUnobservableInputReconciliationCalculationRollForward_b643a992-24ab-4b29-a361-d23caf5c5914" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_FairValueMeasurementWithUnobservableInputsReconciliationRecurringBasisAssetTransfersIntoLevel3_4ab41018-aa30-4441-9c6d-f1c6e1a59c0a" xlink:type="arc" order="6"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_FairValueMeasurementWithUnobservableInputsReconciliationRecurringBasisAssetTransfersOutOfLevel3_2a93d379-c15e-4600-8c00-9d0b2e597337" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_FairValueMeasurementWithUnobservableInputsReconciliationRecurringBasisAssetTransfersOutOfLevel3"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FairValueAssetsMeasuredOnRecurringBasisUnobservableInputReconciliationCalculationRollForward_b643a992-24ab-4b29-a361-d23caf5c5914" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_FairValueMeasurementWithUnobservableInputsReconciliationRecurringBasisAssetTransfersOutOfLevel3_2a93d379-c15e-4600-8c00-9d0b2e597337" xlink:type="arc" order="7"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_FairValueMeasurementWithUnobservableInputsReconciliationRecurringBasisAssetValue_af5ea5f6-f79c-45b3-88f9-fec1edb3191a" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_FairValueMeasurementWithUnobservableInputsReconciliationRecurringBasisAssetValue"/>
  </link:definitionLink>
  <link:roleRef roleURI="http://www.afginc.com/role/FairValueMeasurementsChangesinbalancesofLevel3financialliabilitiescarriedatfairvalueDetails" xlink:type="simple" xlink:href="afg-20240930.xsd#FairValueMeasurementsChangesinbalancesofLevel3financialliabilitiescarriedatfairvalueDetails"/>
  <link:definitionLink xlink:role="http://www.afginc.com/role/FairValueMeasurementsChangesinbalancesofLevel3financialliabilitiescarriedatfairvalueDetails" xlink:type="extended">
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_FairValueLiabilitiesMeasuredOnRecurringBasisUnobservableInputReconciliationLineItems_13922133-af3b-4682-8be9-5a7fdd657ac6" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_FairValueLiabilitiesMeasuredOnRecurringBasisUnobservableInputReconciliationLineItems"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_FairValueLiabilitiesMeasuredOnRecurringBasisUnobservableInputReconciliationTable_12d6d001-2e6c-45f8-9ef9-6a47f85a8162" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_FairValueLiabilitiesMeasuredOnRecurringBasisUnobservableInputReconciliationTable"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/all" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FairValueLiabilitiesMeasuredOnRecurringBasisUnobservableInputReconciliationLineItems_13922133-af3b-4682-8be9-5a7fdd657ac6" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_FairValueLiabilitiesMeasuredOnRecurringBasisUnobservableInputReconciliationTable_12d6d001-2e6c-45f8-9ef9-6a47f85a8162" xlink:type="arc" order="1" xbrldt:closed="true" xbrldt:contextElement="segment"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_FairValueByLiabilityClassAxis_13e0e4d0-c33c-4541-b967-46d5fdcd1213" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_FairValueByLiabilityClassAxis"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/hypercube-dimension" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FairValueLiabilitiesMeasuredOnRecurringBasisUnobservableInputReconciliationTable_12d6d001-2e6c-45f8-9ef9-6a47f85a8162" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_FairValueByLiabilityClassAxis_13e0e4d0-c33c-4541-b967-46d5fdcd1213" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_FairValueLiabilitiesMeasuredOnRecurringBasisUnobservableInputReconciliationByLiabilityClassDomain_13e0e4d0-c33c-4541-b967-46d5fdcd1213_default" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_FairValueLiabilitiesMeasuredOnRecurringBasisUnobservableInputReconciliationByLiabilityClassDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-default" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FairValueByLiabilityClassAxis_13e0e4d0-c33c-4541-b967-46d5fdcd1213" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_FairValueLiabilitiesMeasuredOnRecurringBasisUnobservableInputReconciliationByLiabilityClassDomain_13e0e4d0-c33c-4541-b967-46d5fdcd1213_default" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_FairValueLiabilitiesMeasuredOnRecurringBasisUnobservableInputReconciliationByLiabilityClassDomain_573cd200-5b3e-42ea-968c-34cf7f3a6a9e" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_FairValueLiabilitiesMeasuredOnRecurringBasisUnobservableInputReconciliationByLiabilityClassDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-domain" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FairValueByLiabilityClassAxis_13e0e4d0-c33c-4541-b967-46d5fdcd1213" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_FairValueLiabilitiesMeasuredOnRecurringBasisUnobservableInputReconciliationByLiabilityClassDomain_573cd200-5b3e-42ea-968c-34cf7f3a6a9e" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_ContingentConsiderationAcquisitionsMember_46c336bd-ef42-4ea0-b72d-1b50fd13d4da" xlink:href="afg-20240930.xsd#afg_ContingentConsiderationAcquisitionsMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FairValueLiabilitiesMeasuredOnRecurringBasisUnobservableInputReconciliationByLiabilityClassDomain_573cd200-5b3e-42ea-968c-34cf7f3a6a9e" xlink:to="loc_afg_ContingentConsiderationAcquisitionsMember_46c336bd-ef42-4ea0-b72d-1b50fd13d4da" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_FairValueLiabilitiesMeasuredOnRecurringBasisUnobservableInputReconciliationCalculationRollForward_797583d9-9ee0-452d-8374-9f8c55962818" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_FairValueLiabilitiesMeasuredOnRecurringBasisUnobservableInputReconciliationCalculationRollForward"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FairValueLiabilitiesMeasuredOnRecurringBasisUnobservableInputReconciliationLineItems_13922133-af3b-4682-8be9-5a7fdd657ac6" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_FairValueLiabilitiesMeasuredOnRecurringBasisUnobservableInputReconciliationCalculationRollForward_797583d9-9ee0-452d-8374-9f8c55962818" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_FairValueMeasurementWithUnobservableInputsReconciliationsRecurringBasisLiabilityValue_9155bfc9-ddb3-4d46-844d-5450f5937500" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_FairValueMeasurementWithUnobservableInputsReconciliationsRecurringBasisLiabilityValue"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FairValueLiabilitiesMeasuredOnRecurringBasisUnobservableInputReconciliationCalculationRollForward_797583d9-9ee0-452d-8374-9f8c55962818" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_FairValueMeasurementWithUnobservableInputsReconciliationsRecurringBasisLiabilityValue_9155bfc9-ddb3-4d46-844d-5450f5937500" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_FairValueMeasurementWithUnobservableInputsReconciliationRecurringBasisLiabilityGainLossIncludedInEarnings_465cc740-91a9-4157-a271-9afa3080579d" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_FairValueMeasurementWithUnobservableInputsReconciliationRecurringBasisLiabilityGainLossIncludedInEarnings"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FairValueLiabilitiesMeasuredOnRecurringBasisUnobservableInputReconciliationCalculationRollForward_797583d9-9ee0-452d-8374-9f8c55962818" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_FairValueMeasurementWithUnobservableInputsReconciliationRecurringBasisLiabilityGainLossIncludedInEarnings_465cc740-91a9-4157-a271-9afa3080579d" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_FairValueMeasurementWithUnobservableInputsReconciliationRecurringBasisLiabilityGainLossIncludedInOtherComprehensiveIncome_f94c98e2-da6d-4212-88a7-fa0ba33bc6a4" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_FairValueMeasurementWithUnobservableInputsReconciliationRecurringBasisLiabilityGainLossIncludedInOtherComprehensiveIncome"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FairValueLiabilitiesMeasuredOnRecurringBasisUnobservableInputReconciliationCalculationRollForward_797583d9-9ee0-452d-8374-9f8c55962818" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_FairValueMeasurementWithUnobservableInputsReconciliationRecurringBasisLiabilityGainLossIncludedInOtherComprehensiveIncome_f94c98e2-da6d-4212-88a7-fa0ba33bc6a4" xlink:type="arc" order="3"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_FairValueMeasurementWithUnobservableInputsReconciliationRecurringBasisLiabilityIssues_1f80dc3e-6953-48b4-b57e-02f5e0c41a53" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_FairValueMeasurementWithUnobservableInputsReconciliationRecurringBasisLiabilityIssues"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FairValueLiabilitiesMeasuredOnRecurringBasisUnobservableInputReconciliationCalculationRollForward_797583d9-9ee0-452d-8374-9f8c55962818" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_FairValueMeasurementWithUnobservableInputsReconciliationRecurringBasisLiabilityIssues_1f80dc3e-6953-48b4-b57e-02f5e0c41a53" xlink:type="arc" order="4"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_FairValueMeasurementWithUnobservableInputsReconciliationRecurringBasisLiabilitySettlements_9ed7cfd8-4271-4cdf-96e2-a3f5400f518e" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_FairValueMeasurementWithUnobservableInputsReconciliationRecurringBasisLiabilitySettlements"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FairValueLiabilitiesMeasuredOnRecurringBasisUnobservableInputReconciliationCalculationRollForward_797583d9-9ee0-452d-8374-9f8c55962818" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_FairValueMeasurementWithUnobservableInputsReconciliationRecurringBasisLiabilitySettlements_9ed7cfd8-4271-4cdf-96e2-a3f5400f518e" xlink:type="arc" order="5"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_FairValueMeasurementWithUnobservableInputsReconciliationLiabilityTransfersIntoLevel3_0de8393c-73ef-41d4-bbaf-8910e073d161" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_FairValueMeasurementWithUnobservableInputsReconciliationLiabilityTransfersIntoLevel3"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FairValueLiabilitiesMeasuredOnRecurringBasisUnobservableInputReconciliationCalculationRollForward_797583d9-9ee0-452d-8374-9f8c55962818" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_FairValueMeasurementWithUnobservableInputsReconciliationLiabilityTransfersIntoLevel3_0de8393c-73ef-41d4-bbaf-8910e073d161" xlink:type="arc" order="6"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_FairValueMeasurementWithUnobservableInputsReconciliationLiabilityTransfersOutOfLevel3_9be52aff-ae1d-49a0-8057-be04d999bb04" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_FairValueMeasurementWithUnobservableInputsReconciliationLiabilityTransfersOutOfLevel3"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FairValueLiabilitiesMeasuredOnRecurringBasisUnobservableInputReconciliationCalculationRollForward_797583d9-9ee0-452d-8374-9f8c55962818" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_FairValueMeasurementWithUnobservableInputsReconciliationLiabilityTransfersOutOfLevel3_9be52aff-ae1d-49a0-8057-be04d999bb04" xlink:type="arc" order="7"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_FairValueMeasurementWithUnobservableInputsReconciliationsRecurringBasisLiabilityValue_22fe452b-9c6f-4194-bcc2-35249bd5f869" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_FairValueMeasurementWithUnobservableInputsReconciliationsRecurringBasisLiabilityValue"/>
  </link:definitionLink>
  <link:roleRef roleURI="http://www.afginc.com/role/FairValueMeasurementsThecarryingvalueandfairvalueoffinancialinstrumentsDetails" xlink:type="simple" xlink:href="afg-20240930.xsd#FairValueMeasurementsThecarryingvalueandfairvalueoffinancialinstrumentsDetails"/>
  <link:definitionLink xlink:role="http://www.afginc.com/role/FairValueMeasurementsThecarryingvalueandfairvalueoffinancialinstrumentsDetails" xlink:type="extended">
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_FairValueBalanceSheetGroupingFinancialStatementCaptionsLineItems_93c50ffd-d5bc-4181-b5b4-eda0cf354ebf" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_FairValueBalanceSheetGroupingFinancialStatementCaptionsLineItems"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_FairValueByBalanceSheetGroupingTable_9d1d3dd8-058b-4f96-8953-0a98609445c6" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_FairValueByBalanceSheetGroupingTable"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/all" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FairValueBalanceSheetGroupingFinancialStatementCaptionsLineItems_93c50ffd-d5bc-4181-b5b4-eda0cf354ebf" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_FairValueByBalanceSheetGroupingTable_9d1d3dd8-058b-4f96-8953-0a98609445c6" xlink:type="arc" order="1" xbrldt:closed="true" xbrldt:contextElement="segment"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_FairValueByMeasurementBasisAxis_48348668-d127-4abe-a236-24bdaeb5881d" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_FairValueByMeasurementBasisAxis"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/hypercube-dimension" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FairValueByBalanceSheetGroupingTable_9d1d3dd8-058b-4f96-8953-0a98609445c6" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_FairValueByMeasurementBasisAxis_48348668-d127-4abe-a236-24bdaeb5881d" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_PortionAtFairValueFairValueDisclosureMember_48348668-d127-4abe-a236-24bdaeb5881d_default" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_PortionAtFairValueFairValueDisclosureMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-default" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FairValueByMeasurementBasisAxis_48348668-d127-4abe-a236-24bdaeb5881d" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_PortionAtFairValueFairValueDisclosureMember_48348668-d127-4abe-a236-24bdaeb5881d_default" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_FairValueDisclosureItemAmountsDomain_42393360-932e-4d44-a17a-b0038f445ec6" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_FairValueDisclosureItemAmountsDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-domain" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FairValueByMeasurementBasisAxis_48348668-d127-4abe-a236-24bdaeb5881d" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_FairValueDisclosureItemAmountsDomain_42393360-932e-4d44-a17a-b0038f445ec6" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_PortionAtFairValueFairValueDisclosureMember_5d720fce-135a-4c38-8636-93e11812d78b" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_PortionAtFairValueFairValueDisclosureMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FairValueDisclosureItemAmountsDomain_42393360-932e-4d44-a17a-b0038f445ec6" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_PortionAtFairValueFairValueDisclosureMember_5d720fce-135a-4c38-8636-93e11812d78b" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_CarryingReportedAmountFairValueDisclosureMember_533b7800-cdbd-45c9-b037-1f1086e60ef2" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_CarryingReportedAmountFairValueDisclosureMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_PortionAtFairValueFairValueDisclosureMember_5d720fce-135a-4c38-8636-93e11812d78b" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_CarryingReportedAmountFairValueDisclosureMember_533b7800-cdbd-45c9-b037-1f1086e60ef2" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_EstimateOfFairValueFairValueDisclosureMember_5ef5de57-d8cf-45a6-89a7-3b275115e95b" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_EstimateOfFairValueFairValueDisclosureMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_PortionAtFairValueFairValueDisclosureMember_5d720fce-135a-4c38-8636-93e11812d78b" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_EstimateOfFairValueFairValueDisclosureMember_5ef5de57-d8cf-45a6-89a7-3b275115e95b" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_FairValueByFairValueHierarchyLevelAxis_0dbab710-3671-4da1-b5af-5a1046198c18" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_FairValueByFairValueHierarchyLevelAxis"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/hypercube-dimension" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FairValueByBalanceSheetGroupingTable_9d1d3dd8-058b-4f96-8953-0a98609445c6" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_FairValueByFairValueHierarchyLevelAxis_0dbab710-3671-4da1-b5af-5a1046198c18" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_FairValueMeasurementsFairValueHierarchyDomain_0dbab710-3671-4da1-b5af-5a1046198c18_default" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_FairValueMeasurementsFairValueHierarchyDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-default" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FairValueByFairValueHierarchyLevelAxis_0dbab710-3671-4da1-b5af-5a1046198c18" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_FairValueMeasurementsFairValueHierarchyDomain_0dbab710-3671-4da1-b5af-5a1046198c18_default" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_FairValueMeasurementsFairValueHierarchyDomain_fcc539ad-3002-4537-be0b-7396534bc465" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_FairValueMeasurementsFairValueHierarchyDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-domain" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FairValueByFairValueHierarchyLevelAxis_0dbab710-3671-4da1-b5af-5a1046198c18" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_FairValueMeasurementsFairValueHierarchyDomain_fcc539ad-3002-4537-be0b-7396534bc465" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_FairValueInputsLevel1Member_09400eb0-dff8-4a12-8b23-e467fc218376" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_FairValueInputsLevel1Member"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FairValueMeasurementsFairValueHierarchyDomain_fcc539ad-3002-4537-be0b-7396534bc465" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_FairValueInputsLevel1Member_09400eb0-dff8-4a12-8b23-e467fc218376" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_FairValueInputsLevel2Member_496dfc10-f2bf-4032-bed2-fb8c0fa052b6" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_FairValueInputsLevel2Member"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FairValueMeasurementsFairValueHierarchyDomain_fcc539ad-3002-4537-be0b-7396534bc465" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_FairValueInputsLevel2Member_496dfc10-f2bf-4032-bed2-fb8c0fa052b6" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_FairValueInputsLevel3Member_075e5315-f417-4f80-b9f5-0f75cfb5a3d1" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_FairValueInputsLevel3Member"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FairValueMeasurementsFairValueHierarchyDomain_fcc539ad-3002-4537-be0b-7396534bc465" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_FairValueInputsLevel3Member_075e5315-f417-4f80-b9f5-0f75cfb5a3d1" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_FinancialInstrumentsFinancialAssetsAndLiabilitiesBalanceSheetGroupingsAbstract_d7371e6f-aa2b-4ed5-9562-4467cc08eb88" xlink:href="afg-20240930.xsd#afg_FinancialInstrumentsFinancialAssetsAndLiabilitiesBalanceSheetGroupingsAbstract"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FairValueBalanceSheetGroupingFinancialStatementCaptionsLineItems_93c50ffd-d5bc-4181-b5b4-eda0cf354ebf" xlink:to="loc_afg_FinancialInstrumentsFinancialAssetsAndLiabilitiesBalanceSheetGroupingsAbstract_d7371e6f-aa2b-4ed5-9562-4467cc08eb88" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_FinancialInstrumentsFinancialAssetsBalanceSheetGroupingsAbstract_77412509-58a3-4218-8c18-02830c6813b9" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_FinancialInstrumentsFinancialAssetsBalanceSheetGroupingsAbstract"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_afg_FinancialInstrumentsFinancialAssetsAndLiabilitiesBalanceSheetGroupingsAbstract_d7371e6f-aa2b-4ed5-9562-4467cc08eb88" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_FinancialInstrumentsFinancialAssetsBalanceSheetGroupingsAbstract_77412509-58a3-4218-8c18-02830c6813b9" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_CashAndCashEquivalentsFairValueDisclosure_fba9295e-5cfa-4d57-be78-23a708ff6c13" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_CashAndCashEquivalentsFairValueDisclosure"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FinancialInstrumentsFinancialAssetsBalanceSheetGroupingsAbstract_77412509-58a3-4218-8c18-02830c6813b9" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_CashAndCashEquivalentsFairValueDisclosure_fba9295e-5cfa-4d57-be78-23a708ff6c13" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_MortgageLoansOnRealEstateCommercialAndConsumerNet_62e85161-1b4e-4be5-b34f-ad59bd7325ab" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_MortgageLoansOnRealEstateCommercialAndConsumerNet"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FinancialInstrumentsFinancialAssetsBalanceSheetGroupingsAbstract_77412509-58a3-4218-8c18-02830c6813b9" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_MortgageLoansOnRealEstateCommercialAndConsumerNet_62e85161-1b4e-4be5-b34f-ad59bd7325ab" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_FinancialAssetsNotAccountedForAtFairValue_876b51a2-c744-40af-a497-0a293010e221" xlink:href="afg-20240930.xsd#afg_FinancialAssetsNotAccountedForAtFairValue"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FinancialInstrumentsFinancialAssetsBalanceSheetGroupingsAbstract_77412509-58a3-4218-8c18-02830c6813b9" xlink:to="loc_afg_FinancialAssetsNotAccountedForAtFairValue_876b51a2-c744-40af-a497-0a293010e221" xlink:type="arc" order="3"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_LongTermDebt_eb4389a9-3d86-46dd-aaab-b97ade800d4d" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_LongTermDebt"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_afg_FinancialInstrumentsFinancialAssetsAndLiabilitiesBalanceSheetGroupingsAbstract_d7371e6f-aa2b-4ed5-9562-4467cc08eb88" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_LongTermDebt_eb4389a9-3d86-46dd-aaab-b97ade800d4d" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_FinancialLiabilitiesNotAccountedForAtFairValue_1edb4ea7-10ed-4bfa-a759-13484355a693" xlink:href="afg-20240930.xsd#afg_FinancialLiabilitiesNotAccountedForAtFairValue"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_afg_FinancialInstrumentsFinancialAssetsAndLiabilitiesBalanceSheetGroupingsAbstract_d7371e6f-aa2b-4ed5-9562-4467cc08eb88" xlink:to="loc_afg_FinancialLiabilitiesNotAccountedForAtFairValue_1edb4ea7-10ed-4bfa-a759-13484355a693" xlink:type="arc" order="3"/>
  </link:definitionLink>
  <link:roleRef roleURI="http://www.afginc.com/role/InvestmentsNarrativeDetails" xlink:type="simple" xlink:href="afg-20240930.xsd#InvestmentsNarrativeDetails"/>
  <link:definitionLink xlink:role="http://www.afginc.com/role/InvestmentsNarrativeDetails" xlink:type="extended">
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfInvestmentsLineItems_abcf070f-62b7-4ee2-8997-2dce0746a882" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_ScheduleOfInvestmentsLineItems"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfInvestmentsTable_7e4bcf23-7315-4ff6-8af5-6f056700d52c" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_ScheduleOfInvestmentsTable"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/all" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfInvestmentsLineItems_abcf070f-62b7-4ee2-8997-2dce0746a882" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfInvestmentsTable_7e4bcf23-7315-4ff6-8af5-6f056700d52c" xlink:type="arc" order="1" xbrldt:closed="true" xbrldt:contextElement="segment"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_FinancialInstrumentAxis_daa58fea-76a1-4e37-ba2d-05d9d81b160d" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_FinancialInstrumentAxis"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/hypercube-dimension" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfInvestmentsTable_7e4bcf23-7315-4ff6-8af5-6f056700d52c" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_FinancialInstrumentAxis_daa58fea-76a1-4e37-ba2d-05d9d81b160d" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_TransfersAndServicingOfFinancialInstrumentsTypesOfFinancialInstrumentsDomain_daa58fea-76a1-4e37-ba2d-05d9d81b160d_default" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_TransfersAndServicingOfFinancialInstrumentsTypesOfFinancialInstrumentsDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-default" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FinancialInstrumentAxis_daa58fea-76a1-4e37-ba2d-05d9d81b160d" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_TransfersAndServicingOfFinancialInstrumentsTypesOfFinancialInstrumentsDomain_daa58fea-76a1-4e37-ba2d-05d9d81b160d_default" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_TransfersAndServicingOfFinancialInstrumentsTypesOfFinancialInstrumentsDomain_7732c0b8-b8bc-41e0-801d-438c48e8334e" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_TransfersAndServicingOfFinancialInstrumentsTypesOfFinancialInstrumentsDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-domain" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FinancialInstrumentAxis_daa58fea-76a1-4e37-ba2d-05d9d81b160d" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_TransfersAndServicingOfFinancialInstrumentsTypesOfFinancialInstrumentsDomain_7732c0b8-b8bc-41e0-801d-438c48e8334e" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_FixedMaturitiesMember_5c1d7788-cf1d-4959-b596-5db2e5ff45c2" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_FixedMaturitiesMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_TransfersAndServicingOfFinancialInstrumentsTypesOfFinancialInstrumentsDomain_7732c0b8-b8bc-41e0-801d-438c48e8334e" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_FixedMaturitiesMember_5c1d7788-cf1d-4959-b596-5db2e5ff45c2" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_srt_MortgageLoansOnRealEstateDescriptionTypeOfPropertyAxis_e23d5456-5988-4639-acac-5d0505755b65" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/srt/2024/elts/srt-2024.xsd#srt_MortgageLoansOnRealEstateDescriptionTypeOfPropertyAxis"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/hypercube-dimension" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfInvestmentsTable_7e4bcf23-7315-4ff6-8af5-6f056700d52c" xlink:to="loc_srt_MortgageLoansOnRealEstateDescriptionTypeOfPropertyAxis_e23d5456-5988-4639-acac-5d0505755b65" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_srt_MortgageLoansOnRealEstateNamePropertyTypeDomain_e23d5456-5988-4639-acac-5d0505755b65_default" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/srt/2024/elts/srt-2024.xsd#srt_MortgageLoansOnRealEstateNamePropertyTypeDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-default" xlink:from="loc_srt_MortgageLoansOnRealEstateDescriptionTypeOfPropertyAxis_e23d5456-5988-4639-acac-5d0505755b65" xlink:to="loc_srt_MortgageLoansOnRealEstateNamePropertyTypeDomain_e23d5456-5988-4639-acac-5d0505755b65_default" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_srt_MortgageLoansOnRealEstateNamePropertyTypeDomain_8c625617-3a5a-4c5d-b574-98b300cd74d6" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/srt/2024/elts/srt-2024.xsd#srt_MortgageLoansOnRealEstateNamePropertyTypeDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-domain" xlink:from="loc_srt_MortgageLoansOnRealEstateDescriptionTypeOfPropertyAxis_e23d5456-5988-4639-acac-5d0505755b65" xlink:to="loc_srt_MortgageLoansOnRealEstateNamePropertyTypeDomain_8c625617-3a5a-4c5d-b574-98b300cd74d6" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_srt_MultifamilyMember_d28ed70b-3e78-4927-be04-1f7859ca6ef2" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/srt/2024/elts/srt-2024.xsd#srt_MultifamilyMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_srt_MortgageLoansOnRealEstateNamePropertyTypeDomain_8c625617-3a5a-4c5d-b574-98b300cd74d6" xlink:to="loc_srt_MultifamilyMember_d28ed70b-3e78-4927-be04-1f7859ca6ef2" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_RealEstateRelatedInvestmentsPercentByPropertyType_93307f6b-20d2-4452-a9e6-185530a1cf34" xlink:href="afg-20240930.xsd#afg_RealEstateRelatedInvestmentsPercentByPropertyType"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfInvestmentsLineItems_abcf070f-62b7-4ee2-8997-2dce0746a882" xlink:to="loc_afg_RealEstateRelatedInvestmentsPercentByPropertyType_93307f6b-20d2-4452-a9e6-185530a1cf34" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_UnfundedCommitmentsToLimitedPartnerships_651792f7-3c2c-4220-9a25-9718b76c498a" xlink:href="afg-20240930.xsd#afg_UnfundedCommitmentsToLimitedPartnerships"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfInvestmentsLineItems_abcf070f-62b7-4ee2-8997-2dce0746a882" xlink:to="loc_afg_UnfundedCommitmentsToLimitedPartnerships_651792f7-3c2c-4220-9a25-9718b76c498a" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_AvailableForSaleDebtSecuritiesAccumulatedGrossUnrealizedLossBeforeTax_b70986dc-6ac4-4100-bc76-91d08c2b7bbb" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_AvailableForSaleDebtSecuritiesAccumulatedGrossUnrealizedLossBeforeTax"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfInvestmentsLineItems_abcf070f-62b7-4ee2-8997-2dce0746a882" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_AvailableForSaleDebtSecuritiesAccumulatedGrossUnrealizedLossBeforeTax_b70986dc-6ac4-4100-bc76-91d08c2b7bbb" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_DebtSecuritiesAvailableForSaleUnrealizedLossPositionNumberOfPositions_3bd72915-6755-48fa-8c0b-a61e23a74fdd" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_DebtSecuritiesAvailableForSaleUnrealizedLossPositionNumberOfPositions"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfInvestmentsLineItems_abcf070f-62b7-4ee2-8997-2dce0746a882" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_DebtSecuritiesAvailableForSaleUnrealizedLossPositionNumberOfPositions_3bd72915-6755-48fa-8c0b-a61e23a74fdd" xlink:type="arc" order="3"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_PercentageBasedOnUnrealizedLossOfAvailableForSaleFixedMaturitiesThatAreInUnrealizedLossPositionAndRatedInvestmentGrade_c527a18a-2136-443a-ac5b-c3a6871d0be6" xlink:href="afg-20240930.xsd#afg_PercentageBasedOnUnrealizedLossOfAvailableForSaleFixedMaturitiesThatAreInUnrealizedLossPositionAndRatedInvestmentGrade"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfInvestmentsLineItems_abcf070f-62b7-4ee2-8997-2dce0746a882" xlink:to="loc_afg_PercentageBasedOnUnrealizedLossOfAvailableForSaleFixedMaturitiesThatAreInUnrealizedLossPositionAndRatedInvestmentGrade_c527a18a-2136-443a-ac5b-c3a6871d0be6" xlink:type="arc" order="4"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_PercentageBasedOnFairValueOfAvailableForSaleFixedMaturitiesThatAreInUnrealizedLossPositionAndRatedInvestmentGrade_4f4d1cf5-d097-4e4d-a0d6-e0db99b20f41" xlink:href="afg-20240930.xsd#afg_PercentageBasedOnFairValueOfAvailableForSaleFixedMaturitiesThatAreInUnrealizedLossPositionAndRatedInvestmentGrade"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfInvestmentsLineItems_abcf070f-62b7-4ee2-8997-2dce0746a882" xlink:to="loc_afg_PercentageBasedOnFairValueOfAvailableForSaleFixedMaturitiesThatAreInUnrealizedLossPositionAndRatedInvestmentGrade_4f4d1cf5-d097-4e4d-a0d6-e0db99b20f41" xlink:type="arc" order="5"/>
  </link:definitionLink>
  <link:roleRef roleURI="http://www.afginc.com/role/InvestmentsAvailableforsalefixedmaturitiesDetails" xlink:type="simple" xlink:href="afg-20240930.xsd#InvestmentsAvailableforsalefixedmaturitiesDetails"/>
  <link:definitionLink xlink:role="http://www.afginc.com/role/InvestmentsAvailableforsalefixedmaturitiesDetails" xlink:type="extended">
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfAvailableForSaleSecuritiesLineItems_16c7ce0d-07e8-4b03-9acc-c830b085941b" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_ScheduleOfAvailableForSaleSecuritiesLineItems"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_DebtSecuritiesAvailableForSaleTable_0e99def7-669e-411d-99e0-7ff04738eb17" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_DebtSecuritiesAvailableForSaleTable"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/all" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfAvailableForSaleSecuritiesLineItems_16c7ce0d-07e8-4b03-9acc-c830b085941b" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_DebtSecuritiesAvailableForSaleTable_0e99def7-669e-411d-99e0-7ff04738eb17" xlink:type="arc" order="1" xbrldt:closed="true" xbrldt:contextElement="segment"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_FinancialInstrumentAxis_1a6e9964-0480-4403-b7b5-0d68326edce0" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_FinancialInstrumentAxis"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/hypercube-dimension" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DebtSecuritiesAvailableForSaleTable_0e99def7-669e-411d-99e0-7ff04738eb17" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_FinancialInstrumentAxis_1a6e9964-0480-4403-b7b5-0d68326edce0" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_TransfersAndServicingOfFinancialInstrumentsTypesOfFinancialInstrumentsDomain_1a6e9964-0480-4403-b7b5-0d68326edce0_default" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_TransfersAndServicingOfFinancialInstrumentsTypesOfFinancialInstrumentsDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-default" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FinancialInstrumentAxis_1a6e9964-0480-4403-b7b5-0d68326edce0" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_TransfersAndServicingOfFinancialInstrumentsTypesOfFinancialInstrumentsDomain_1a6e9964-0480-4403-b7b5-0d68326edce0_default" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_TransfersAndServicingOfFinancialInstrumentsTypesOfFinancialInstrumentsDomain_4b0c48f5-a340-43af-90d4-b2325c460d39" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_TransfersAndServicingOfFinancialInstrumentsTypesOfFinancialInstrumentsDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-domain" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FinancialInstrumentAxis_1a6e9964-0480-4403-b7b5-0d68326edce0" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_TransfersAndServicingOfFinancialInstrumentsTypesOfFinancialInstrumentsDomain_4b0c48f5-a340-43af-90d4-b2325c460d39" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_FixedMaturitiesMember_da9434c0-f0fc-4854-878f-9be0d71ee3a9" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_FixedMaturitiesMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_TransfersAndServicingOfFinancialInstrumentsTypesOfFinancialInstrumentsDomain_4b0c48f5-a340-43af-90d4-b2325c460d39" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_FixedMaturitiesMember_da9434c0-f0fc-4854-878f-9be0d71ee3a9" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_USTreasuryAndGovernmentMember_c45d8532-a8dc-48ce-8e42-3908cd7e4a29" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_USTreasuryAndGovernmentMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FixedMaturitiesMember_da9434c0-f0fc-4854-878f-9be0d71ee3a9" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_USTreasuryAndGovernmentMember_c45d8532-a8dc-48ce-8e42-3908cd7e4a29" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_USStatesAndPoliticalSubdivisionsMember_6b7806b6-0a34-46d6-81a7-feddeca93366" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_USStatesAndPoliticalSubdivisionsMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FixedMaturitiesMember_da9434c0-f0fc-4854-878f-9be0d71ee3a9" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_USStatesAndPoliticalSubdivisionsMember_6b7806b6-0a34-46d6-81a7-feddeca93366" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_ForeignGovernmentDebtSecuritiesMember_4df10642-f42f-428c-83b0-a5bcf8b06548" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_ForeignGovernmentDebtSecuritiesMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FixedMaturitiesMember_da9434c0-f0fc-4854-878f-9be0d71ee3a9" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_ForeignGovernmentDebtSecuritiesMember_4df10642-f42f-428c-83b0-a5bcf8b06548" xlink:type="arc" order="3"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_ResidentialMortgageBackedSecuritiesMember_d4edb338-5995-4d8f-a16c-a5a1a2c010e9" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_ResidentialMortgageBackedSecuritiesMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FixedMaturitiesMember_da9434c0-f0fc-4854-878f-9be0d71ee3a9" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_ResidentialMortgageBackedSecuritiesMember_d4edb338-5995-4d8f-a16c-a5a1a2c010e9" xlink:type="arc" order="4"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_CommercialMortgageBackedSecuritiesMember_758e284d-9500-4ff1-91c0-97d150a23d2a" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_CommercialMortgageBackedSecuritiesMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FixedMaturitiesMember_da9434c0-f0fc-4854-878f-9be0d71ee3a9" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_CommercialMortgageBackedSecuritiesMember_758e284d-9500-4ff1-91c0-97d150a23d2a" xlink:type="arc" order="5"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_CollateralizedLoanObligationsMember_18d8c349-297f-4a5e-9342-30c861d59e37" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_CollateralizedLoanObligationsMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FixedMaturitiesMember_da9434c0-f0fc-4854-878f-9be0d71ee3a9" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_CollateralizedLoanObligationsMember_18d8c349-297f-4a5e-9342-30c861d59e37" xlink:type="arc" order="6"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_AssetBackedSecuritiesMember_187ffe61-2c0f-46c0-a455-40d1611e5c91" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_AssetBackedSecuritiesMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FixedMaturitiesMember_da9434c0-f0fc-4854-878f-9be0d71ee3a9" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_AssetBackedSecuritiesMember_187ffe61-2c0f-46c0-a455-40d1611e5c91" xlink:type="arc" order="7"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_CorporateDebtSecuritiesMember_a5b0d12c-8ef3-45a9-a22c-7de4882078b9" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_CorporateDebtSecuritiesMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FixedMaturitiesMember_da9434c0-f0fc-4854-878f-9be0d71ee3a9" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_CorporateDebtSecuritiesMember_a5b0d12c-8ef3-45a9-a22c-7de4882078b9" xlink:type="arc" order="8"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_AvailableForSaleDebtSecuritiesAmortizedCostBasis_a3fd4205-e297-48de-8cb6-06037862c845" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_AvailableForSaleDebtSecuritiesAmortizedCostBasis"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfAvailableForSaleSecuritiesLineItems_16c7ce0d-07e8-4b03-9acc-c830b085941b" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_AvailableForSaleDebtSecuritiesAmortizedCostBasis_a3fd4205-e297-48de-8cb6-06037862c845" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_DebtSecuritiesAvailableForSaleAllowanceForCreditLoss_086d2af0-2450-428d-a12f-7f8fffa015f8" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_DebtSecuritiesAvailableForSaleAllowanceForCreditLoss"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfAvailableForSaleSecuritiesLineItems_16c7ce0d-07e8-4b03-9acc-c830b085941b" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_DebtSecuritiesAvailableForSaleAllowanceForCreditLoss_086d2af0-2450-428d-a12f-7f8fffa015f8" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_AvailableForSaleDebtSecuritiesAccumulatedGrossUnrealizedGainBeforeTax_347ba9db-633d-48cf-9199-8bdd4937bd79" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_AvailableForSaleDebtSecuritiesAccumulatedGrossUnrealizedGainBeforeTax"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfAvailableForSaleSecuritiesLineItems_16c7ce0d-07e8-4b03-9acc-c830b085941b" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_AvailableForSaleDebtSecuritiesAccumulatedGrossUnrealizedGainBeforeTax_347ba9db-633d-48cf-9199-8bdd4937bd79" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_AvailableForSaleDebtSecuritiesAccumulatedGrossUnrealizedLossBeforeTax_14136a5b-753d-46e6-b53a-42baf53a7153" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_AvailableForSaleDebtSecuritiesAccumulatedGrossUnrealizedLossBeforeTax"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfAvailableForSaleSecuritiesLineItems_16c7ce0d-07e8-4b03-9acc-c830b085941b" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_AvailableForSaleDebtSecuritiesAccumulatedGrossUnrealizedLossBeforeTax_14136a5b-753d-46e6-b53a-42baf53a7153" xlink:type="arc" order="3"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_DebtSecuritiesAvailableForSaleAccumulatedGrossUnrealizedGainLossBeforeTax_5e15577b-55a3-4b33-9c34-00ab3f7aee2a" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_DebtSecuritiesAvailableForSaleAccumulatedGrossUnrealizedGainLossBeforeTax"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfAvailableForSaleSecuritiesLineItems_16c7ce0d-07e8-4b03-9acc-c830b085941b" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_DebtSecuritiesAvailableForSaleAccumulatedGrossUnrealizedGainLossBeforeTax_5e15577b-55a3-4b33-9c34-00ab3f7aee2a" xlink:type="arc" order="4"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtSecurities_90ca4e34-7148-41c2-86bf-b43ed2f93df2" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtSecurities"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfAvailableForSaleSecuritiesLineItems_16c7ce0d-07e8-4b03-9acc-c830b085941b" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtSecurities_90ca4e34-7148-41c2-86bf-b43ed2f93df2" xlink:type="arc" order="5"/>
  </link:definitionLink>
  <link:roleRef roleURI="http://www.afginc.com/role/InvestmentsEquitysecuritiesreportedatfairvalueDetails" xlink:type="simple" xlink:href="afg-20240930.xsd#InvestmentsEquitysecuritiesreportedatfairvalueDetails"/>
  <link:definitionLink xlink:role="http://www.afginc.com/role/InvestmentsEquitysecuritiesreportedatfairvalueDetails" xlink:type="extended">
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfTradingSecuritiesAndOtherTradingAssetsLineItems_0c9b07db-7ce6-4a29-aeee-b58e918d5f44" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_ScheduleOfTradingSecuritiesAndOtherTradingAssetsLineItems"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfTradingSecuritiesAndOtherTradingAssetsTable_153917be-429f-4767-ac63-273f61ab322e" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_ScheduleOfTradingSecuritiesAndOtherTradingAssetsTable"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/all" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfTradingSecuritiesAndOtherTradingAssetsLineItems_0c9b07db-7ce6-4a29-aeee-b58e918d5f44" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfTradingSecuritiesAndOtherTradingAssetsTable_153917be-429f-4767-ac63-273f61ab322e" xlink:type="arc" order="1" xbrldt:closed="true" xbrldt:contextElement="segment"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_FinancialInstrumentAxis_9e9a18f9-f288-4000-91cf-f2c233372c46" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_FinancialInstrumentAxis"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/hypercube-dimension" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfTradingSecuritiesAndOtherTradingAssetsTable_153917be-429f-4767-ac63-273f61ab322e" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_FinancialInstrumentAxis_9e9a18f9-f288-4000-91cf-f2c233372c46" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_TransfersAndServicingOfFinancialInstrumentsTypesOfFinancialInstrumentsDomain_9e9a18f9-f288-4000-91cf-f2c233372c46_default" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_TransfersAndServicingOfFinancialInstrumentsTypesOfFinancialInstrumentsDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-default" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FinancialInstrumentAxis_9e9a18f9-f288-4000-91cf-f2c233372c46" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_TransfersAndServicingOfFinancialInstrumentsTypesOfFinancialInstrumentsDomain_9e9a18f9-f288-4000-91cf-f2c233372c46_default" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_TransfersAndServicingOfFinancialInstrumentsTypesOfFinancialInstrumentsDomain_707241ed-0f1c-4756-a102-ed278e9668b8" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_TransfersAndServicingOfFinancialInstrumentsTypesOfFinancialInstrumentsDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-domain" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FinancialInstrumentAxis_9e9a18f9-f288-4000-91cf-f2c233372c46" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_TransfersAndServicingOfFinancialInstrumentsTypesOfFinancialInstrumentsDomain_707241ed-0f1c-4756-a102-ed278e9668b8" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_CommonStockMember_2371678f-da5d-4789-bd53-4751d6359237" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_CommonStockMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_TransfersAndServicingOfFinancialInstrumentsTypesOfFinancialInstrumentsDomain_707241ed-0f1c-4756-a102-ed278e9668b8" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_CommonStockMember_2371678f-da5d-4789-bd53-4751d6359237" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_PreferredStockMember_42293da2-ec00-4ed6-9415-c52c4190140b" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_PreferredStockMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_TransfersAndServicingOfFinancialInstrumentsTypesOfFinancialInstrumentsDomain_707241ed-0f1c-4756-a102-ed278e9668b8" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_PreferredStockMember_42293da2-ec00-4ed6-9415-c52c4190140b" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_EquitySecuritiesMember_c9dbe7fe-f52b-403a-bb0a-d580def9d74c" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_EquitySecuritiesMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_TransfersAndServicingOfFinancialInstrumentsTypesOfFinancialInstrumentsDomain_707241ed-0f1c-4756-a102-ed278e9668b8" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_EquitySecuritiesMember_c9dbe7fe-f52b-403a-bb0a-d580def9d74c" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_EquitySecuritiesFvNiCost_c27c5b9c-9579-484f-910c-0244721c8264" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_EquitySecuritiesFvNiCost"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfTradingSecuritiesAndOtherTradingAssetsLineItems_0c9b07db-7ce6-4a29-aeee-b58e918d5f44" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_EquitySecuritiesFvNiCost_c27c5b9c-9579-484f-910c-0244721c8264" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_EquitySecuritiesFvNi_d065c638-7be6-4b8f-9d9e-c97aecb01fa9" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_EquitySecuritiesFvNi"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfTradingSecuritiesAndOtherTradingAssetsLineItems_0c9b07db-7ce6-4a29-aeee-b58e918d5f44" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_EquitySecuritiesFvNi_d065c638-7be6-4b8f-9d9e-c97aecb01fa9" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_EquitySecuritiesFVNIFairValueinExcessofCost_d59cea28-8014-401c-8c8d-32796ad60491" xlink:href="afg-20240930.xsd#afg_EquitySecuritiesFVNIFairValueinExcessofCost"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfTradingSecuritiesAndOtherTradingAssetsLineItems_0c9b07db-7ce6-4a29-aeee-b58e918d5f44" xlink:to="loc_afg_EquitySecuritiesFVNIFairValueinExcessofCost_d59cea28-8014-401c-8c8d-32796ad60491" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
  </link:definitionLink>
  <link:roleRef roleURI="http://www.afginc.com/role/InvestmentsDetailofequitymethodinvestmentsDetails" xlink:type="simple" xlink:href="afg-20240930.xsd#InvestmentsDetailofequitymethodinvestmentsDetails"/>
  <link:definitionLink xlink:role="http://www.afginc.com/role/InvestmentsDetailofequitymethodinvestmentsDetails" xlink:type="extended">
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfInvestmentsLineItems_25d74c9f-72f4-444b-a503-343606594376" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_ScheduleOfInvestmentsLineItems"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfInvestmentsTable_3d658c85-4bcd-458a-b113-468c39c83c59" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_ScheduleOfInvestmentsTable"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/all" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfInvestmentsLineItems_25d74c9f-72f4-444b-a503-343606594376" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfInvestmentsTable_3d658c85-4bcd-458a-b113-468c39c83c59" xlink:type="arc" order="1" xbrldt:closed="true" xbrldt:contextElement="segment"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_srt_ScheduleOfEquityMethodInvestmentEquityMethodInvesteeNameAxis_3a26dcb5-c144-46e0-959b-4a0ef75f9c36" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/srt/2024/elts/srt-2024.xsd#srt_ScheduleOfEquityMethodInvestmentEquityMethodInvesteeNameAxis"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/hypercube-dimension" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfInvestmentsTable_3d658c85-4bcd-458a-b113-468c39c83c59" xlink:to="loc_srt_ScheduleOfEquityMethodInvestmentEquityMethodInvesteeNameAxis_3a26dcb5-c144-46e0-959b-4a0ef75f9c36" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_srt_EquityMethodInvesteeNameDomain_3a26dcb5-c144-46e0-959b-4a0ef75f9c36_default" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/srt/2024/elts/srt-2024.xsd#srt_EquityMethodInvesteeNameDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-default" xlink:from="loc_srt_ScheduleOfEquityMethodInvestmentEquityMethodInvesteeNameAxis_3a26dcb5-c144-46e0-959b-4a0ef75f9c36" xlink:to="loc_srt_EquityMethodInvesteeNameDomain_3a26dcb5-c144-46e0-959b-4a0ef75f9c36_default" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_srt_EquityMethodInvesteeNameDomain_3a7f814a-bc05-4dba-a986-53b06d51b5be" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/srt/2024/elts/srt-2024.xsd#srt_EquityMethodInvesteeNameDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-domain" xlink:from="loc_srt_ScheduleOfEquityMethodInvestmentEquityMethodInvesteeNameAxis_3a26dcb5-c144-46e0-959b-4a0ef75f9c36" xlink:to="loc_srt_EquityMethodInvesteeNameDomain_3a7f814a-bc05-4dba-a986-53b06d51b5be" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_EquityMethodInvestmentsRealEstateRelatedInvestmentsMember_a6def07f-238d-44ff-a7eb-9f1ce29c9025" xlink:href="afg-20240930.xsd#afg_EquityMethodInvestmentsRealEstateRelatedInvestmentsMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_srt_EquityMethodInvesteeNameDomain_3a7f814a-bc05-4dba-a986-53b06d51b5be" xlink:to="loc_afg_EquityMethodInvestmentsRealEstateRelatedInvestmentsMember_a6def07f-238d-44ff-a7eb-9f1ce29c9025" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_EquityMethodInvestmentsPrivateEquityFundsMember_72cf7196-07dc-4bf6-b096-8dbd4fda76b6" xlink:href="afg-20240930.xsd#afg_EquityMethodInvestmentsPrivateEquityFundsMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_srt_EquityMethodInvesteeNameDomain_3a7f814a-bc05-4dba-a986-53b06d51b5be" xlink:to="loc_afg_EquityMethodInvestmentsPrivateEquityFundsMember_72cf7196-07dc-4bf6-b096-8dbd4fda76b6" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_EquityMethodInvestmentsPrivateDebtFundsMember_4ee4d135-7dc0-405c-b4cb-09bab5327fa0" xlink:href="afg-20240930.xsd#afg_EquityMethodInvestmentsPrivateDebtFundsMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_srt_EquityMethodInvesteeNameDomain_3a7f814a-bc05-4dba-a986-53b06d51b5be" xlink:to="loc_afg_EquityMethodInvestmentsPrivateDebtFundsMember_4ee4d135-7dc0-405c-b4cb-09bab5327fa0" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_EquityMethodInvestments_a075015e-dca6-49a1-a6df-d458d3be3682" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_EquityMethodInvestments"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfInvestmentsLineItems_25d74c9f-72f4-444b-a503-343606594376" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_EquityMethodInvestments_a075015e-dca6-49a1-a6df-d458d3be3682" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_IncomeLossFromEquityMethodInvestments_901b5939-abf7-4792-957b-8f8aaab8f059" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_IncomeLossFromEquityMethodInvestments"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfInvestmentsLineItems_25d74c9f-72f4-444b-a503-343606594376" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_IncomeLossFromEquityMethodInvestments_901b5939-abf7-4792-957b-8f8aaab8f059" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
  </link:definitionLink>
  <link:roleRef roleURI="http://www.afginc.com/role/InvestmentsGrossunrealizedlossesonsecuritiesbyinvestmentcategoryandlengthoftimethathavebeeninacontinuousunrealizedlosspositionDetails" xlink:type="simple" xlink:href="afg-20240930.xsd#InvestmentsGrossunrealizedlossesonsecuritiesbyinvestmentcategoryandlengthoftimethathavebeeninacontinuousunrealizedlosspositionDetails"/>
  <link:definitionLink xlink:role="http://www.afginc.com/role/InvestmentsGrossunrealizedlossesonsecuritiesbyinvestmentcategoryandlengthoftimethathavebeeninacontinuousunrealizedlosspositionDetails" xlink:type="extended">
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfAvailableForSaleSecuritiesLineItems_6f8525b8-066b-4573-9d6e-93e1473aeb5b" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_ScheduleOfAvailableForSaleSecuritiesLineItems"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_DebtSecuritiesAvailableForSaleTable_e50aa475-3124-47c2-abea-117a99f06248" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_DebtSecuritiesAvailableForSaleTable"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/all" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfAvailableForSaleSecuritiesLineItems_6f8525b8-066b-4573-9d6e-93e1473aeb5b" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_DebtSecuritiesAvailableForSaleTable_e50aa475-3124-47c2-abea-117a99f06248" xlink:type="arc" order="1" xbrldt:closed="true" xbrldt:contextElement="segment"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_FinancialInstrumentAxis_6a638df6-df8e-4192-b841-8b2f3f0dfa57" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_FinancialInstrumentAxis"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/hypercube-dimension" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DebtSecuritiesAvailableForSaleTable_e50aa475-3124-47c2-abea-117a99f06248" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_FinancialInstrumentAxis_6a638df6-df8e-4192-b841-8b2f3f0dfa57" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_TransfersAndServicingOfFinancialInstrumentsTypesOfFinancialInstrumentsDomain_6a638df6-df8e-4192-b841-8b2f3f0dfa57_default" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_TransfersAndServicingOfFinancialInstrumentsTypesOfFinancialInstrumentsDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-default" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FinancialInstrumentAxis_6a638df6-df8e-4192-b841-8b2f3f0dfa57" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_TransfersAndServicingOfFinancialInstrumentsTypesOfFinancialInstrumentsDomain_6a638df6-df8e-4192-b841-8b2f3f0dfa57_default" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_TransfersAndServicingOfFinancialInstrumentsTypesOfFinancialInstrumentsDomain_baa02861-2c39-4d38-addc-fd69d05cc738" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_TransfersAndServicingOfFinancialInstrumentsTypesOfFinancialInstrumentsDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-domain" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FinancialInstrumentAxis_6a638df6-df8e-4192-b841-8b2f3f0dfa57" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_TransfersAndServicingOfFinancialInstrumentsTypesOfFinancialInstrumentsDomain_baa02861-2c39-4d38-addc-fd69d05cc738" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_FixedMaturitiesMember_66c87a23-e638-4f7d-8f2a-2581472ba31c" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_FixedMaturitiesMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_TransfersAndServicingOfFinancialInstrumentsTypesOfFinancialInstrumentsDomain_baa02861-2c39-4d38-addc-fd69d05cc738" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_FixedMaturitiesMember_66c87a23-e638-4f7d-8f2a-2581472ba31c" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_USTreasuryAndGovernmentMember_0f1dff9a-7238-4c03-a6c3-8ffa052ac2fc" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_USTreasuryAndGovernmentMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FixedMaturitiesMember_66c87a23-e638-4f7d-8f2a-2581472ba31c" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_USTreasuryAndGovernmentMember_0f1dff9a-7238-4c03-a6c3-8ffa052ac2fc" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_USStatesAndPoliticalSubdivisionsMember_d44f21d2-6baa-4bba-99db-9cdacf433d70" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_USStatesAndPoliticalSubdivisionsMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FixedMaturitiesMember_66c87a23-e638-4f7d-8f2a-2581472ba31c" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_USStatesAndPoliticalSubdivisionsMember_d44f21d2-6baa-4bba-99db-9cdacf433d70" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_ForeignGovernmentDebtSecuritiesMember_e5f0e50e-36e9-4f99-b060-b58bcf50e258" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_ForeignGovernmentDebtSecuritiesMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FixedMaturitiesMember_66c87a23-e638-4f7d-8f2a-2581472ba31c" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_ForeignGovernmentDebtSecuritiesMember_e5f0e50e-36e9-4f99-b060-b58bcf50e258" xlink:type="arc" order="3"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_ResidentialMortgageBackedSecuritiesMember_b8fe3a5d-2246-4a04-922a-498b43159904" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_ResidentialMortgageBackedSecuritiesMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FixedMaturitiesMember_66c87a23-e638-4f7d-8f2a-2581472ba31c" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_ResidentialMortgageBackedSecuritiesMember_b8fe3a5d-2246-4a04-922a-498b43159904" xlink:type="arc" order="4"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_CommercialMortgageBackedSecuritiesMember_d1e8fa45-d38d-47de-90f9-0576aad565cd" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_CommercialMortgageBackedSecuritiesMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FixedMaturitiesMember_66c87a23-e638-4f7d-8f2a-2581472ba31c" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_CommercialMortgageBackedSecuritiesMember_d1e8fa45-d38d-47de-90f9-0576aad565cd" xlink:type="arc" order="5"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_CollateralizedLoanObligationsMember_6358c632-b15e-46c7-b9dd-c6bd847e1478" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_CollateralizedLoanObligationsMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FixedMaturitiesMember_66c87a23-e638-4f7d-8f2a-2581472ba31c" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_CollateralizedLoanObligationsMember_6358c632-b15e-46c7-b9dd-c6bd847e1478" xlink:type="arc" order="6"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_AssetBackedSecuritiesMember_3c7b73a4-55fd-42b1-b51e-91930e8360a5" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_AssetBackedSecuritiesMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FixedMaturitiesMember_66c87a23-e638-4f7d-8f2a-2581472ba31c" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_AssetBackedSecuritiesMember_3c7b73a4-55fd-42b1-b51e-91930e8360a5" xlink:type="arc" order="7"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_CorporateDebtSecuritiesMember_a083a054-884d-4ebd-a17c-b6487d24cf35" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_CorporateDebtSecuritiesMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FixedMaturitiesMember_66c87a23-e638-4f7d-8f2a-2581472ba31c" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_CorporateDebtSecuritiesMember_a083a054-884d-4ebd-a17c-b6487d24cf35" xlink:type="arc" order="8"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesContinuousUnrealizedLossPositionAccumulatedLossAbstract_f83cc592-5fb6-4d3f-b923-41dc88b460d6" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesContinuousUnrealizedLossPositionAccumulatedLossAbstract"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfAvailableForSaleSecuritiesLineItems_6f8525b8-066b-4573-9d6e-93e1473aeb5b" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesContinuousUnrealizedLossPositionAccumulatedLossAbstract_f83cc592-5fb6-4d3f-b923-41dc88b460d6" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_DebtSecuritiesAvailableForSaleContinuousUnrealizedLossPositionLessThan12MonthsAccumulatedLoss_a78f618f-9398-48d7-8b18-c2fd2425f9d0" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_DebtSecuritiesAvailableForSaleContinuousUnrealizedLossPositionLessThan12MonthsAccumulatedLoss"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesContinuousUnrealizedLossPositionAccumulatedLossAbstract_f83cc592-5fb6-4d3f-b923-41dc88b460d6" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_DebtSecuritiesAvailableForSaleContinuousUnrealizedLossPositionLessThan12MonthsAccumulatedLoss_a78f618f-9398-48d7-8b18-c2fd2425f9d0" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_DebtSecuritiesAvailableForSaleContinuousUnrealizedLossPositionLessThan12Months_bd34ad02-da34-45ee-be31-ed162d824ee0" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_DebtSecuritiesAvailableForSaleContinuousUnrealizedLossPositionLessThan12Months"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesContinuousUnrealizedLossPositionAccumulatedLossAbstract_f83cc592-5fb6-4d3f-b923-41dc88b460d6" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_DebtSecuritiesAvailableForSaleContinuousUnrealizedLossPositionLessThan12Months_bd34ad02-da34-45ee-be31-ed162d824ee0" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_DebtSecuritiesAvailableForSaleContinuousUnrealizedLossPositionLessThanTwelveMonthsFairValueAsPercentageOfCost_c9e9c99d-c05e-4e7d-a84e-fc35c8af449a" xlink:href="afg-20240930.xsd#afg_DebtSecuritiesAvailableForSaleContinuousUnrealizedLossPositionLessThanTwelveMonthsFairValueAsPercentageOfCost"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesContinuousUnrealizedLossPositionAccumulatedLossAbstract_f83cc592-5fb6-4d3f-b923-41dc88b460d6" xlink:to="loc_afg_DebtSecuritiesAvailableForSaleContinuousUnrealizedLossPositionLessThanTwelveMonthsFairValueAsPercentageOfCost_c9e9c99d-c05e-4e7d-a84e-fc35c8af449a" xlink:type="arc" order="3"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_DebtSecuritiesAvailableForSaleContinuousUnrealizedLossPosition12MonthsOrLongerAccumulatedLoss_38d865c5-758e-49f1-b00a-4f21fdbc4c8f" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_DebtSecuritiesAvailableForSaleContinuousUnrealizedLossPosition12MonthsOrLongerAccumulatedLoss"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesContinuousUnrealizedLossPositionAccumulatedLossAbstract_f83cc592-5fb6-4d3f-b923-41dc88b460d6" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_DebtSecuritiesAvailableForSaleContinuousUnrealizedLossPosition12MonthsOrLongerAccumulatedLoss_38d865c5-758e-49f1-b00a-4f21fdbc4c8f" xlink:type="arc" order="4"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_DebtSecuritiesAvailableForSaleContinuousUnrealizedLossPosition12MonthsOrLonger_03611737-f6d6-4734-a7e8-bd816ec0048a" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_DebtSecuritiesAvailableForSaleContinuousUnrealizedLossPosition12MonthsOrLonger"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesContinuousUnrealizedLossPositionAccumulatedLossAbstract_f83cc592-5fb6-4d3f-b923-41dc88b460d6" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_DebtSecuritiesAvailableForSaleContinuousUnrealizedLossPosition12MonthsOrLonger_03611737-f6d6-4734-a7e8-bd816ec0048a" xlink:type="arc" order="5"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_DebtSecuritiesAvailableForSaleContinuousUnrealizedLossPositionTwelveMonthsOrLongerFairValueAsPercentageOfCost_1a3cb535-7a35-40b7-a557-022fc60ab01a" xlink:href="afg-20240930.xsd#afg_DebtSecuritiesAvailableForSaleContinuousUnrealizedLossPositionTwelveMonthsOrLongerFairValueAsPercentageOfCost"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesContinuousUnrealizedLossPositionAccumulatedLossAbstract_f83cc592-5fb6-4d3f-b923-41dc88b460d6" xlink:to="loc_afg_DebtSecuritiesAvailableForSaleContinuousUnrealizedLossPositionTwelveMonthsOrLongerFairValueAsPercentageOfCost_1a3cb535-7a35-40b7-a557-022fc60ab01a" xlink:type="arc" order="6"/>
  </link:definitionLink>
  <link:roleRef roleURI="http://www.afginc.com/role/InvestmentsAllowanceforcreditlossesonfixedmaturitiesDetails" xlink:type="simple" xlink:href="afg-20240930.xsd#InvestmentsAllowanceforcreditlossesonfixedmaturitiesDetails"/>
  <link:definitionLink xlink:role="http://www.afginc.com/role/InvestmentsAllowanceforcreditlossesonfixedmaturitiesDetails" xlink:type="extended">
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_DebtSecuritiesAvailableforsaleAllowanceForCreditLossLineItems_72545209-c236-4f43-93ba-493261523015" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_DebtSecuritiesAvailableforsaleAllowanceForCreditLossLineItems"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_DebtSecuritiesAvailableForSaleAllowanceForCreditLossTable_6931c0b9-6fc4-418c-b7db-ddc1ddcc6ceb" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_DebtSecuritiesAvailableForSaleAllowanceForCreditLossTable"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/all" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DebtSecuritiesAvailableforsaleAllowanceForCreditLossLineItems_72545209-c236-4f43-93ba-493261523015" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_DebtSecuritiesAvailableForSaleAllowanceForCreditLossTable_6931c0b9-6fc4-418c-b7db-ddc1ddcc6ceb" xlink:type="arc" order="1" xbrldt:closed="true" xbrldt:contextElement="segment"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_FinancialInstrumentAxis_5497e623-21ba-47cb-97c9-d5e0bd624570" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_FinancialInstrumentAxis"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/hypercube-dimension" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DebtSecuritiesAvailableForSaleAllowanceForCreditLossTable_6931c0b9-6fc4-418c-b7db-ddc1ddcc6ceb" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_FinancialInstrumentAxis_5497e623-21ba-47cb-97c9-d5e0bd624570" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_TransfersAndServicingOfFinancialInstrumentsTypesOfFinancialInstrumentsDomain_5497e623-21ba-47cb-97c9-d5e0bd624570_default" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_TransfersAndServicingOfFinancialInstrumentsTypesOfFinancialInstrumentsDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-default" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FinancialInstrumentAxis_5497e623-21ba-47cb-97c9-d5e0bd624570" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_TransfersAndServicingOfFinancialInstrumentsTypesOfFinancialInstrumentsDomain_5497e623-21ba-47cb-97c9-d5e0bd624570_default" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_TransfersAndServicingOfFinancialInstrumentsTypesOfFinancialInstrumentsDomain_b5430fd9-a007-4eef-881c-9beaec53ddef" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_TransfersAndServicingOfFinancialInstrumentsTypesOfFinancialInstrumentsDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-domain" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FinancialInstrumentAxis_5497e623-21ba-47cb-97c9-d5e0bd624570" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_TransfersAndServicingOfFinancialInstrumentsTypesOfFinancialInstrumentsDomain_b5430fd9-a007-4eef-881c-9beaec53ddef" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_StructuredSecuritiesMember_fe72881d-8508-4dac-9915-6dc9497330db" xlink:href="afg-20240930.xsd#afg_StructuredSecuritiesMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_TransfersAndServicingOfFinancialInstrumentsTypesOfFinancialInstrumentsDomain_b5430fd9-a007-4eef-881c-9beaec53ddef" xlink:to="loc_afg_StructuredSecuritiesMember_fe72881d-8508-4dac-9915-6dc9497330db" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_CorporateDebtSecuritiesMember_20fef341-7d07-4907-b981-0fb804d702a6" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_CorporateDebtSecuritiesMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_TransfersAndServicingOfFinancialInstrumentsTypesOfFinancialInstrumentsDomain_b5430fd9-a007-4eef-881c-9beaec53ddef" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_CorporateDebtSecuritiesMember_20fef341-7d07-4907-b981-0fb804d702a6" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_DebtSecuritiesAvailableForSaleAllowanceForCreditLossRollForward_c5512e52-1b70-4e06-96c6-6582620266be" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_DebtSecuritiesAvailableForSaleAllowanceForCreditLossRollForward"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DebtSecuritiesAvailableforsaleAllowanceForCreditLossLineItems_72545209-c236-4f43-93ba-493261523015" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_DebtSecuritiesAvailableForSaleAllowanceForCreditLossRollForward_c5512e52-1b70-4e06-96c6-6582620266be" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_DebtSecuritiesAvailableForSaleAllowanceForCreditLoss_d0f71ca8-d09f-4fd9-9074-00d888d5a360" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_DebtSecuritiesAvailableForSaleAllowanceForCreditLoss"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DebtSecuritiesAvailableForSaleAllowanceForCreditLossRollForward_c5512e52-1b70-4e06-96c6-6582620266be" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_DebtSecuritiesAvailableForSaleAllowanceForCreditLoss_d0f71ca8-d09f-4fd9-9074-00d888d5a360" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_DebtSecuritiesAvailableForSaleAllowanceForCreditLossNotPreviouslyRecorded_b3267f4c-8b8d-42f2-b433-cc1c1aecf446" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_DebtSecuritiesAvailableForSaleAllowanceForCreditLossNotPreviouslyRecorded"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DebtSecuritiesAvailableForSaleAllowanceForCreditLossRollForward_c5512e52-1b70-4e06-96c6-6582620266be" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_DebtSecuritiesAvailableForSaleAllowanceForCreditLossNotPreviouslyRecorded_b3267f4c-8b8d-42f2-b433-cc1c1aecf446" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_DebtSecuritiesAvailableForSaleAllowanceForCreditLossNotToSellBeforeRecoveryCreditLossPreviouslyRecordedExpenseReversal_03ffcb31-e9c5-4be2-8ffe-db11897a4154" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_DebtSecuritiesAvailableForSaleAllowanceForCreditLossNotToSellBeforeRecoveryCreditLossPreviouslyRecordedExpenseReversal"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DebtSecuritiesAvailableForSaleAllowanceForCreditLossRollForward_c5512e52-1b70-4e06-96c6-6582620266be" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_DebtSecuritiesAvailableForSaleAllowanceForCreditLossNotToSellBeforeRecoveryCreditLossPreviouslyRecordedExpenseReversal_03ffcb31-e9c5-4be2-8ffe-db11897a4154" xlink:type="arc" order="3"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_DebtSecuritiesAvailableForSaleAllowanceForCreditLossSecuritiesSold_1dd62a7b-a40e-4215-b399-74a56ecc2b9f" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_DebtSecuritiesAvailableForSaleAllowanceForCreditLossSecuritiesSold"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DebtSecuritiesAvailableForSaleAllowanceForCreditLossRollForward_c5512e52-1b70-4e06-96c6-6582620266be" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_DebtSecuritiesAvailableForSaleAllowanceForCreditLossSecuritiesSold_1dd62a7b-a40e-4215-b399-74a56ecc2b9f" xlink:type="arc" order="4"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_DebtSecuritiesAvailableForSaleAllowanceForCreditLoss_9b046b91-ff0e-442c-97e1-d8f204b907f9" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_DebtSecuritiesAvailableForSaleAllowanceForCreditLoss"/>
  </link:definitionLink>
  <link:roleRef roleURI="http://www.afginc.com/role/InvestmentsScheduledmaturitiesofavailableforsalefixedmaturitiesDetails" xlink:type="simple" xlink:href="afg-20240930.xsd#InvestmentsScheduledmaturitiesofavailableforsalefixedmaturitiesDetails"/>
  <link:definitionLink xlink:role="http://www.afginc.com/role/InvestmentsScheduledmaturitiesofavailableforsalefixedmaturitiesDetails" xlink:type="extended">
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfAvailableForSaleSecuritiesLineItems_90c583ac-f066-4cb4-a89e-ee85728d7805" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_ScheduleOfAvailableForSaleSecuritiesLineItems"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_DebtSecuritiesAvailableForSaleTable_ef67964b-6c34-4c27-9d3e-b52547e4e668" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_DebtSecuritiesAvailableForSaleTable"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/all" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfAvailableForSaleSecuritiesLineItems_90c583ac-f066-4cb4-a89e-ee85728d7805" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_DebtSecuritiesAvailableForSaleTable_ef67964b-6c34-4c27-9d3e-b52547e4e668" xlink:type="arc" order="1" xbrldt:closed="true" xbrldt:contextElement="segment"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_FinancialInstrumentAxis_4315864d-78b2-4ff6-8bd4-5c3c9c467069" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_FinancialInstrumentAxis"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/hypercube-dimension" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DebtSecuritiesAvailableForSaleTable_ef67964b-6c34-4c27-9d3e-b52547e4e668" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_FinancialInstrumentAxis_4315864d-78b2-4ff6-8bd4-5c3c9c467069" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_TransfersAndServicingOfFinancialInstrumentsTypesOfFinancialInstrumentsDomain_4315864d-78b2-4ff6-8bd4-5c3c9c467069_default" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_TransfersAndServicingOfFinancialInstrumentsTypesOfFinancialInstrumentsDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-default" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FinancialInstrumentAxis_4315864d-78b2-4ff6-8bd4-5c3c9c467069" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_TransfersAndServicingOfFinancialInstrumentsTypesOfFinancialInstrumentsDomain_4315864d-78b2-4ff6-8bd4-5c3c9c467069_default" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_TransfersAndServicingOfFinancialInstrumentsTypesOfFinancialInstrumentsDomain_66235651-b93c-498f-bfdc-b63433ca3b2d" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_TransfersAndServicingOfFinancialInstrumentsTypesOfFinancialInstrumentsDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-domain" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FinancialInstrumentAxis_4315864d-78b2-4ff6-8bd4-5c3c9c467069" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_TransfersAndServicingOfFinancialInstrumentsTypesOfFinancialInstrumentsDomain_66235651-b93c-498f-bfdc-b63433ca3b2d" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_FixedMaturitiesMember_257081cd-6e5c-4e9f-a61b-e59adc8991b2" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_FixedMaturitiesMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_TransfersAndServicingOfFinancialInstrumentsTypesOfFinancialInstrumentsDomain_66235651-b93c-498f-bfdc-b63433ca3b2d" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_FixedMaturitiesMember_257081cd-6e5c-4e9f-a61b-e59adc8991b2" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_CollateralizedLoanObligationsAndOtherAssetBackedSecuritiesMember_4de34bfd-dbb8-4644-9e9f-a190ae47e354" xlink:href="afg-20240930.xsd#afg_CollateralizedLoanObligationsAndOtherAssetBackedSecuritiesMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_TransfersAndServicingOfFinancialInstrumentsTypesOfFinancialInstrumentsDomain_66235651-b93c-498f-bfdc-b63433ca3b2d" xlink:to="loc_afg_CollateralizedLoanObligationsAndOtherAssetBackedSecuritiesMember_4de34bfd-dbb8-4644-9e9f-a190ae47e354" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_MortgageBackedSecuritiesMember_0559f203-32fa-4d99-8ccd-78c0a6e9f44a" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_MortgageBackedSecuritiesMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_TransfersAndServicingOfFinancialInstrumentsTypesOfFinancialInstrumentsDomain_66235651-b93c-498f-bfdc-b63433ca3b2d" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_MortgageBackedSecuritiesMember_0559f203-32fa-4d99-8ccd-78c0a6e9f44a" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtMaturitiesAbstract_24f0c49d-7e29-4e8a-aed9-e3ad80e99f10" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtMaturitiesAbstract"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfAvailableForSaleSecuritiesLineItems_90c583ac-f066-4cb4-a89e-ee85728d7805" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtMaturitiesAbstract_24f0c49d-7e29-4e8a-aed9-e3ad80e99f10" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtMaturitiesAmortizedCostAbstract_834ffb02-6a47-48ab-a861-b7eb95f28e12" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtMaturitiesAmortizedCostAbstract"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtMaturitiesAbstract_24f0c49d-7e29-4e8a-aed9-e3ad80e99f10" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtMaturitiesAmortizedCostAbstract_834ffb02-6a47-48ab-a861-b7eb95f28e12" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtMaturitiesWithinOneYearAmortizedCost_24d85f06-794e-43e8-95e4-262bfbf66612" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtMaturitiesWithinOneYearAmortizedCost"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtMaturitiesAmortizedCostAbstract_834ffb02-6a47-48ab-a861-b7eb95f28e12" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtMaturitiesWithinOneYearAmortizedCost_24d85f06-794e-43e8-95e4-262bfbf66612" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtMaturitiesAfterOneThroughFiveYearsAmortizedCost_3656ea51-6c07-4b8e-9187-f944009fb927" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtMaturitiesAfterOneThroughFiveYearsAmortizedCost"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtMaturitiesAmortizedCostAbstract_834ffb02-6a47-48ab-a861-b7eb95f28e12" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtMaturitiesAfterOneThroughFiveYearsAmortizedCost_3656ea51-6c07-4b8e-9187-f944009fb927" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtMaturitiesAfterFiveThroughTenYearsAmortizedCost_8589acb1-d7f8-407e-b5e2-76a31a997ada" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtMaturitiesAfterFiveThroughTenYearsAmortizedCost"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtMaturitiesAmortizedCostAbstract_834ffb02-6a47-48ab-a861-b7eb95f28e12" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtMaturitiesAfterFiveThroughTenYearsAmortizedCost_8589acb1-d7f8-407e-b5e2-76a31a997ada" xlink:type="arc" order="3"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtMaturitiesAfterTenYearsAmortizedCost_cd58cfc8-1be6-41d4-8dc3-5c9befc70b79" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtMaturitiesAfterTenYearsAmortizedCost"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtMaturitiesAmortizedCostAbstract_834ffb02-6a47-48ab-a861-b7eb95f28e12" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtMaturitiesAfterTenYearsAmortizedCost_cd58cfc8-1be6-41d4-8dc3-5c9befc70b79" xlink:type="arc" order="4"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtMaturitiesExcludingAbsAndMbsAmortizedCost_2be734fc-6e3e-4832-813d-2731ac7e8e09" xlink:href="afg-20240930.xsd#afg_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtMaturitiesExcludingAbsAndMbsAmortizedCost"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtMaturitiesAmortizedCostAbstract_834ffb02-6a47-48ab-a861-b7eb95f28e12" xlink:to="loc_afg_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtMaturitiesExcludingAbsAndMbsAmortizedCost_2be734fc-6e3e-4832-813d-2731ac7e8e09" xlink:type="arc" order="5"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtMaturitiesWithoutSingleMaturityDateAmortizedCost_d9cae247-2293-45cd-94d5-6ac4710a0eae" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtMaturitiesWithoutSingleMaturityDateAmortizedCost"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtMaturitiesAmortizedCostAbstract_834ffb02-6a47-48ab-a861-b7eb95f28e12" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtMaturitiesWithoutSingleMaturityDateAmortizedCost_d9cae247-2293-45cd-94d5-6ac4710a0eae" xlink:type="arc" order="6"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_DebtSecuritiesAvailableForSaleAmortizedCostAfterAllowanceForCreditLoss_0177dc75-d804-43de-ac79-bbb87dd72f6f" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_DebtSecuritiesAvailableForSaleAmortizedCostAfterAllowanceForCreditLoss"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtMaturitiesAmortizedCostAbstract_834ffb02-6a47-48ab-a861-b7eb95f28e12" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_DebtSecuritiesAvailableForSaleAmortizedCostAfterAllowanceForCreditLoss_0177dc75-d804-43de-ac79-bbb87dd72f6f" xlink:type="arc" order="7"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtMaturitiesFairValueAbstract_a6e796ba-74ea-441d-9afd-d5a1b90a5df3" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtMaturitiesFairValueAbstract"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtMaturitiesAbstract_24f0c49d-7e29-4e8a-aed9-e3ad80e99f10" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtMaturitiesFairValueAbstract_a6e796ba-74ea-441d-9afd-d5a1b90a5df3" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtMaturitiesWithinOneYearFairValue_c6d44a7f-8c51-4fa4-8e5e-6f084bfc8f09" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtMaturitiesWithinOneYearFairValue"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtMaturitiesFairValueAbstract_a6e796ba-74ea-441d-9afd-d5a1b90a5df3" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtMaturitiesWithinOneYearFairValue_c6d44a7f-8c51-4fa4-8e5e-6f084bfc8f09" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtMaturitiesAfterOneThroughFiveYearsFairValue_d4921e7d-ef85-4861-95c8-9861a87c2b34" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtMaturitiesAfterOneThroughFiveYearsFairValue"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtMaturitiesFairValueAbstract_a6e796ba-74ea-441d-9afd-d5a1b90a5df3" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtMaturitiesAfterOneThroughFiveYearsFairValue_d4921e7d-ef85-4861-95c8-9861a87c2b34" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtMaturitiesAfterFiveThroughTenYearsFairValue_2ffe9ec1-68c2-421a-914e-ddf44d487d8f" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtMaturitiesAfterFiveThroughTenYearsFairValue"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtMaturitiesFairValueAbstract_a6e796ba-74ea-441d-9afd-d5a1b90a5df3" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtMaturitiesAfterFiveThroughTenYearsFairValue_2ffe9ec1-68c2-421a-914e-ddf44d487d8f" xlink:type="arc" order="3"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtMaturitiesAfterTenYearsFairValue_b1a0f1f7-590a-44fe-9987-69c284b32508" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtMaturitiesAfterTenYearsFairValue"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtMaturitiesFairValueAbstract_a6e796ba-74ea-441d-9afd-d5a1b90a5df3" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtMaturitiesAfterTenYearsFairValue_b1a0f1f7-590a-44fe-9987-69c284b32508" xlink:type="arc" order="4"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtMaturitiesExcludingAbsAndMbsFairValue_6b2e8971-ec55-456b-9baf-30dc7a256a4b" xlink:href="afg-20240930.xsd#afg_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtMaturitiesExcludingAbsAndMbsFairValue"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtMaturitiesFairValueAbstract_a6e796ba-74ea-441d-9afd-d5a1b90a5df3" xlink:to="loc_afg_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtMaturitiesExcludingAbsAndMbsFairValue_6b2e8971-ec55-456b-9baf-30dc7a256a4b" xlink:type="arc" order="5"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtMaturitiesWithoutSingleMaturityDateFairValue_9e933fbc-2051-49fb-8ea2-0b2a65ca9a62" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtMaturitiesWithoutSingleMaturityDateFairValue"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtMaturitiesFairValueAbstract_a6e796ba-74ea-441d-9afd-d5a1b90a5df3" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtMaturitiesWithoutSingleMaturityDateFairValue_9e933fbc-2051-49fb-8ea2-0b2a65ca9a62" xlink:type="arc" order="6"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtSecurities_e453a587-663e-49c6-a02e-a7b71a699f4d" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtSecurities"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtMaturitiesFairValueAbstract_a6e796ba-74ea-441d-9afd-d5a1b90a5df3" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtSecurities_e453a587-663e-49c6-a02e-a7b71a699f4d" xlink:type="arc" order="7"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtMaturitiesFairValuePercentFiscalYearMaturityAbstract_84950cb9-29d8-45eb-961e-ccad6231adc0" xlink:href="afg-20240930.xsd#afg_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtMaturitiesFairValuePercentFiscalYearMaturityAbstract"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtMaturitiesAbstract_24f0c49d-7e29-4e8a-aed9-e3ad80e99f10" xlink:to="loc_afg_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtMaturitiesFairValuePercentFiscalYearMaturityAbstract_84950cb9-29d8-45eb-961e-ccad6231adc0" xlink:type="arc" order="3"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtMaturitiesWithinOneYearFairValuePercent_591dc636-0dda-4679-8833-1186af8b858c" xlink:href="afg-20240930.xsd#afg_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtMaturitiesWithinOneYearFairValuePercent"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_afg_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtMaturitiesFairValuePercentFiscalYearMaturityAbstract_84950cb9-29d8-45eb-961e-ccad6231adc0" xlink:to="loc_afg_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtMaturitiesWithinOneYearFairValuePercent_591dc636-0dda-4679-8833-1186af8b858c" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtMaturitiesAfterOneThroughFiveYearsFairValuePercent_ca007f48-6fa2-4bb2-9e7f-8b0038b6da69" xlink:href="afg-20240930.xsd#afg_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtMaturitiesAfterOneThroughFiveYearsFairValuePercent"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_afg_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtMaturitiesFairValuePercentFiscalYearMaturityAbstract_84950cb9-29d8-45eb-961e-ccad6231adc0" xlink:to="loc_afg_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtMaturitiesAfterOneThroughFiveYearsFairValuePercent_ca007f48-6fa2-4bb2-9e7f-8b0038b6da69" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtMaturitiesAfterFiveThroughTenYearsFairValuePercent_ee54556a-afc0-46db-96ca-f4d3ed8e6a24" xlink:href="afg-20240930.xsd#afg_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtMaturitiesAfterFiveThroughTenYearsFairValuePercent"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_afg_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtMaturitiesFairValuePercentFiscalYearMaturityAbstract_84950cb9-29d8-45eb-961e-ccad6231adc0" xlink:to="loc_afg_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtMaturitiesAfterFiveThroughTenYearsFairValuePercent_ee54556a-afc0-46db-96ca-f4d3ed8e6a24" xlink:type="arc" order="3"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtMaturitiesAfterTenYearsFairValuePercent_711c6b27-c5f6-408b-ad84-977a06da5b48" xlink:href="afg-20240930.xsd#afg_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtMaturitiesAfterTenYearsFairValuePercent"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_afg_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtMaturitiesFairValuePercentFiscalYearMaturityAbstract_84950cb9-29d8-45eb-961e-ccad6231adc0" xlink:to="loc_afg_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtMaturitiesAfterTenYearsFairValuePercent_711c6b27-c5f6-408b-ad84-977a06da5b48" xlink:type="arc" order="4"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtMaturitiesExcludingAbsAndMbsFairValuePercent_3f8c2bd5-cc51-40b1-aebc-845e52068d40" xlink:href="afg-20240930.xsd#afg_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtMaturitiesExcludingAbsAndMbsFairValuePercent"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_afg_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtMaturitiesFairValuePercentFiscalYearMaturityAbstract_84950cb9-29d8-45eb-961e-ccad6231adc0" xlink:to="loc_afg_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtMaturitiesExcludingAbsAndMbsFairValuePercent_3f8c2bd5-cc51-40b1-aebc-845e52068d40" xlink:type="arc" order="5"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtMaturitiesWithoutSingleMaturityDateFairValuePercent_3b266ed3-9435-4949-8a16-22ef531502be" xlink:href="afg-20240930.xsd#afg_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtMaturitiesWithoutSingleMaturityDateFairValuePercent"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_afg_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtMaturitiesFairValuePercentFiscalYearMaturityAbstract_84950cb9-29d8-45eb-961e-ccad6231adc0" xlink:to="loc_afg_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtMaturitiesWithoutSingleMaturityDateFairValuePercent_3b266ed3-9435-4949-8a16-22ef531502be" xlink:type="arc" order="6"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtMaturitiesFairValuePercent_a7784d44-a22c-4d7f-9ce7-6890487de45a" xlink:href="afg-20240930.xsd#afg_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtMaturitiesFairValuePercent"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_afg_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtMaturitiesFairValuePercentFiscalYearMaturityAbstract_84950cb9-29d8-45eb-961e-ccad6231adc0" xlink:to="loc_afg_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtMaturitiesFairValuePercent_a7784d44-a22c-4d7f-9ce7-6890487de45a" xlink:type="arc" order="7"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_CollateralizedLoanObligationsandOtherAssetBackedSecuritiesAverageUsefulLife_194daaff-af96-4797-9d4e-bb09ecb1f569" xlink:href="afg-20240930.xsd#afg_CollateralizedLoanObligationsandOtherAssetBackedSecuritiesAverageUsefulLife"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtMaturitiesAbstract_24f0c49d-7e29-4e8a-aed9-e3ad80e99f10" xlink:to="loc_afg_CollateralizedLoanObligationsandOtherAssetBackedSecuritiesAverageUsefulLife_194daaff-af96-4797-9d4e-bb09ecb1f569" xlink:type="arc" order="4"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_MortgageBackedSecuritiesAverageUsefulLife_0813fd86-d050-4d86-b86a-8185c44c0b16" xlink:href="afg-20240930.xsd#afg_MortgageBackedSecuritiesAverageUsefulLife"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtMaturitiesAbstract_24f0c49d-7e29-4e8a-aed9-e3ad80e99f10" xlink:to="loc_afg_MortgageBackedSecuritiesAverageUsefulLife_0813fd86-d050-4d86-b86a-8185c44c0b16" xlink:type="arc" order="5"/>
  </link:definitionLink>
  <link:roleRef roleURI="http://www.afginc.com/role/InvestmentsScheduleofsourcesofnetinvestmentincomeDetails" xlink:type="simple" xlink:href="afg-20240930.xsd#InvestmentsScheduleofsourcesofnetinvestmentincomeDetails"/>
  <link:definitionLink xlink:role="http://www.afginc.com/role/InvestmentsScheduleofsourcesofnetinvestmentincomeDetails" xlink:type="extended">
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfInvestmentIncomeReportedAmountsByCategoryLineItems_38ee0c0b-40c4-44f0-961d-8ddad72beded" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_ScheduleOfInvestmentIncomeReportedAmountsByCategoryLineItems"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfInvestmentIncomeReportedAmountsByCategoryTable_18d09922-8fa7-4336-8e0d-eae646eedc32" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_ScheduleOfInvestmentIncomeReportedAmountsByCategoryTable"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/all" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfInvestmentIncomeReportedAmountsByCategoryLineItems_38ee0c0b-40c4-44f0-961d-8ddad72beded" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfInvestmentIncomeReportedAmountsByCategoryTable_18d09922-8fa7-4336-8e0d-eae646eedc32" xlink:type="arc" order="1" xbrldt:closed="true" xbrldt:contextElement="segment"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_DividendsAxis_dda077f3-9489-487d-b7c9-26ee4406f6f4" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_DividendsAxis"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/hypercube-dimension" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfInvestmentIncomeReportedAmountsByCategoryTable_18d09922-8fa7-4336-8e0d-eae646eedc32" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_DividendsAxis_dda077f3-9489-487d-b7c9-26ee4406f6f4" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_DividendsDomain_dda077f3-9489-487d-b7c9-26ee4406f6f4_default" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_DividendsDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-default" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DividendsAxis_dda077f3-9489-487d-b7c9-26ee4406f6f4" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_DividendsDomain_dda077f3-9489-487d-b7c9-26ee4406f6f4_default" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_DividendsDomain_a4f74b2a-4b00-45d8-ac7e-e406aff22cbe" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_DividendsDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-domain" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DividendsAxis_dda077f3-9489-487d-b7c9-26ee4406f6f4" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_DividendsDomain_a4f74b2a-4b00-45d8-ac7e-e406aff22cbe" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_InvestmentIncomeMember_a5b14615-e580-4f3a-94e2-22663a1a1335" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_InvestmentIncomeMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DividendsDomain_a4f74b2a-4b00-45d8-ac7e-e406aff22cbe" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_InvestmentIncomeMember_a5b14615-e580-4f3a-94e2-22663a1a1335" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_InvestmentTypeAxis_1433a33a-35af-4edb-8ed6-9b271a982050" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_InvestmentTypeAxis"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/hypercube-dimension" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfInvestmentIncomeReportedAmountsByCategoryTable_18d09922-8fa7-4336-8e0d-eae646eedc32" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_InvestmentTypeAxis_1433a33a-35af-4edb-8ed6-9b271a982050" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_InvestmentTypeCategorizationMember_1433a33a-35af-4edb-8ed6-9b271a982050_default" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_InvestmentTypeCategorizationMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-default" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_InvestmentTypeAxis_1433a33a-35af-4edb-8ed6-9b271a982050" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_InvestmentTypeCategorizationMember_1433a33a-35af-4edb-8ed6-9b271a982050_default" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_InvestmentTypeCategorizationMember_609488dd-be0b-405b-9eb0-d7d6763b782f" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_InvestmentTypeCategorizationMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-domain" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_InvestmentTypeAxis_1433a33a-35af-4edb-8ed6-9b271a982050" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_InvestmentTypeCategorizationMember_609488dd-be0b-405b-9eb0-d7d6763b782f" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_FixedMaturitiesMember_4924ac02-763e-4ad5-9580-e162211c74f4" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_FixedMaturitiesMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_InvestmentTypeCategorizationMember_609488dd-be0b-405b-9eb0-d7d6763b782f" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_FixedMaturitiesMember_4924ac02-763e-4ad5-9580-e162211c74f4" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_EquitySecuritiesMember_2eda0ef8-6a34-4469-8200-2324cb8d56a7" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_EquitySecuritiesMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_InvestmentTypeCategorizationMember_609488dd-be0b-405b-9eb0-d7d6763b782f" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_EquitySecuritiesMember_2eda0ef8-6a34-4469-8200-2324cb8d56a7" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_OtherLongTermInvestmentsMember_13a69007-840c-47a7-86ce-830019ddab16" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_OtherLongTermInvestmentsMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_InvestmentTypeCategorizationMember_609488dd-be0b-405b-9eb0-d7d6763b782f" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_OtherLongTermInvestmentsMember_13a69007-840c-47a7-86ce-830019ddab16" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_IncomeStatementLocationAxis_62face7c-1a71-4936-b890-b2e0a4459e4c" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_IncomeStatementLocationAxis"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/hypercube-dimension" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfInvestmentIncomeReportedAmountsByCategoryTable_18d09922-8fa7-4336-8e0d-eae646eedc32" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_IncomeStatementLocationAxis_62face7c-1a71-4936-b890-b2e0a4459e4c" xlink:type="arc" order="3"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_IncomeStatementLocationDomain_62face7c-1a71-4936-b890-b2e0a4459e4c_default" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_IncomeStatementLocationDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-default" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_IncomeStatementLocationAxis_62face7c-1a71-4936-b890-b2e0a4459e4c" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_IncomeStatementLocationDomain_62face7c-1a71-4936-b890-b2e0a4459e4c_default" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_IncomeStatementLocationDomain_a3f9c5c8-fafe-4bbd-aeb2-79e514a905fe" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_IncomeStatementLocationDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-domain" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_IncomeStatementLocationAxis_62face7c-1a71-4936-b890-b2e0a4459e4c" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_IncomeStatementLocationDomain_a3f9c5c8-fafe-4bbd-aeb2-79e514a905fe" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_InvestmentIncomeMember_babeb70d-01bf-49b8-b1b8-ee5cdfab0346" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_InvestmentIncomeMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_IncomeStatementLocationDomain_a3f9c5c8-fafe-4bbd-aeb2-79e514a905fe" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_InvestmentIncomeMember_babeb70d-01bf-49b8-b1b8-ee5cdfab0346" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_ChangeInFairValueAxis_b27b5c99-6df3-4d34-89e6-43434932322e" xlink:href="afg-20240930.xsd#afg_ChangeInFairValueAxis"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/hypercube-dimension" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfInvestmentIncomeReportedAmountsByCategoryTable_18d09922-8fa7-4336-8e0d-eae646eedc32" xlink:to="loc_afg_ChangeInFairValueAxis_b27b5c99-6df3-4d34-89e6-43434932322e" xlink:type="arc" order="4"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_ChangeInFairValueDomain_b27b5c99-6df3-4d34-89e6-43434932322e_default" xlink:href="afg-20240930.xsd#afg_ChangeInFairValueDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-default" xlink:from="loc_afg_ChangeInFairValueAxis_b27b5c99-6df3-4d34-89e6-43434932322e" xlink:to="loc_afg_ChangeInFairValueDomain_b27b5c99-6df3-4d34-89e6-43434932322e_default" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_ChangeInFairValueDomain_3c920c7a-abb1-4696-8eae-ca3c3c9a3d34" xlink:href="afg-20240930.xsd#afg_ChangeInFairValueDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-domain" xlink:from="loc_afg_ChangeInFairValueAxis_b27b5c99-6df3-4d34-89e6-43434932322e" xlink:to="loc_afg_ChangeInFairValueDomain_3c920c7a-abb1-4696-8eae-ca3c3c9a3d34" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_InvestmentIncomeMember_894b7526-7534-4e06-80fe-17ebb4b622aa" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_InvestmentIncomeMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_afg_ChangeInFairValueDomain_3c920c7a-abb1-4696-8eae-ca3c3c9a3d34" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_InvestmentIncomeMember_894b7526-7534-4e06-80fe-17ebb4b622aa" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_InterestAndAmortizationAxis_bc8f0776-2306-4349-8580-5e8675a092ae" xlink:href="afg-20240930.xsd#afg_InterestAndAmortizationAxis"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/hypercube-dimension" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfInvestmentIncomeReportedAmountsByCategoryTable_18d09922-8fa7-4336-8e0d-eae646eedc32" xlink:to="loc_afg_InterestAndAmortizationAxis_bc8f0776-2306-4349-8580-5e8675a092ae" xlink:type="arc" order="5"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_InterestAndAmortizationDomain_bc8f0776-2306-4349-8580-5e8675a092ae_default" xlink:href="afg-20240930.xsd#afg_InterestAndAmortizationDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-default" xlink:from="loc_afg_InterestAndAmortizationAxis_bc8f0776-2306-4349-8580-5e8675a092ae" xlink:to="loc_afg_InterestAndAmortizationDomain_bc8f0776-2306-4349-8580-5e8675a092ae_default" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_InterestAndAmortizationDomain_9dd347bb-9bfe-482e-a18d-a06de6201b35" xlink:href="afg-20240930.xsd#afg_InterestAndAmortizationDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-domain" xlink:from="loc_afg_InterestAndAmortizationAxis_bc8f0776-2306-4349-8580-5e8675a092ae" xlink:to="loc_afg_InterestAndAmortizationDomain_9dd347bb-9bfe-482e-a18d-a06de6201b35" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_InvestmentIncomeMember_9c5b0afd-95e7-442a-b257-4e70aa987e29" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_InvestmentIncomeMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_afg_InterestAndAmortizationDomain_9dd347bb-9bfe-482e-a18d-a06de6201b35" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_InvestmentIncomeMember_9c5b0afd-95e7-442a-b257-4e70aa987e29" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_GrossInvestmentIncomeOperating_90da4623-16c6-43b9-ba6f-d294b71c880c" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_GrossInvestmentIncomeOperating"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfInvestmentIncomeReportedAmountsByCategoryLineItems_38ee0c0b-40c4-44f0-961d-8ddad72beded" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_GrossInvestmentIncomeOperating_90da4623-16c6-43b9-ba6f-d294b71c880c" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_DebtSecuritiesTradingAndConvertibleGainLoss_e1a119ca-2afb-438a-b455-12ea1cd7e624" xlink:href="afg-20240930.xsd#afg_DebtSecuritiesTradingAndConvertibleGainLoss"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfInvestmentIncomeReportedAmountsByCategoryLineItems_38ee0c0b-40c4-44f0-961d-8ddad72beded" xlink:to="loc_afg_DebtSecuritiesTradingAndConvertibleGainLoss_e1a119ca-2afb-438a-b455-12ea1cd7e624" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_DividendIncomeOperating_ba3dd242-430b-4fa0-987f-e7ef8c0765ff" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_DividendIncomeOperating"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfInvestmentIncomeReportedAmountsByCategoryLineItems_38ee0c0b-40c4-44f0-961d-8ddad72beded" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_DividendIncomeOperating_ba3dd242-430b-4fa0-987f-e7ef8c0765ff" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_EquitySecuritiesFvNiGainLoss_8ffec019-e713-46cf-bc14-d30772846963" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_EquitySecuritiesFvNiGainLoss"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfInvestmentIncomeReportedAmountsByCategoryLineItems_38ee0c0b-40c4-44f0-961d-8ddad72beded" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_EquitySecuritiesFvNiGainLoss_8ffec019-e713-46cf-bc14-d30772846963" xlink:type="arc" order="3"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_IncomeLossFromEquityMethodInvestments_2607b6ee-e0d0-45d2-897f-f6c5644a8f39" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_IncomeLossFromEquityMethodInvestments"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfInvestmentIncomeReportedAmountsByCategoryLineItems_38ee0c0b-40c4-44f0-961d-8ddad72beded" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_IncomeLossFromEquityMethodInvestments_2607b6ee-e0d0-45d2-897f-f6c5644a8f39" xlink:type="arc" order="4"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_InvestmentIncomeInvestmentExpense_fba77d9b-3267-4878-b57d-94a8200cac6a" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_InvestmentIncomeInvestmentExpense"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfInvestmentIncomeReportedAmountsByCategoryLineItems_38ee0c0b-40c4-44f0-961d-8ddad72beded" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_InvestmentIncomeInvestmentExpense_fba77d9b-3267-4878-b57d-94a8200cac6a" xlink:type="arc" order="5"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_NetInvestmentIncome_a589e7e9-2a9f-4509-8ab2-578112c04093" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_NetInvestmentIncome"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfInvestmentIncomeReportedAmountsByCategoryLineItems_38ee0c0b-40c4-44f0-961d-8ddad72beded" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_NetInvestmentIncome_a589e7e9-2a9f-4509-8ab2-578112c04093" xlink:type="arc" order="6"/>
  </link:definitionLink>
  <link:roleRef roleURI="http://www.afginc.com/role/InvestmentsRealizedgainslossesandchangesinunrealizedappreciationdepreciationrelatedtofixedmaturityandequitysecurityinvestmentsDetails" xlink:type="simple" xlink:href="afg-20240930.xsd#InvestmentsRealizedgainslossesandchangesinunrealizedappreciationdepreciationrelatedtofixedmaturityandequitysecurityinvestmentsDetails"/>
  <link:definitionLink xlink:role="http://www.afginc.com/role/InvestmentsRealizedgainslossesandchangesinunrealizedappreciationdepreciationrelatedtofixedmaturityandequitysecurityinvestmentsDetails" xlink:type="extended">
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfAvailableForSaleSecuritiesLineItems_10b916b9-0759-4890-895a-700febafc152" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_ScheduleOfAvailableForSaleSecuritiesLineItems"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_DebtSecuritiesAvailableForSaleTable_b31fc295-f180-4534-8b8a-0ffd56f1cd8c" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_DebtSecuritiesAvailableForSaleTable"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/all" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfAvailableForSaleSecuritiesLineItems_10b916b9-0759-4890-895a-700febafc152" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_DebtSecuritiesAvailableForSaleTable_b31fc295-f180-4534-8b8a-0ffd56f1cd8c" xlink:type="arc" order="1" xbrldt:closed="true" xbrldt:contextElement="segment"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_FinancialInstrumentAxis_4561c36d-3abc-4649-b1c1-9d8f122becba" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_FinancialInstrumentAxis"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/hypercube-dimension" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DebtSecuritiesAvailableForSaleTable_b31fc295-f180-4534-8b8a-0ffd56f1cd8c" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_FinancialInstrumentAxis_4561c36d-3abc-4649-b1c1-9d8f122becba" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_TransfersAndServicingOfFinancialInstrumentsTypesOfFinancialInstrumentsDomain_4561c36d-3abc-4649-b1c1-9d8f122becba_default" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_TransfersAndServicingOfFinancialInstrumentsTypesOfFinancialInstrumentsDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-default" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FinancialInstrumentAxis_4561c36d-3abc-4649-b1c1-9d8f122becba" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_TransfersAndServicingOfFinancialInstrumentsTypesOfFinancialInstrumentsDomain_4561c36d-3abc-4649-b1c1-9d8f122becba_default" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_TransfersAndServicingOfFinancialInstrumentsTypesOfFinancialInstrumentsDomain_76630afe-d79c-4bdb-ab86-77877be5408f" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_TransfersAndServicingOfFinancialInstrumentsTypesOfFinancialInstrumentsDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-domain" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FinancialInstrumentAxis_4561c36d-3abc-4649-b1c1-9d8f122becba" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_TransfersAndServicingOfFinancialInstrumentsTypesOfFinancialInstrumentsDomain_76630afe-d79c-4bdb-ab86-77877be5408f" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_NetOfTaxMember_8726b422-4e74-461b-bb22-df477bc7a283" xlink:href="afg-20240930.xsd#afg_NetOfTaxMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_TransfersAndServicingOfFinancialInstrumentsTypesOfFinancialInstrumentsDomain_76630afe-d79c-4bdb-ab86-77877be5408f" xlink:to="loc_afg_NetOfTaxMember_8726b422-4e74-461b-bb22-df477bc7a283" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_PretaxMember_82d82b9e-6738-4f8c-889c-405c536d8f0d" xlink:href="afg-20240930.xsd#afg_PretaxMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_afg_NetOfTaxMember_8726b422-4e74-461b-bb22-df477bc7a283" xlink:to="loc_afg_PretaxMember_82d82b9e-6738-4f8c-889c-405c536d8f0d" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_FixedMaturitiesMember_1e27cd6b-fe1b-4baa-8503-e1e4c01136a1" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_FixedMaturitiesMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_afg_PretaxMember_82d82b9e-6738-4f8c-889c-405c536d8f0d" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_FixedMaturitiesMember_1e27cd6b-fe1b-4baa-8503-e1e4c01136a1" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_EquitySecuritiesMember_60e4e69d-e87d-4cd0-a00b-babba17c169e" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_EquitySecuritiesMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_afg_PretaxMember_82d82b9e-6738-4f8c-889c-405c536d8f0d" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_EquitySecuritiesMember_60e4e69d-e87d-4cd0-a00b-babba17c169e" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_MortgageLoansAndOtherInvestmentsMember_3875484c-cf5b-4120-862a-ed7fe26a8efb" xlink:href="afg-20240930.xsd#afg_MortgageLoansAndOtherInvestmentsMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_afg_PretaxMember_82d82b9e-6738-4f8c-889c-405c536d8f0d" xlink:to="loc_afg_MortgageLoansAndOtherInvestmentsMember_3875484c-cf5b-4120-862a-ed7fe26a8efb" xlink:type="arc" order="3"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_TaxEffectsMember_f915218e-07b7-4f90-b25d-806c8a94e4a5" xlink:href="afg-20240930.xsd#afg_TaxEffectsMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_TransfersAndServicingOfFinancialInstrumentsTypesOfFinancialInstrumentsDomain_76630afe-d79c-4bdb-ab86-77877be5408f" xlink:to="loc_afg_TaxEffectsMember_f915218e-07b7-4f90-b25d-806c8a94e4a5" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_RealizedGainsLossesAndChangesInUnrealizedAppreciationDepreciationRelatedToFixedMaturityAndEquitySecurityInvestmentsAbstract_254d80a5-7663-465c-9f56-756e7ea7d766" xlink:href="afg-20240930.xsd#afg_RealizedGainsLossesAndChangesInUnrealizedAppreciationDepreciationRelatedToFixedMaturityAndEquitySecurityInvestmentsAbstract"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfAvailableForSaleSecuritiesLineItems_10b916b9-0759-4890-895a-700febafc152" xlink:to="loc_afg_RealizedGainsLossesAndChangesInUnrealizedAppreciationDepreciationRelatedToFixedMaturityAndEquitySecurityInvestmentsAbstract_254d80a5-7663-465c-9f56-756e7ea7d766" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_MarketableSecuritiesRealizedGainLossExcludingOtherThanTemporaryImpairments_977626fa-f349-482d-9e82-c69a0bbf2fa0" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_MarketableSecuritiesRealizedGainLossExcludingOtherThanTemporaryImpairments"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_afg_RealizedGainsLossesAndChangesInUnrealizedAppreciationDepreciationRelatedToFixedMaturityAndEquitySecurityInvestmentsAbstract_254d80a5-7663-465c-9f56-756e7ea7d766" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_MarketableSecuritiesRealizedGainLossExcludingOtherThanTemporaryImpairments_977626fa-f349-482d-9e82-c69a0bbf2fa0" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_DebtSecuritiesAvailableForSaleAllowanceForCreditLossPeriodIncreaseDecrease_8f124f6d-52a3-40d4-9a65-9704701ffeab" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_DebtSecuritiesAvailableForSaleAllowanceForCreditLossPeriodIncreaseDecrease"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_afg_RealizedGainsLossesAndChangesInUnrealizedAppreciationDepreciationRelatedToFixedMaturityAndEquitySecurityInvestmentsAbstract_254d80a5-7663-465c-9f56-756e7ea7d766" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_DebtSecuritiesAvailableForSaleAllowanceForCreditLossPeriodIncreaseDecrease_8f124f6d-52a3-40d4-9a65-9704701ffeab" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_FinancingReceivableAllowanceForCreditLossesPeriodIncreaseDecrease_84f095c0-460d-4223-9dfb-e0639bb82538" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_FinancingReceivableAllowanceForCreditLossesPeriodIncreaseDecrease"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_afg_RealizedGainsLossesAndChangesInUnrealizedAppreciationDepreciationRelatedToFixedMaturityAndEquitySecurityInvestmentsAbstract_254d80a5-7663-465c-9f56-756e7ea7d766" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_FinancingReceivableAllowanceForCreditLossesPeriodIncreaseDecrease_84f095c0-460d-4223-9dfb-e0639bb82538" xlink:type="arc" order="3"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_InvestmentsAllowanceForCreditLossPeriodIncreaseDecrease_027d81c5-5cbc-47bf-8841-2643334dbdc2" xlink:href="afg-20240930.xsd#afg_InvestmentsAllowanceForCreditLossPeriodIncreaseDecrease"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_afg_RealizedGainsLossesAndChangesInUnrealizedAppreciationDepreciationRelatedToFixedMaturityAndEquitySecurityInvestmentsAbstract_254d80a5-7663-465c-9f56-756e7ea7d766" xlink:to="loc_afg_InvestmentsAllowanceForCreditLossPeriodIncreaseDecrease_027d81c5-5cbc-47bf-8841-2643334dbdc2" xlink:type="arc" order="4"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_DebtAndEquitySecuritiesRealizedGainLoss_c238378c-4a2f-447d-87a5-6c7767f8a26e" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_DebtAndEquitySecuritiesRealizedGainLoss"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_afg_RealizedGainsLossesAndChangesInUnrealizedAppreciationDepreciationRelatedToFixedMaturityAndEquitySecurityInvestmentsAbstract_254d80a5-7663-465c-9f56-756e7ea7d766" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_DebtAndEquitySecuritiesRealizedGainLoss_c238378c-4a2f-447d-87a5-6c7767f8a26e" xlink:type="arc" order="5"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_ChangeInUnrealizedAppreciationDepreciation_e4fb2512-391b-45ad-92dd-9b8e9456fc3f" xlink:href="afg-20240930.xsd#afg_ChangeInUnrealizedAppreciationDepreciation"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_afg_RealizedGainsLossesAndChangesInUnrealizedAppreciationDepreciationRelatedToFixedMaturityAndEquitySecurityInvestmentsAbstract_254d80a5-7663-465c-9f56-756e7ea7d766" xlink:to="loc_afg_ChangeInUnrealizedAppreciationDepreciation_e4fb2512-391b-45ad-92dd-9b8e9456fc3f" xlink:type="arc" order="6"/>
  </link:definitionLink>
  <link:roleRef roleURI="http://www.afginc.com/role/InvestmentsHoldinggainslossesonequitysecuritiesstillheldDetails" xlink:type="simple" xlink:href="afg-20240930.xsd#InvestmentsHoldinggainslossesonequitysecuritiesstillheldDetails"/>
  <link:definitionLink xlink:role="http://www.afginc.com/role/InvestmentsHoldinggainslossesonequitysecuritiesstillheldDetails" xlink:type="extended">
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_HoldingGainsLossesonEquitySecuritiesStillHeldLineItems_4b51bc72-dda0-4e3c-89e7-7470a1c8371d" xlink:href="afg-20240930.xsd#afg_HoldingGainsLossesonEquitySecuritiesStillHeldLineItems"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_HoldingGainsLossesonEquitySecuritiesStillHeldTable_1d6e2248-eb7c-4be4-bbcc-8a70a3a47ea3" xlink:href="afg-20240930.xsd#afg_HoldingGainsLossesonEquitySecuritiesStillHeldTable"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/all" xlink:from="loc_afg_HoldingGainsLossesonEquitySecuritiesStillHeldLineItems_4b51bc72-dda0-4e3c-89e7-7470a1c8371d" xlink:to="loc_afg_HoldingGainsLossesonEquitySecuritiesStillHeldTable_1d6e2248-eb7c-4be4-bbcc-8a70a3a47ea3" xlink:type="arc" order="1" xbrldt:closed="true" xbrldt:contextElement="segment"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_IncomeStatementLocationAxis_8b326133-85b4-4f7f-a61c-485ad78c0ba7" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_IncomeStatementLocationAxis"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/hypercube-dimension" xlink:from="loc_afg_HoldingGainsLossesonEquitySecuritiesStillHeldTable_1d6e2248-eb7c-4be4-bbcc-8a70a3a47ea3" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_IncomeStatementLocationAxis_8b326133-85b4-4f7f-a61c-485ad78c0ba7" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_IncomeStatementLocationDomain_8b326133-85b4-4f7f-a61c-485ad78c0ba7_default" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_IncomeStatementLocationDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-default" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_IncomeStatementLocationAxis_8b326133-85b4-4f7f-a61c-485ad78c0ba7" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_IncomeStatementLocationDomain_8b326133-85b4-4f7f-a61c-485ad78c0ba7_default" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_IncomeStatementLocationDomain_9b76cb4c-224a-486a-813e-16b2ef12af59" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_IncomeStatementLocationDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-domain" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_IncomeStatementLocationAxis_8b326133-85b4-4f7f-a61c-485ad78c0ba7" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_IncomeStatementLocationDomain_9b76cb4c-224a-486a-813e-16b2ef12af59" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_RealizedGainsLossesOnSecuritiesMember_8d98fb79-06ea-4569-8f90-677a3e51bc01" xlink:href="afg-20240930.xsd#afg_RealizedGainsLossesOnSecuritiesMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_IncomeStatementLocationDomain_9b76cb4c-224a-486a-813e-16b2ef12af59" xlink:to="loc_afg_RealizedGainsLossesOnSecuritiesMember_8d98fb79-06ea-4569-8f90-677a3e51bc01" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_InvestmentIncomeMember_24b10230-3c4a-4097-a4e6-b3c7c1fc11b0" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_InvestmentIncomeMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_IncomeStatementLocationDomain_9b76cb4c-224a-486a-813e-16b2ef12af59" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_InvestmentIncomeMember_24b10230-3c4a-4097-a4e6-b3c7c1fc11b0" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_EquitySecuritiesFvNiUnrealizedGainLoss_68aeb470-c328-4b63-923a-7f6ce34a8eb4" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_EquitySecuritiesFvNiUnrealizedGainLoss"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_afg_HoldingGainsLossesonEquitySecuritiesStillHeldLineItems_4b51bc72-dda0-4e3c-89e7-7470a1c8371d" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_EquitySecuritiesFvNiUnrealizedGainLoss_68aeb470-c328-4b63-923a-7f6ce34a8eb4" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
  </link:definitionLink>
  <link:roleRef roleURI="http://www.afginc.com/role/InvestmentsGrossrealizedgainsandlossesonavailableforsalefixedmaturityinvestmenttransactionsDetails" xlink:type="simple" xlink:href="afg-20240930.xsd#InvestmentsGrossrealizedgainsandlossesonavailableforsalefixedmaturityinvestmenttransactionsDetails"/>
  <link:definitionLink xlink:role="http://www.afginc.com/role/InvestmentsGrossrealizedgainsandlossesonavailableforsalefixedmaturityinvestmenttransactionsDetails" xlink:type="extended">
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfAvailableForSaleSecuritiesLineItems_a63d7544-eb4f-4034-b8c6-fdde02dd635b" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_ScheduleOfAvailableForSaleSecuritiesLineItems"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_DebtSecuritiesAvailableForSaleTable_ba4d155e-43f2-4d25-b55e-36498f308098" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_DebtSecuritiesAvailableForSaleTable"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/all" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfAvailableForSaleSecuritiesLineItems_a63d7544-eb4f-4034-b8c6-fdde02dd635b" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_DebtSecuritiesAvailableForSaleTable_ba4d155e-43f2-4d25-b55e-36498f308098" xlink:type="arc" order="1" xbrldt:closed="true" xbrldt:contextElement="segment"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_FinancialInstrumentAxis_5063c42f-fc4b-4282-89ec-a635b1e13ed3" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_FinancialInstrumentAxis"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/hypercube-dimension" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DebtSecuritiesAvailableForSaleTable_ba4d155e-43f2-4d25-b55e-36498f308098" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_FinancialInstrumentAxis_5063c42f-fc4b-4282-89ec-a635b1e13ed3" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_TransfersAndServicingOfFinancialInstrumentsTypesOfFinancialInstrumentsDomain_5063c42f-fc4b-4282-89ec-a635b1e13ed3_default" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_TransfersAndServicingOfFinancialInstrumentsTypesOfFinancialInstrumentsDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-default" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FinancialInstrumentAxis_5063c42f-fc4b-4282-89ec-a635b1e13ed3" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_TransfersAndServicingOfFinancialInstrumentsTypesOfFinancialInstrumentsDomain_5063c42f-fc4b-4282-89ec-a635b1e13ed3_default" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_TransfersAndServicingOfFinancialInstrumentsTypesOfFinancialInstrumentsDomain_1fe324ad-5060-4caa-9c3c-cc2c5f377c64" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_TransfersAndServicingOfFinancialInstrumentsTypesOfFinancialInstrumentsDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-domain" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FinancialInstrumentAxis_5063c42f-fc4b-4282-89ec-a635b1e13ed3" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_TransfersAndServicingOfFinancialInstrumentsTypesOfFinancialInstrumentsDomain_1fe324ad-5060-4caa-9c3c-cc2c5f377c64" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_FixedMaturitiesMember_9b7c4952-eb3c-4301-994f-212c58cda5c5" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_FixedMaturitiesMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_TransfersAndServicingOfFinancialInstrumentsTypesOfFinancialInstrumentsDomain_1fe324ad-5060-4caa-9c3c-cc2c5f377c64" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_FixedMaturitiesMember_9b7c4952-eb3c-4301-994f-212c58cda5c5" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesGrossRealizedGainLossAbstract_785c9306-617c-48de-8e26-8b44aaec901d" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesGrossRealizedGainLossAbstract"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfAvailableForSaleSecuritiesLineItems_a63d7544-eb4f-4034-b8c6-fdde02dd635b" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesGrossRealizedGainLossAbstract_785c9306-617c-48de-8e26-8b44aaec901d" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_DebtSecuritiesAvailableForSaleRealizedGain_d50573ca-fbe7-4315-bbdd-7341cd169b41" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_DebtSecuritiesAvailableForSaleRealizedGain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesGrossRealizedGainLossAbstract_785c9306-617c-48de-8e26-8b44aaec901d" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_DebtSecuritiesAvailableForSaleRealizedGain_d50573ca-fbe7-4315-bbdd-7341cd169b41" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_DebtSecuritiesAvailableForSaleRealizedLoss_dc010842-dd29-4b76-8d8e-1e0ac70017bd" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_DebtSecuritiesAvailableForSaleRealizedLoss"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesGrossRealizedGainLossAbstract_785c9306-617c-48de-8e26-8b44aaec901d" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_DebtSecuritiesAvailableForSaleRealizedLoss_dc010842-dd29-4b76-8d8e-1e0ac70017bd" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
  </link:definitionLink>
  <link:roleRef roleURI="http://www.afginc.com/role/DerivativesNarrativeDetails" xlink:type="simple" xlink:href="afg-20240930.xsd#DerivativesNarrativeDetails"/>
  <link:definitionLink xlink:role="http://www.afginc.com/role/DerivativesNarrativeDetails" xlink:type="extended">
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_DerivativeInstrumentsAndHedgingActivitiesDisclosuresLineItems_4fbdadfd-f1fc-4f2c-901e-158ac6c5a470" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_DerivativeInstrumentsAndHedgingActivitiesDisclosuresLineItems"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_DerivativeInstrumentsAndHedgingActivitiesDisclosuresTable_7a30f462-a115-4140-a51f-b72598b9127d" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_DerivativeInstrumentsAndHedgingActivitiesDisclosuresTable"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/all" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DerivativeInstrumentsAndHedgingActivitiesDisclosuresLineItems_4fbdadfd-f1fc-4f2c-901e-158ac6c5a470" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_DerivativeInstrumentsAndHedgingActivitiesDisclosuresTable_7a30f462-a115-4140-a51f-b72598b9127d" xlink:type="arc" order="1" xbrldt:closed="true" xbrldt:contextElement="segment"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_DerivativeInstrumentRiskAxis_98705794-313e-480f-8f44-53387c6ddbdc" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_DerivativeInstrumentRiskAxis"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/hypercube-dimension" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DerivativeInstrumentsAndHedgingActivitiesDisclosuresTable_7a30f462-a115-4140-a51f-b72598b9127d" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_DerivativeInstrumentRiskAxis_98705794-313e-480f-8f44-53387c6ddbdc" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_DerivativeContractTypeDomain_98705794-313e-480f-8f44-53387c6ddbdc_default" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_DerivativeContractTypeDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-default" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DerivativeInstrumentRiskAxis_98705794-313e-480f-8f44-53387c6ddbdc" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_DerivativeContractTypeDomain_98705794-313e-480f-8f44-53387c6ddbdc_default" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_DerivativeContractTypeDomain_acbe3bd4-5f98-422e-ae62-045169eefdc2" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_DerivativeContractTypeDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-domain" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DerivativeInstrumentRiskAxis_98705794-313e-480f-8f44-53387c6ddbdc" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_DerivativeContractTypeDomain_acbe3bd4-5f98-422e-ae62-045169eefdc2" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_InterestRateSwapMember_17f6737e-b1c3-4210-a510-4f23d1a6f8e6" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_InterestRateSwapMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DerivativeContractTypeDomain_acbe3bd4-5f98-422e-ae62-045169eefdc2" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_InterestRateSwapMember_17f6737e-b1c3-4210-a510-4f23d1a6f8e6" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_TotalReturnSwapMember_979b9639-6bc9-4039-9197-0dea4eb1dac0" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_TotalReturnSwapMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DerivativeContractTypeDomain_acbe3bd4-5f98-422e-ae62-045169eefdc2" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_TotalReturnSwapMember_979b9639-6bc9-4039-9197-0dea4eb1dac0" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_DerivativeInstrumentsGainLossByHedgingRelationshipAxis_3abcdd52-1678-47ad-9e3b-899c1e41e08b" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_DerivativeInstrumentsGainLossByHedgingRelationshipAxis"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/hypercube-dimension" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DerivativeInstrumentsAndHedgingActivitiesDisclosuresTable_7a30f462-a115-4140-a51f-b72598b9127d" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_DerivativeInstrumentsGainLossByHedgingRelationshipAxis_3abcdd52-1678-47ad-9e3b-899c1e41e08b" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_HedgingRelationshipDomain_3abcdd52-1678-47ad-9e3b-899c1e41e08b_default" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_HedgingRelationshipDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-default" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DerivativeInstrumentsGainLossByHedgingRelationshipAxis_3abcdd52-1678-47ad-9e3b-899c1e41e08b" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_HedgingRelationshipDomain_3abcdd52-1678-47ad-9e3b-899c1e41e08b_default" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_HedgingRelationshipDomain_dbafa07f-254b-456f-9510-252a10be74e9" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_HedgingRelationshipDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-domain" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DerivativeInstrumentsGainLossByHedgingRelationshipAxis_3abcdd52-1678-47ad-9e3b-899c1e41e08b" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_HedgingRelationshipDomain_dbafa07f-254b-456f-9510-252a10be74e9" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_CashFlowHedgingMember_4924c416-84a7-45ed-ada2-b211b461f875" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_CashFlowHedgingMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_HedgingRelationshipDomain_dbafa07f-254b-456f-9510-252a10be74e9" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_CashFlowHedgingMember_4924c416-84a7-45ed-ada2-b211b461f875" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_HedgingDesignationAxis_c0e4e7f4-0c72-44e2-9aaf-979156619d11" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_HedgingDesignationAxis"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/hypercube-dimension" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DerivativeInstrumentsAndHedgingActivitiesDisclosuresTable_7a30f462-a115-4140-a51f-b72598b9127d" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_HedgingDesignationAxis_c0e4e7f4-0c72-44e2-9aaf-979156619d11" xlink:type="arc" order="3"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_HedgingDesignationDomain_c0e4e7f4-0c72-44e2-9aaf-979156619d11_default" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_HedgingDesignationDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-default" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_HedgingDesignationAxis_c0e4e7f4-0c72-44e2-9aaf-979156619d11" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_HedgingDesignationDomain_c0e4e7f4-0c72-44e2-9aaf-979156619d11_default" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_HedgingDesignationDomain_bb8cd800-d11f-4b1d-95dc-a3eaca53481c" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_HedgingDesignationDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-domain" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_HedgingDesignationAxis_c0e4e7f4-0c72-44e2-9aaf-979156619d11" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_HedgingDesignationDomain_bb8cd800-d11f-4b1d-95dc-a3eaca53481c" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_DesignatedAsHedgingInstrumentMember_6acf8c58-4f83-444d-b9b2-7f042cf36d15" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_DesignatedAsHedgingInstrumentMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_HedgingDesignationDomain_bb8cd800-d11f-4b1d-95dc-a3eaca53481c" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_DesignatedAsHedgingInstrumentMember_6acf8c58-4f83-444d-b9b2-7f042cf36d15" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_NondesignatedMember_d2284a42-c3f6-4836-b576-265ab6240537" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_NondesignatedMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_HedgingDesignationDomain_bb8cd800-d11f-4b1d-95dc-a3eaca53481c" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_NondesignatedMember_d2284a42-c3f6-4836-b576-265ab6240537" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_IncomeStatementLocationAxis_af10125d-43ea-4434-b110-1731c2a06b94" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_IncomeStatementLocationAxis"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/hypercube-dimension" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DerivativeInstrumentsAndHedgingActivitiesDisclosuresTable_7a30f462-a115-4140-a51f-b72598b9127d" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_IncomeStatementLocationAxis_af10125d-43ea-4434-b110-1731c2a06b94" xlink:type="arc" order="4"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_IncomeStatementLocationDomain_af10125d-43ea-4434-b110-1731c2a06b94_default" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_IncomeStatementLocationDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-default" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_IncomeStatementLocationAxis_af10125d-43ea-4434-b110-1731c2a06b94" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_IncomeStatementLocationDomain_af10125d-43ea-4434-b110-1731c2a06b94_default" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_IncomeStatementLocationDomain_a6422a27-4a96-4696-bc76-641b2dc8ea20" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_IncomeStatementLocationDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-domain" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_IncomeStatementLocationAxis_af10125d-43ea-4434-b110-1731c2a06b94" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_IncomeStatementLocationDomain_a6422a27-4a96-4696-bc76-641b2dc8ea20" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_InvestmentIncomeMember_bc52d047-65a5-4449-b2f2-01593914fc5c" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_InvestmentIncomeMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_IncomeStatementLocationDomain_a6422a27-4a96-4696-bc76-641b2dc8ea20" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_InvestmentIncomeMember_bc52d047-65a5-4449-b2f2-01593914fc5c" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_TransactionTypeAxis_ceac72bc-5093-459b-948a-9ef6c527cfce" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_TransactionTypeAxis"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/hypercube-dimension" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DerivativeInstrumentsAndHedgingActivitiesDisclosuresTable_7a30f462-a115-4140-a51f-b72598b9127d" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_TransactionTypeAxis_ceac72bc-5093-459b-948a-9ef6c527cfce" xlink:type="arc" order="5"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_TransactionDomain_ceac72bc-5093-459b-948a-9ef6c527cfce_default" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_TransactionDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-default" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_TransactionTypeAxis_ceac72bc-5093-459b-948a-9ef6c527cfce" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_TransactionDomain_ceac72bc-5093-459b-948a-9ef6c527cfce_default" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_TransactionDomain_a7b6c394-0d4d-4ec3-bb8b-2a80b3101849" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_TransactionDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-domain" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_TransactionTypeAxis_ceac72bc-5093-459b-948a-9ef6c527cfce" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_TransactionDomain_a7b6c394-0d4d-4ec3-bb8b-2a80b3101849" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_FacilityClosingMember_8598490e-7bd0-4030-83e1-10ed5a14af31" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_FacilityClosingMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_TransactionDomain_a7b6c394-0d4d-4ec3-bb8b-2a80b3101849" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_FacilityClosingMember_8598490e-7bd0-4030-83e1-10ed5a14af31" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_DerivativeNotionalAmount_20c4a52a-066c-4137-ab01-bf18125b5a0b" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_DerivativeNotionalAmount"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DerivativeInstrumentsAndHedgingActivitiesDisclosuresLineItems_4fbdadfd-f1fc-4f2c-901e-158ac6c5a470" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_DerivativeNotionalAmount_20c4a52a-066c-4137-ab01-bf18125b5a0b" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_NumberOfInterestRateSwapsExpiredDuringThePeriod_761259f8-8bce-4889-878a-21fbbb36f2c3" xlink:href="afg-20240930.xsd#afg_NumberOfInterestRateSwapsExpiredDuringThePeriod"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DerivativeInstrumentsAndHedgingActivitiesDisclosuresLineItems_4fbdadfd-f1fc-4f2c-901e-158ac6c5a470" xlink:to="loc_afg_NumberOfInterestRateSwapsExpiredDuringThePeriod_761259f8-8bce-4889-878a-21fbbb36f2c3" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_ReclassificationFromAccumulatedOtherComprehensiveIncomeCurrentPeriodBeforeTax_89b32b81-6d04-4632-81b4-4ba14da91885" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_ReclassificationFromAccumulatedOtherComprehensiveIncomeCurrentPeriodBeforeTax"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DerivativeInstrumentsAndHedgingActivitiesDisclosuresLineItems_4fbdadfd-f1fc-4f2c-901e-158ac6c5a470" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_ReclassificationFromAccumulatedOtherComprehensiveIncomeCurrentPeriodBeforeTax_89b32b81-6d04-4632-81b4-4ba14da91885" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_CashFlowHedgeGainLossToBeReclassifiedWithinTwelveMonths_a6c8b186-9f02-41f6-9aa4-76256dd43441" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_CashFlowHedgeGainLossToBeReclassifiedWithinTwelveMonths"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DerivativeInstrumentsAndHedgingActivitiesDisclosuresLineItems_4fbdadfd-f1fc-4f2c-901e-158ac6c5a470" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_CashFlowHedgeGainLossToBeReclassifiedWithinTwelveMonths_a6c8b186-9f02-41f6-9aa4-76256dd43441" xlink:type="arc" order="3"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_DerivativeLiabilityNotSubjectToMasterNettingArrangementCollateralRightToReclaimCash_fd762de4-0adf-412b-8a62-d5ef382b2569" xlink:href="afg-20240930.xsd#afg_DerivativeLiabilityNotSubjectToMasterNettingArrangementCollateralRightToReclaimCash"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DerivativeInstrumentsAndHedgingActivitiesDisclosuresLineItems_4fbdadfd-f1fc-4f2c-901e-158ac6c5a470" xlink:to="loc_afg_DerivativeLiabilityNotSubjectToMasterNettingArrangementCollateralRightToReclaimCash_fd762de4-0adf-412b-8a62-d5ef382b2569" xlink:type="arc" order="4"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_DerivativeAssetNotSubjectToMasterNettingArrangementCollateralObligationToReturnCash_fc6ab15b-c45c-4a21-9d1f-df5508bc852f" xlink:href="afg-20240930.xsd#afg_DerivativeAssetNotSubjectToMasterNettingArrangementCollateralObligationToReturnCash"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DerivativeInstrumentsAndHedgingActivitiesDisclosuresLineItems_4fbdadfd-f1fc-4f2c-901e-158ac6c5a470" xlink:to="loc_afg_DerivativeAssetNotSubjectToMasterNettingArrangementCollateralObligationToReturnCash_fc6ab15b-c45c-4a21-9d1f-df5508bc852f" xlink:type="arc" order="5"/>
  </link:definitionLink>
  <link:roleRef roleURI="http://www.afginc.com/role/DerivativesDerivativesincludedintheBalanceSheetatfairvalueDetails" xlink:type="simple" xlink:href="afg-20240930.xsd#DerivativesDerivativesincludedintheBalanceSheetatfairvalueDetails"/>
  <link:definitionLink xlink:role="http://www.afginc.com/role/DerivativesDerivativesincludedintheBalanceSheetatfairvalueDetails" xlink:type="extended">
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_DerivativesFairValueLineItems_33b58a5c-7707-47f9-824e-9006696e5e40" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_DerivativesFairValueLineItems"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_FairValuesDerivativesBalanceSheetLocationByDerivativeContractTypeByHedgingDesignationTable_cfde5f24-b6de-4a68-82e7-1bf622054ec4" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_FairValuesDerivativesBalanceSheetLocationByDerivativeContractTypeByHedgingDesignationTable"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/all" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DerivativesFairValueLineItems_33b58a5c-7707-47f9-824e-9006696e5e40" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_FairValuesDerivativesBalanceSheetLocationByDerivativeContractTypeByHedgingDesignationTable_cfde5f24-b6de-4a68-82e7-1bf622054ec4" xlink:type="arc" order="1" xbrldt:closed="true" xbrldt:contextElement="segment"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_DerivativeInstrumentRiskAxis_15237ce8-cfcd-4b62-9a94-60f193699c97" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_DerivativeInstrumentRiskAxis"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/hypercube-dimension" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FairValuesDerivativesBalanceSheetLocationByDerivativeContractTypeByHedgingDesignationTable_cfde5f24-b6de-4a68-82e7-1bf622054ec4" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_DerivativeInstrumentRiskAxis_15237ce8-cfcd-4b62-9a94-60f193699c97" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_DerivativeContractTypeDomain_15237ce8-cfcd-4b62-9a94-60f193699c97_default" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_DerivativeContractTypeDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-default" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DerivativeInstrumentRiskAxis_15237ce8-cfcd-4b62-9a94-60f193699c97" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_DerivativeContractTypeDomain_15237ce8-cfcd-4b62-9a94-60f193699c97_default" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_DerivativeContractTypeDomain_a9ac4b89-9e14-4091-9b37-8a7b97d4219a" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_DerivativeContractTypeDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-domain" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DerivativeInstrumentRiskAxis_15237ce8-cfcd-4b62-9a94-60f193699c97" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_DerivativeContractTypeDomain_a9ac4b89-9e14-4091-9b37-8a7b97d4219a" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_InterestRateSwapMember_8bee6387-68ab-428c-84fd-d80948abda50" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_InterestRateSwapMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DerivativeContractTypeDomain_a9ac4b89-9e14-4091-9b37-8a7b97d4219a" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_InterestRateSwapMember_8bee6387-68ab-428c-84fd-d80948abda50" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_FixedMaturitySecuritiesWithEmbeddedDerivativesMember_c2c59691-d3bc-465b-ba5f-3e8d16856d42" xlink:href="afg-20240930.xsd#afg_FixedMaturitySecuritiesWithEmbeddedDerivativesMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DerivativeContractTypeDomain_a9ac4b89-9e14-4091-9b37-8a7b97d4219a" xlink:to="loc_afg_FixedMaturitySecuritiesWithEmbeddedDerivativesMember_c2c59691-d3bc-465b-ba5f-3e8d16856d42" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_TotalReturnSwapMember_1fd485ae-a8d4-48bc-84e2-14ee6f6df5d2" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_TotalReturnSwapMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DerivativeContractTypeDomain_a9ac4b89-9e14-4091-9b37-8a7b97d4219a" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_TotalReturnSwapMember_1fd485ae-a8d4-48bc-84e2-14ee6f6df5d2" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_HedgingDesignationAxis_cd4de83a-a5cf-4360-a7db-42936e99f1d0" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_HedgingDesignationAxis"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/hypercube-dimension" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FairValuesDerivativesBalanceSheetLocationByDerivativeContractTypeByHedgingDesignationTable_cfde5f24-b6de-4a68-82e7-1bf622054ec4" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_HedgingDesignationAxis_cd4de83a-a5cf-4360-a7db-42936e99f1d0" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_HedgingDesignationDomain_cd4de83a-a5cf-4360-a7db-42936e99f1d0_default" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_HedgingDesignationDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-default" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_HedgingDesignationAxis_cd4de83a-a5cf-4360-a7db-42936e99f1d0" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_HedgingDesignationDomain_cd4de83a-a5cf-4360-a7db-42936e99f1d0_default" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_HedgingDesignationDomain_f4df37d2-70aa-475e-a823-2ffb312d5cae" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_HedgingDesignationDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-domain" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_HedgingDesignationAxis_cd4de83a-a5cf-4360-a7db-42936e99f1d0" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_HedgingDesignationDomain_f4df37d2-70aa-475e-a823-2ffb312d5cae" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_DesignatedAsHedgingInstrumentMember_8cb2f6ab-12b4-41e9-8368-973640cf4b7e" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_DesignatedAsHedgingInstrumentMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_HedgingDesignationDomain_f4df37d2-70aa-475e-a823-2ffb312d5cae" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_DesignatedAsHedgingInstrumentMember_8cb2f6ab-12b4-41e9-8368-973640cf4b7e" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_NondesignatedMember_87e9a694-b655-409e-9b41-da10a4d69b1f" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_NondesignatedMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_HedgingDesignationDomain_f4df37d2-70aa-475e-a823-2ffb312d5cae" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_NondesignatedMember_87e9a694-b655-409e-9b41-da10a4d69b1f" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_DerivativeAssets_42481f56-614c-43f7-973a-a0ca18eb3636" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_DerivativeAssets"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DerivativesFairValueLineItems_33b58a5c-7707-47f9-824e-9006696e5e40" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_DerivativeAssets_42481f56-614c-43f7-973a-a0ca18eb3636" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_DerivativeLiabilities_cfeb9dfe-f723-4f8a-9782-1bdb279f8929" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_DerivativeLiabilities"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DerivativesFairValueLineItems_33b58a5c-7707-47f9-824e-9006696e5e40" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_DerivativeLiabilities_cfeb9dfe-f723-4f8a-9782-1bdb279f8929" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_DerivativeAssetStatementOfFinancialPositionExtensibleEnumeration_0aa422f1-8bd1-4436-bd89-1c620054e37d" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_DerivativeAssetStatementOfFinancialPositionExtensibleEnumeration"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DerivativesFairValueLineItems_33b58a5c-7707-47f9-824e-9006696e5e40" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_DerivativeAssetStatementOfFinancialPositionExtensibleEnumeration_0aa422f1-8bd1-4436-bd89-1c620054e37d" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_DerivativeLiabilityStatementOfFinancialPositionExtensibleEnumeration_92519662-c30b-4d07-a922-ba056ea4ee73" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_DerivativeLiabilityStatementOfFinancialPositionExtensibleEnumeration"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DerivativesFairValueLineItems_33b58a5c-7707-47f9-824e-9006696e5e40" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_DerivativeLiabilityStatementOfFinancialPositionExtensibleEnumeration_92519662-c30b-4d07-a922-ba056ea4ee73" xlink:type="arc" order="3"/>
  </link:definitionLink>
  <link:roleRef roleURI="http://www.afginc.com/role/DerivativesGainslossesincludedintheStatementofEarningsforchangesinthefairvalueofderivativesDetails" xlink:type="simple" xlink:href="afg-20240930.xsd#DerivativesGainslossesincludedintheStatementofEarningsforchangesinthefairvalueofderivativesDetails"/>
  <link:definitionLink xlink:role="http://www.afginc.com/role/DerivativesGainslossesincludedintheStatementofEarningsforchangesinthefairvalueofderivativesDetails" xlink:type="extended">
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_DerivativeInstrumentsAndHedgingActivitiesDisclosuresLineItems_03775dac-b7ce-4de4-b08e-42b8c11e2726" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_DerivativeInstrumentsAndHedgingActivitiesDisclosuresLineItems"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_DerivativeInstrumentsAndHedgingActivitiesDisclosuresTable_e4bb93cf-3988-43ec-96d4-62db26ff24bc" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_DerivativeInstrumentsAndHedgingActivitiesDisclosuresTable"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/all" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DerivativeInstrumentsAndHedgingActivitiesDisclosuresLineItems_03775dac-b7ce-4de4-b08e-42b8c11e2726" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_DerivativeInstrumentsAndHedgingActivitiesDisclosuresTable_e4bb93cf-3988-43ec-96d4-62db26ff24bc" xlink:type="arc" order="1" xbrldt:closed="true" xbrldt:contextElement="segment"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_HedgingDesignationAxis_5dfa4944-29aa-4899-a0c1-d31558a32b71" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_HedgingDesignationAxis"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/hypercube-dimension" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DerivativeInstrumentsAndHedgingActivitiesDisclosuresTable_e4bb93cf-3988-43ec-96d4-62db26ff24bc" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_HedgingDesignationAxis_5dfa4944-29aa-4899-a0c1-d31558a32b71" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_HedgingDesignationDomain_5dfa4944-29aa-4899-a0c1-d31558a32b71_default" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_HedgingDesignationDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-default" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_HedgingDesignationAxis_5dfa4944-29aa-4899-a0c1-d31558a32b71" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_HedgingDesignationDomain_5dfa4944-29aa-4899-a0c1-d31558a32b71_default" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_HedgingDesignationDomain_940ecb64-ebe9-4841-9311-e540715dba63" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_HedgingDesignationDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-domain" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_HedgingDesignationAxis_5dfa4944-29aa-4899-a0c1-d31558a32b71" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_HedgingDesignationDomain_940ecb64-ebe9-4841-9311-e540715dba63" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_DesignatedAsHedgingInstrumentMember_a01874f9-940c-4ac0-8b98-e98b8707d608" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_DesignatedAsHedgingInstrumentMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_HedgingDesignationDomain_940ecb64-ebe9-4841-9311-e540715dba63" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_DesignatedAsHedgingInstrumentMember_a01874f9-940c-4ac0-8b98-e98b8707d608" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_DerivativeInstrumentRiskAxis_ff912964-ad69-4863-b908-f0c3e9f2387a" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_DerivativeInstrumentRiskAxis"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/hypercube-dimension" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DerivativeInstrumentsAndHedgingActivitiesDisclosuresTable_e4bb93cf-3988-43ec-96d4-62db26ff24bc" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_DerivativeInstrumentRiskAxis_ff912964-ad69-4863-b908-f0c3e9f2387a" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_DerivativeContractTypeDomain_ff912964-ad69-4863-b908-f0c3e9f2387a_default" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_DerivativeContractTypeDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-default" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DerivativeInstrumentRiskAxis_ff912964-ad69-4863-b908-f0c3e9f2387a" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_DerivativeContractTypeDomain_ff912964-ad69-4863-b908-f0c3e9f2387a_default" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_DerivativeContractTypeDomain_7e8a8a15-bdbd-44ff-8069-0d603b8af9a3" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_DerivativeContractTypeDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-domain" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DerivativeInstrumentRiskAxis_ff912964-ad69-4863-b908-f0c3e9f2387a" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_DerivativeContractTypeDomain_7e8a8a15-bdbd-44ff-8069-0d603b8af9a3" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_InterestRateSwapMember_bfac5a8a-a32a-45ff-8705-ed71937092bb" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_InterestRateSwapMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DerivativeContractTypeDomain_7e8a8a15-bdbd-44ff-8069-0d603b8af9a3" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_InterestRateSwapMember_bfac5a8a-a32a-45ff-8705-ed71937092bb" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_FixedMaturitySecuritiesWithEmbeddedDerivativesMember_3583ca26-1d97-4c98-8eea-0de424426d06" xlink:href="afg-20240930.xsd#afg_FixedMaturitySecuritiesWithEmbeddedDerivativesMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DerivativeContractTypeDomain_7e8a8a15-bdbd-44ff-8069-0d603b8af9a3" xlink:to="loc_afg_FixedMaturitySecuritiesWithEmbeddedDerivativesMember_3583ca26-1d97-4c98-8eea-0de424426d06" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_TotalReturnSwapMember_0b460941-938b-40c6-a964-b8857b6cd548" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_TotalReturnSwapMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DerivativeContractTypeDomain_7e8a8a15-bdbd-44ff-8069-0d603b8af9a3" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_TotalReturnSwapMember_0b460941-938b-40c6-a964-b8857b6cd548" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_IncomeStatementLocationAxis_3f027d55-1b4e-4584-94c8-24b7433007f9" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_IncomeStatementLocationAxis"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/hypercube-dimension" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DerivativeInstrumentsAndHedgingActivitiesDisclosuresTable_e4bb93cf-3988-43ec-96d4-62db26ff24bc" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_IncomeStatementLocationAxis_3f027d55-1b4e-4584-94c8-24b7433007f9" xlink:type="arc" order="3"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_IncomeStatementLocationDomain_3f027d55-1b4e-4584-94c8-24b7433007f9_default" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_IncomeStatementLocationDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-default" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_IncomeStatementLocationAxis_3f027d55-1b4e-4584-94c8-24b7433007f9" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_IncomeStatementLocationDomain_3f027d55-1b4e-4584-94c8-24b7433007f9_default" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_IncomeStatementLocationDomain_40c952e1-a6cd-4e17-a83c-e8eb2edd15dc" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_IncomeStatementLocationDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-domain" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_IncomeStatementLocationAxis_3f027d55-1b4e-4584-94c8-24b7433007f9" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_IncomeStatementLocationDomain_40c952e1-a6cd-4e17-a83c-e8eb2edd15dc" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_RealizedGainsLossesOnSecuritiesMember_5851d133-bf1e-4d98-8f43-3fffb899a949" xlink:href="afg-20240930.xsd#afg_RealizedGainsLossesOnSecuritiesMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_IncomeStatementLocationDomain_40c952e1-a6cd-4e17-a83c-e8eb2edd15dc" xlink:to="loc_afg_RealizedGainsLossesOnSecuritiesMember_5851d133-bf1e-4d98-8f43-3fffb899a949" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_InvestmentIncomeMember_800fe9fb-4eb8-4fd4-b6fc-236cfc92aff2" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_InvestmentIncomeMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_IncomeStatementLocationDomain_40c952e1-a6cd-4e17-a83c-e8eb2edd15dc" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_InvestmentIncomeMember_800fe9fb-4eb8-4fd4-b6fc-236cfc92aff2" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_OtherExpenseMember_01a39447-09c3-4e4c-85c0-54ebf797dfb8" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_OtherExpenseMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_IncomeStatementLocationDomain_40c952e1-a6cd-4e17-a83c-e8eb2edd15dc" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_OtherExpenseMember_01a39447-09c3-4e4c-85c0-54ebf797dfb8" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_ReclassificationFromAccumulatedOtherComprehensiveIncomeCurrentPeriodBeforeTax_c76f8dac-7d59-4e63-8695-d30f481b8030" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_ReclassificationFromAccumulatedOtherComprehensiveIncomeCurrentPeriodBeforeTax"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DerivativeInstrumentsAndHedgingActivitiesDisclosuresLineItems_03775dac-b7ce-4de4-b08e-42b8c11e2726" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_ReclassificationFromAccumulatedOtherComprehensiveIncomeCurrentPeriodBeforeTax_c76f8dac-7d59-4e63-8695-d30f481b8030" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_DerivativeInstrumentsNotDesignatedAsHedgingInstrumentsGainLossNet_b976c29d-a0a5-417f-b280-9aee41a5613e" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_DerivativeInstrumentsNotDesignatedAsHedgingInstrumentsGainLossNet"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DerivativeInstrumentsAndHedgingActivitiesDisclosuresLineItems_03775dac-b7ce-4de4-b08e-42b8c11e2726" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_DerivativeInstrumentsNotDesignatedAsHedgingInstrumentsGainLossNet_b976c29d-a0a5-417f-b280-9aee41a5613e" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_GainLossOnDerivativeInstrumentsNetPretax_a857d07b-7cdd-428d-92b4-0f166e0de3f9" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_GainLossOnDerivativeInstrumentsNetPretax"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DerivativeInstrumentsAndHedgingActivitiesDisclosuresLineItems_03775dac-b7ce-4de4-b08e-42b8c11e2726" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_GainLossOnDerivativeInstrumentsNetPretax_a857d07b-7cdd-428d-92b4-0f166e0de3f9" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
  </link:definitionLink>
  <link:roleRef roleURI="http://www.afginc.com/role/ManagedInvestmentEntitiesNarrativeDetails" xlink:type="simple" xlink:href="afg-20240930.xsd#ManagedInvestmentEntitiesNarrativeDetails"/>
  <link:definitionLink xlink:role="http://www.afginc.com/role/ManagedInvestmentEntitiesNarrativeDetails" xlink:type="extended">
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_VariableInterestEntityLineItems_758eb1e6-c104-4351-b15e-7640f9cdfcab" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_VariableInterestEntityLineItems"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfVariableInterestEntitiesTable_6e1412d4-ea8a-4b0d-8298-a70d30ea9b4d" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_ScheduleOfVariableInterestEntitiesTable"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/all" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_VariableInterestEntityLineItems_758eb1e6-c104-4351-b15e-7640f9cdfcab" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfVariableInterestEntitiesTable_6e1412d4-ea8a-4b0d-8298-a70d30ea9b4d" xlink:type="arc" order="1" xbrldt:closed="true" xbrldt:contextElement="segment"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesAxis_e171269e-e7dc-4a26-985f-1028ad380a28" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/srt/2024/elts/srt-2024.xsd#srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesAxis"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/hypercube-dimension" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfVariableInterestEntitiesTable_6e1412d4-ea8a-4b0d-8298-a70d30ea9b4d" xlink:to="loc_srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesAxis_e171269e-e7dc-4a26-985f-1028ad380a28" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesDomain_e171269e-e7dc-4a26-985f-1028ad380a28_default" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/srt/2024/elts/srt-2024.xsd#srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-default" xlink:from="loc_srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesAxis_e171269e-e7dc-4a26-985f-1028ad380a28" xlink:to="loc_srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesDomain_e171269e-e7dc-4a26-985f-1028ad380a28_default" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesDomain_927eb09a-32ab-4d61-a5ff-27ee58dbd37a" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/srt/2024/elts/srt-2024.xsd#srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-domain" xlink:from="loc_srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesAxis_e171269e-e7dc-4a26-985f-1028ad380a28" xlink:to="loc_srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesDomain_927eb09a-32ab-4d61-a5ff-27ee58dbd37a" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_VariableInterestEntityPrimaryBeneficiaryMember_6616485c-6212-42b1-a518-c9c0b00a9974" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_VariableInterestEntityPrimaryBeneficiaryMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesDomain_927eb09a-32ab-4d61-a5ff-27ee58dbd37a" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_VariableInterestEntityPrimaryBeneficiaryMember_6616485c-6212-42b1-a518-c9c0b00a9974" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_NewCollateralizedLoanObligationTemporaryWarehousingEntitiesMember_72a5ec03-4009-4e91-90f2-dceb87021990" xlink:href="afg-20240930.xsd#afg_NewCollateralizedLoanObligationTemporaryWarehousingEntitiesMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesDomain_927eb09a-32ab-4d61-a5ff-27ee58dbd37a" xlink:to="loc_afg_NewCollateralizedLoanObligationTemporaryWarehousingEntitiesMember_72a5ec03-4009-4e91-90f2-dceb87021990" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_NewCollateralizedLoanObligationEntitiesMember_ae4e8ec9-36e0-4c37-b843-2cd1716a5466" xlink:href="afg-20240930.xsd#afg_NewCollateralizedLoanObligationEntitiesMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesDomain_927eb09a-32ab-4d61-a5ff-27ee58dbd37a" xlink:to="loc_afg_NewCollateralizedLoanObligationEntitiesMember_ae4e8ec9-36e0-4c37-b843-2cd1716a5466" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_DebtInstrumentAxis_d9b3286d-f79a-4cda-bb98-57dcc212ccfa" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_DebtInstrumentAxis"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/hypercube-dimension" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfVariableInterestEntitiesTable_6e1412d4-ea8a-4b0d-8298-a70d30ea9b4d" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_DebtInstrumentAxis_d9b3286d-f79a-4cda-bb98-57dcc212ccfa" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_DebtInstrumentNameDomain_d9b3286d-f79a-4cda-bb98-57dcc212ccfa_default" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_DebtInstrumentNameDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-default" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DebtInstrumentAxis_d9b3286d-f79a-4cda-bb98-57dcc212ccfa" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_DebtInstrumentNameDomain_d9b3286d-f79a-4cda-bb98-57dcc212ccfa_default" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_DebtInstrumentNameDomain_459d126e-c6ad-44e1-a96b-c4586460aa5f" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_DebtInstrumentNameDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-domain" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DebtInstrumentAxis_d9b3286d-f79a-4cda-bb98-57dcc212ccfa" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_DebtInstrumentNameDomain_459d126e-c6ad-44e1-a96b-c4586460aa5f" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_SubordinatedDebtObligationsMember_b194b845-9751-404b-a765-201892df71fd" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_SubordinatedDebtObligationsMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DebtInstrumentNameDomain_459d126e-c6ad-44e1-a96b-c4586460aa5f" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_SubordinatedDebtObligationsMember_b194b845-9751-404b-a765-201892df71fd" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_ManagedbyThirdPartiesMember_123aab46-8ac6-4e78-a374-a5e2b6bf0a02" xlink:href="afg-20240930.xsd#afg_ManagedbyThirdPartiesMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DebtInstrumentNameDomain_459d126e-c6ad-44e1-a96b-c4586460aa5f" xlink:to="loc_afg_ManagedbyThirdPartiesMember_123aab46-8ac6-4e78-a374-a5e2b6bf0a02" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_FinancialInstrumentAxis_51fb1198-fe68-4e53-9b6d-6e02f7d4fc0b" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_FinancialInstrumentAxis"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/hypercube-dimension" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfVariableInterestEntitiesTable_6e1412d4-ea8a-4b0d-8298-a70d30ea9b4d" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_FinancialInstrumentAxis_51fb1198-fe68-4e53-9b6d-6e02f7d4fc0b" xlink:type="arc" order="3"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_TransfersAndServicingOfFinancialInstrumentsTypesOfFinancialInstrumentsDomain_51fb1198-fe68-4e53-9b6d-6e02f7d4fc0b_default" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_TransfersAndServicingOfFinancialInstrumentsTypesOfFinancialInstrumentsDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-default" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FinancialInstrumentAxis_51fb1198-fe68-4e53-9b6d-6e02f7d4fc0b" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_TransfersAndServicingOfFinancialInstrumentsTypesOfFinancialInstrumentsDomain_51fb1198-fe68-4e53-9b6d-6e02f7d4fc0b_default" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_TransfersAndServicingOfFinancialInstrumentsTypesOfFinancialInstrumentsDomain_2fd291c5-3326-4f13-af63-8282bf9f595f" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_TransfersAndServicingOfFinancialInstrumentsTypesOfFinancialInstrumentsDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-domain" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FinancialInstrumentAxis_51fb1198-fe68-4e53-9b6d-6e02f7d4fc0b" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_TransfersAndServicingOfFinancialInstrumentsTypesOfFinancialInstrumentsDomain_2fd291c5-3326-4f13-af63-8282bf9f595f" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_CollateralizedLoanObligationsMember_ed8ddc17-f14a-4510-990f-188ee0515cea" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_CollateralizedLoanObligationsMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_TransfersAndServicingOfFinancialInstrumentsTypesOfFinancialInstrumentsDomain_2fd291c5-3326-4f13-af63-8282bf9f595f" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_CollateralizedLoanObligationsMember_ed8ddc17-f14a-4510-990f-188ee0515cea" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_PercentageOfInvestmentOfMostSubordinateDebtTrancheOfVariableInterestEntityMinimum_451a9245-75d8-4fe5-b8b8-ecbe2203dd16" xlink:href="afg-20240930.xsd#afg_PercentageOfInvestmentOfMostSubordinateDebtTrancheOfVariableInterestEntityMinimum"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_VariableInterestEntityLineItems_758eb1e6-c104-4351-b15e-7640f9cdfcab" xlink:to="loc_afg_PercentageOfInvestmentOfMostSubordinateDebtTrancheOfVariableInterestEntityMinimum_451a9245-75d8-4fe5-b8b8-ecbe2203dd16" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_PercentageOfInvestmentOfMostSubordinateDebtTrancheOfVariableInterestEntityMaximum_487d914f-7f81-41d3-80ac-4481de7a4c4a" xlink:href="afg-20240930.xsd#afg_PercentageOfInvestmentOfMostSubordinateDebtTrancheOfVariableInterestEntityMaximum"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_VariableInterestEntityLineItems_758eb1e6-c104-4351-b15e-7640f9cdfcab" xlink:to="loc_afg_PercentageOfInvestmentOfMostSubordinateDebtTrancheOfVariableInterestEntityMaximum_487d914f-7f81-41d3-80ac-4481de7a4c4a" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_NumberOfCollateralizedLoanObligationEntities_d542965a-94f0-4967-a986-051ea18b1160" xlink:href="afg-20240930.xsd#afg_NumberOfCollateralizedLoanObligationEntities"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_VariableInterestEntityLineItems_758eb1e6-c104-4351-b15e-7640f9cdfcab" xlink:to="loc_afg_NumberOfCollateralizedLoanObligationEntities_d542965a-94f0-4967-a986-051ea18b1160" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_VariableInterestEntityEntityMaximumLossExposureAmount_6fbfba6c-cb85-4ad4-b28a-95341aebaf88" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_VariableInterestEntityEntityMaximumLossExposureAmount"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_VariableInterestEntityLineItems_758eb1e6-c104-4351-b15e-7640f9cdfcab" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_VariableInterestEntityEntityMaximumLossExposureAmount_6fbfba6c-cb85-4ad4-b28a-95341aebaf88" xlink:type="arc" order="3"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_NumberOfCollateralizedLoanObligationEntitiesFormedDuringThePeriod_9c1bc1e9-f00e-486a-a41c-cb8701f4989d" xlink:href="afg-20240930.xsd#afg_NumberOfCollateralizedLoanObligationEntitiesFormedDuringThePeriod"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_VariableInterestEntityLineItems_758eb1e6-c104-4351-b15e-7640f9cdfcab" xlink:to="loc_afg_NumberOfCollateralizedLoanObligationEntitiesFormedDuringThePeriod_9c1bc1e9-f00e-486a-a41c-cb8701f4989d" xlink:type="arc" order="4"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_FaceValueOfLiabilitiesIssuedByManagedInvestmentEntitiesOnIssuanceDate_a10610ae-ca35-41fe-aed7-b4f6e544c3b1" xlink:href="afg-20240930.xsd#afg_FaceValueOfLiabilitiesIssuedByManagedInvestmentEntitiesOnIssuanceDate"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_VariableInterestEntityLineItems_758eb1e6-c104-4351-b15e-7640f9cdfcab" xlink:to="loc_afg_FaceValueOfLiabilitiesIssuedByManagedInvestmentEntitiesOnIssuanceDate_a10610ae-ca35-41fe-aed7-b4f6e544c3b1" xlink:type="arc" order="5"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_FaceAmountOfManagedInvestmentEntitiesLiabilitiesPurchasedAtIssuanceDate_9d5b5438-0229-4f3e-8772-9608cef525a3" xlink:href="afg-20240930.xsd#afg_FaceAmountOfManagedInvestmentEntitiesLiabilitiesPurchasedAtIssuanceDate"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_VariableInterestEntityLineItems_758eb1e6-c104-4351-b15e-7640f9cdfcab" xlink:to="loc_afg_FaceAmountOfManagedInvestmentEntitiesLiabilitiesPurchasedAtIssuanceDate_9d5b5438-0229-4f3e-8772-9608cef525a3" xlink:type="arc" order="6"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_DifferenceBetweenAggregateUnpaidPrincipalBalanceAndFairValueOfVariableInterestEntityInvestments_1d175972-eeef-4ce4-bea0-61cea7e88497" xlink:href="afg-20240930.xsd#afg_DifferenceBetweenAggregateUnpaidPrincipalBalanceAndFairValueOfVariableInterestEntityInvestments"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_VariableInterestEntityLineItems_758eb1e6-c104-4351-b15e-7640f9cdfcab" xlink:to="loc_afg_DifferenceBetweenAggregateUnpaidPrincipalBalanceAndFairValueOfVariableInterestEntityInvestments_1d175972-eeef-4ce4-bea0-61cea7e88497" xlink:type="arc" order="7"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_DifferenceBetweenAggregateUnpaidPrincipalBalanceAndFairValueOfVariableInterestEntityDebt_b2dbdefe-767e-4ff9-8c34-7cf2877a8ac6" xlink:href="afg-20240930.xsd#afg_DifferenceBetweenAggregateUnpaidPrincipalBalanceAndFairValueOfVariableInterestEntityDebt"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_VariableInterestEntityLineItems_758eb1e6-c104-4351-b15e-7640f9cdfcab" xlink:to="loc_afg_DifferenceBetweenAggregateUnpaidPrincipalBalanceAndFairValueOfVariableInterestEntityDebt_b2dbdefe-767e-4ff9-8c34-7cf2877a8ac6" xlink:type="arc" order="8"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_CarryingAmountOfVariableInterestEntityLoansInDefault_540172fb-17d4-4a56-876c-0bc5a1684718" xlink:href="afg-20240930.xsd#afg_CarryingAmountOfVariableInterestEntityLoansInDefault"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_VariableInterestEntityLineItems_758eb1e6-c104-4351-b15e-7640f9cdfcab" xlink:to="loc_afg_CarryingAmountOfVariableInterestEntityLoansInDefault_540172fb-17d4-4a56-876c-0bc5a1684718" xlink:type="arc" order="9"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_Aggregateunpaidprincipalbalanceofvariableinterestentityloansindefault_13b3f3f5-6327-4e37-bf5f-4939deff814f" xlink:href="afg-20240930.xsd#afg_Aggregateunpaidprincipalbalanceofvariableinterestentityloansindefault"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_VariableInterestEntityLineItems_758eb1e6-c104-4351-b15e-7640f9cdfcab" xlink:to="loc_afg_Aggregateunpaidprincipalbalanceofvariableinterestentityloansindefault_13b3f3f5-6327-4e37-bf5f-4939deff814f" xlink:type="arc" order="10"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtSecurities_93c1242c-c7f6-46ae-b5fe-45a6f4e2ad2d" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtSecurities"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_VariableInterestEntityLineItems_758eb1e6-c104-4351-b15e-7640f9cdfcab" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtSecurities_93c1242c-c7f6-46ae-b5fe-45a6f4e2ad2d" xlink:type="arc" order="11"/>
  </link:definitionLink>
  <link:roleRef roleURI="http://www.afginc.com/role/ManagedInvestmentEntitiesProgressionofinvestmentinCLOtranchesDetails" xlink:type="simple" xlink:href="afg-20240930.xsd#ManagedInvestmentEntitiesProgressionofinvestmentinCLOtranchesDetails"/>
  <link:definitionLink xlink:role="http://www.afginc.com/role/ManagedInvestmentEntitiesProgressionofinvestmentinCLOtranchesDetails" xlink:type="extended">
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_VariableInterestEntityLineItems_6c391406-1417-4f39-b82c-1f61221c8fea" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_VariableInterestEntityLineItems"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfVariableInterestEntitiesTable_5101ecb4-476f-4391-82ef-0aac4fc6aa5e" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_ScheduleOfVariableInterestEntitiesTable"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/all" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_VariableInterestEntityLineItems_6c391406-1417-4f39-b82c-1f61221c8fea" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfVariableInterestEntitiesTable_5101ecb4-476f-4391-82ef-0aac4fc6aa5e" xlink:type="arc" order="1" xbrldt:closed="true" xbrldt:contextElement="segment"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesAxis_85a87bcc-7888-4ab8-982e-12888c538a9d" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/srt/2024/elts/srt-2024.xsd#srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesAxis"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/hypercube-dimension" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfVariableInterestEntitiesTable_5101ecb4-476f-4391-82ef-0aac4fc6aa5e" xlink:to="loc_srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesAxis_85a87bcc-7888-4ab8-982e-12888c538a9d" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesDomain_85a87bcc-7888-4ab8-982e-12888c538a9d_default" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/srt/2024/elts/srt-2024.xsd#srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-default" xlink:from="loc_srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesAxis_85a87bcc-7888-4ab8-982e-12888c538a9d" xlink:to="loc_srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesDomain_85a87bcc-7888-4ab8-982e-12888c538a9d_default" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesDomain_791facb7-9c80-4318-b1fc-15e9cd7c7935" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/srt/2024/elts/srt-2024.xsd#srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-domain" xlink:from="loc_srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesAxis_85a87bcc-7888-4ab8-982e-12888c538a9d" xlink:to="loc_srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesDomain_791facb7-9c80-4318-b1fc-15e9cd7c7935" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_VariableInterestEntityPrimaryBeneficiaryMember_9bd75912-f38a-4572-828c-94cd29cc054f" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_VariableInterestEntityPrimaryBeneficiaryMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesDomain_791facb7-9c80-4318-b1fc-15e9cd7c7935" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_VariableInterestEntityPrimaryBeneficiaryMember_9bd75912-f38a-4572-828c-94cd29cc054f" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_VariableInterestEntityOwnershipRollForward_4b4f5429-c6a3-4b97-9137-b062d00619c3" xlink:href="afg-20240930.xsd#afg_VariableInterestEntityOwnershipRollForward"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_VariableInterestEntityLineItems_6c391406-1417-4f39-b82c-1f61221c8fea" xlink:to="loc_afg_VariableInterestEntityOwnershipRollForward_4b4f5429-c6a3-4b97-9137-b062d00619c3" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_VariableInterestEntityPrimaryBeneficiaryMaximumLossExposureAmount_49cba48e-292b-4102-bc64-c6aa45c77519" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_VariableInterestEntityPrimaryBeneficiaryMaximumLossExposureAmount"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_afg_VariableInterestEntityOwnershipRollForward_4b4f5429-c6a3-4b97-9137-b062d00619c3" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_VariableInterestEntityPrimaryBeneficiaryMaximumLossExposureAmount_49cba48e-292b-4102-bc64-c6aa45c77519" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_AmountOfManagedInvestmentEntitiesLiabilitiesPurchasedDuringThePeriod_c722d2f8-be90-4216-bd90-0f1d83feadba" xlink:href="afg-20240930.xsd#afg_AmountOfManagedInvestmentEntitiesLiabilitiesPurchasedDuringThePeriod"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_afg_VariableInterestEntityOwnershipRollForward_4b4f5429-c6a3-4b97-9137-b062d00619c3" xlink:to="loc_afg_AmountOfManagedInvestmentEntitiesLiabilitiesPurchasedDuringThePeriod_c722d2f8-be90-4216-bd90-0f1d83feadba" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_ProceedsReceivedRelatedToSalesOfManagedInvestmentEntitiesLiabilities_a99dbe52-03f4-4372-a596-b65e7396c9b6" xlink:href="afg-20240930.xsd#afg_ProceedsReceivedRelatedToSalesOfManagedInvestmentEntitiesLiabilities"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_afg_VariableInterestEntityOwnershipRollForward_4b4f5429-c6a3-4b97-9137-b062d00619c3" xlink:to="loc_afg_ProceedsReceivedRelatedToSalesOfManagedInvestmentEntitiesLiabilities_a99dbe52-03f4-4372-a596-b65e7396c9b6" xlink:type="arc" order="3"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_ProceedsReceivedFromDistributionsOfManagedInvestmentEntitiesLiabilities_f8503482-2de8-4832-92bb-a04bf4b51ba8" xlink:href="afg-20240930.xsd#afg_ProceedsReceivedFromDistributionsOfManagedInvestmentEntitiesLiabilities"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_afg_VariableInterestEntityOwnershipRollForward_4b4f5429-c6a3-4b97-9137-b062d00619c3" xlink:to="loc_afg_ProceedsReceivedFromDistributionsOfManagedInvestmentEntitiesLiabilities_f8503482-2de8-4832-92bb-a04bf4b51ba8" xlink:type="arc" order="4"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_ChangeInFairValueOfOwnershipOfManagedInvestmentEntitiesLiabilities_2bf43b61-53d1-46ce-9470-2daa07efeff9" xlink:href="afg-20240930.xsd#afg_ChangeInFairValueOfOwnershipOfManagedInvestmentEntitiesLiabilities"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_afg_VariableInterestEntityOwnershipRollForward_4b4f5429-c6a3-4b97-9137-b062d00619c3" xlink:to="loc_afg_ChangeInFairValueOfOwnershipOfManagedInvestmentEntitiesLiabilities_2bf43b61-53d1-46ce-9470-2daa07efeff9" xlink:type="arc" order="5"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_ChangeInAccruedInterestOfManagedInvestmentEntitiesLiabilitiesOwned_faddb9d4-4da6-4809-b176-7295e31c259b" xlink:href="afg-20240930.xsd#afg_ChangeInAccruedInterestOfManagedInvestmentEntitiesLiabilitiesOwned"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_afg_VariableInterestEntityOwnershipRollForward_4b4f5429-c6a3-4b97-9137-b062d00619c3" xlink:to="loc_afg_ChangeInAccruedInterestOfManagedInvestmentEntitiesLiabilitiesOwned_faddb9d4-4da6-4809-b176-7295e31c259b" xlink:type="arc" order="6"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_VariableInterestEntityPrimaryBeneficiaryMaximumLossExposureAmount_f8a32dc8-e69f-4b6d-bf51-c0dd7b855d78" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_VariableInterestEntityPrimaryBeneficiaryMaximumLossExposureAmount"/>
  </link:definitionLink>
  <link:roleRef roleURI="http://www.afginc.com/role/ManagedInvestmentEntitiesSelectedfinancialinformationrelatedtoCLOsDetails" xlink:type="simple" xlink:href="afg-20240930.xsd#ManagedInvestmentEntitiesSelectedfinancialinformationrelatedtoCLOsDetails"/>
  <link:definitionLink xlink:role="http://www.afginc.com/role/ManagedInvestmentEntitiesSelectedfinancialinformationrelatedtoCLOsDetails" xlink:type="extended">
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_VariableInterestEntityLineItems_63f0001c-daa6-43af-a33c-13b5a1437baf" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_VariableInterestEntityLineItems"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfVariableInterestEntitiesTable_f916b031-f15a-40ba-9f76-907a5a6c5c79" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_ScheduleOfVariableInterestEntitiesTable"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/all" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_VariableInterestEntityLineItems_63f0001c-daa6-43af-a33c-13b5a1437baf" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfVariableInterestEntitiesTable_f916b031-f15a-40ba-9f76-907a5a6c5c79" xlink:type="arc" order="1" xbrldt:closed="true" xbrldt:contextElement="segment"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesAxis_85757f3d-0cca-4d7b-b24f-5346a9c4e606" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/srt/2024/elts/srt-2024.xsd#srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesAxis"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/hypercube-dimension" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfVariableInterestEntitiesTable_f916b031-f15a-40ba-9f76-907a5a6c5c79" xlink:to="loc_srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesAxis_85757f3d-0cca-4d7b-b24f-5346a9c4e606" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesDomain_85757f3d-0cca-4d7b-b24f-5346a9c4e606_default" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/srt/2024/elts/srt-2024.xsd#srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-default" xlink:from="loc_srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesAxis_85757f3d-0cca-4d7b-b24f-5346a9c4e606" xlink:to="loc_srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesDomain_85757f3d-0cca-4d7b-b24f-5346a9c4e606_default" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesDomain_e2d86955-22b4-463b-983b-672902d09275" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/srt/2024/elts/srt-2024.xsd#srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-domain" xlink:from="loc_srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesAxis_85757f3d-0cca-4d7b-b24f-5346a9c4e606" xlink:to="loc_srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesDomain_e2d86955-22b4-463b-983b-672902d09275" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_VariableInterestEntityPrimaryBeneficiaryMember_f4014d5f-1030-452c-bbad-8d5189599f63" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_VariableInterestEntityPrimaryBeneficiaryMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesDomain_e2d86955-22b4-463b-983b-672902d09275" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_VariableInterestEntityPrimaryBeneficiaryMember_f4014d5f-1030-452c-bbad-8d5189599f63" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_FinancialInformationRelatedToCollateralizedLoanObligationsAbstract_f17caeb4-7212-41be-9b64-ab6b68d66579" xlink:href="afg-20240930.xsd#afg_FinancialInformationRelatedToCollateralizedLoanObligationsAbstract"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_VariableInterestEntityLineItems_63f0001c-daa6-43af-a33c-13b5a1437baf" xlink:to="loc_afg_FinancialInformationRelatedToCollateralizedLoanObligationsAbstract_f17caeb4-7212-41be-9b64-ab6b68d66579" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_GainsLossesOnChangeInFairValueOfAssetsLiabilitiesOfCollateralizedLoanObligationsAbstract_6f4f508c-e316-4cb7-ba9d-de22f0f81a46" xlink:href="afg-20240930.xsd#afg_GainsLossesOnChangeInFairValueOfAssetsLiabilitiesOfCollateralizedLoanObligationsAbstract"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_afg_FinancialInformationRelatedToCollateralizedLoanObligationsAbstract_f17caeb4-7212-41be-9b64-ab6b68d66579" xlink:to="loc_afg_GainsLossesOnChangeInFairValueOfAssetsLiabilitiesOfCollateralizedLoanObligationsAbstract_6f4f508c-e316-4cb7-ba9d-de22f0f81a46" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_GainLossOnChangeInFairValueOfAssetsOfVariableInterestEntities_f9fca8be-7855-4609-955b-30a85a843afe" xlink:href="afg-20240930.xsd#afg_GainLossOnChangeInFairValueOfAssetsOfVariableInterestEntities"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_afg_GainsLossesOnChangeInFairValueOfAssetsLiabilitiesOfCollateralizedLoanObligationsAbstract_6f4f508c-e316-4cb7-ba9d-de22f0f81a46" xlink:to="loc_afg_GainLossOnChangeInFairValueOfAssetsOfVariableInterestEntities_f9fca8be-7855-4609-955b-30a85a843afe" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_GainLossOnChangeInFairValueOfLiabilitiesOfVariableInterestEntities_b0eb718c-cbba-408a-abf8-baf1e4c4ced2" xlink:href="afg-20240930.xsd#afg_GainLossOnChangeInFairValueOfLiabilitiesOfVariableInterestEntities"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_afg_GainsLossesOnChangeInFairValueOfAssetsLiabilitiesOfCollateralizedLoanObligationsAbstract_6f4f508c-e316-4cb7-ba9d-de22f0f81a46" xlink:to="loc_afg_GainLossOnChangeInFairValueOfLiabilitiesOfVariableInterestEntities_b0eb718c-cbba-408a-abf8-baf1e4c4ced2" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_ManagementFeesPaidByVariableInterestEntities_40ca5401-dd95-4fef-8c65-4a0df5df8c4a" xlink:href="afg-20240930.xsd#afg_ManagementFeesPaidByVariableInterestEntities"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_afg_FinancialInformationRelatedToCollateralizedLoanObligationsAbstract_f17caeb4-7212-41be-9b64-ab6b68d66579" xlink:to="loc_afg_ManagementFeesPaidByVariableInterestEntities_40ca5401-dd95-4fef-8c65-4a0df5df8c4a" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_EarningsLossesOfVariableInterestEntitiesAttributableToShareholders_9281071e-6bc6-48d3-8166-3e65a808e688" xlink:href="afg-20240930.xsd#afg_EarningsLossesOfVariableInterestEntitiesAttributableToShareholders"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_afg_FinancialInformationRelatedToCollateralizedLoanObligationsAbstract_f17caeb4-7212-41be-9b64-ab6b68d66579" xlink:to="loc_afg_EarningsLossesOfVariableInterestEntitiesAttributableToShareholders_9281071e-6bc6-48d3-8166-3e65a808e688" xlink:type="arc" order="3"/>
  </link:definitionLink>
  <link:roleRef roleURI="http://www.afginc.com/role/LongTermDebtNarrativeDetails" xlink:type="simple" xlink:href="afg-20240930.xsd#LongTermDebtNarrativeDetails"/>
  <link:definitionLink xlink:role="http://www.afginc.com/role/LongTermDebtNarrativeDetails" xlink:type="extended">
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_DebtInstrumentLineItems_587cf9a6-9727-44ab-a599-35460ea168e2" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_DebtInstrumentLineItems"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_DebtInstrumentTable_77371ca7-2617-49fe-9a83-aaa2bcfedbcc" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_DebtInstrumentTable"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/all" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DebtInstrumentLineItems_587cf9a6-9727-44ab-a599-35460ea168e2" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_DebtInstrumentTable_77371ca7-2617-49fe-9a83-aaa2bcfedbcc" xlink:type="arc" order="1" xbrldt:closed="true" xbrldt:contextElement="segment"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesAxis_eed9dd24-b690-45d1-8169-9de1fa2b66fb" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/srt/2024/elts/srt-2024.xsd#srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesAxis"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/hypercube-dimension" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DebtInstrumentTable_77371ca7-2617-49fe-9a83-aaa2bcfedbcc" xlink:to="loc_srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesAxis_eed9dd24-b690-45d1-8169-9de1fa2b66fb" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesDomain_eed9dd24-b690-45d1-8169-9de1fa2b66fb_default" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/srt/2024/elts/srt-2024.xsd#srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-default" xlink:from="loc_srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesAxis_eed9dd24-b690-45d1-8169-9de1fa2b66fb" xlink:to="loc_srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesDomain_eed9dd24-b690-45d1-8169-9de1fa2b66fb_default" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesDomain_7400b905-cbaa-4aed-a593-1c9670ec9795" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/srt/2024/elts/srt-2024.xsd#srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-domain" xlink:from="loc_srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesAxis_eed9dd24-b690-45d1-8169-9de1fa2b66fb" xlink:to="loc_srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesDomain_7400b905-cbaa-4aed-a593-1c9670ec9795" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_srt_ParentCompanyMember_3f629f4d-f06f-4a49-9d66-75ad4b227ba4" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/srt/2024/elts/srt-2024.xsd#srt_ParentCompanyMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesDomain_7400b905-cbaa-4aed-a593-1c9670ec9795" xlink:to="loc_srt_ParentCompanyMember_3f629f4d-f06f-4a49-9d66-75ad4b227ba4" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_srt_RangeAxis_1db9d162-0d8b-46cd-a2e8-9dde55c9b5f6" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/srt/2024/elts/srt-2024.xsd#srt_RangeAxis"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/hypercube-dimension" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DebtInstrumentTable_77371ca7-2617-49fe-9a83-aaa2bcfedbcc" xlink:to="loc_srt_RangeAxis_1db9d162-0d8b-46cd-a2e8-9dde55c9b5f6" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_srt_RangeMember_1db9d162-0d8b-46cd-a2e8-9dde55c9b5f6_default" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/srt/2024/elts/srt-2024.xsd#srt_RangeMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-default" xlink:from="loc_srt_RangeAxis_1db9d162-0d8b-46cd-a2e8-9dde55c9b5f6" xlink:to="loc_srt_RangeMember_1db9d162-0d8b-46cd-a2e8-9dde55c9b5f6_default" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_srt_RangeMember_acd21522-6e3e-46c7-8af6-5ad4afe7a491" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/srt/2024/elts/srt-2024.xsd#srt_RangeMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-domain" xlink:from="loc_srt_RangeAxis_1db9d162-0d8b-46cd-a2e8-9dde55c9b5f6" xlink:to="loc_srt_RangeMember_acd21522-6e3e-46c7-8af6-5ad4afe7a491" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_srt_MinimumMember_efee5315-1a8f-4b7e-b2f8-81566fe6ee1b" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/srt/2024/elts/srt-2024.xsd#srt_MinimumMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_srt_RangeMember_acd21522-6e3e-46c7-8af6-5ad4afe7a491" xlink:to="loc_srt_MinimumMember_efee5315-1a8f-4b7e-b2f8-81566fe6ee1b" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_srt_MaximumMember_98825af1-943c-4e6b-b076-a1d57c679fd1" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/srt/2024/elts/srt-2024.xsd#srt_MaximumMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_srt_RangeMember_acd21522-6e3e-46c7-8af6-5ad4afe7a491" xlink:to="loc_srt_MaximumMember_98825af1-943c-4e6b-b076-a1d57c679fd1" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_DebtInstrumentAxis_2b54c972-a377-41c5-a101-be747fab188f" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_DebtInstrumentAxis"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/hypercube-dimension" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DebtInstrumentTable_77371ca7-2617-49fe-9a83-aaa2bcfedbcc" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_DebtInstrumentAxis_2b54c972-a377-41c5-a101-be747fab188f" xlink:type="arc" order="3"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_DebtInstrumentNameDomain_2b54c972-a377-41c5-a101-be747fab188f_default" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_DebtInstrumentNameDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-default" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DebtInstrumentAxis_2b54c972-a377-41c5-a101-be747fab188f" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_DebtInstrumentNameDomain_2b54c972-a377-41c5-a101-be747fab188f_default" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_DebtInstrumentNameDomain_c76deb24-0cf2-4e6a-8d88-b39241953b13" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_DebtInstrumentNameDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-domain" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DebtInstrumentAxis_2b54c972-a377-41c5-a101-be747fab188f" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_DebtInstrumentNameDomain_c76deb24-0cf2-4e6a-8d88-b39241953b13" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_SeniorNotesDueInJune2047Member_46676e88-bcd1-4534-aea7-5e46e81ae578" xlink:href="afg-20240930.xsd#afg_SeniorNotesDueInJune2047Member"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DebtInstrumentNameDomain_c76deb24-0cf2-4e6a-8d88-b39241953b13" xlink:to="loc_afg_SeniorNotesDueInJune2047Member_46676e88-bcd1-4534-aea7-5e46e81ae578" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_SeniorNotesDueInApril2030Member_09aa922b-f990-4088-854d-5a5259376570" xlink:href="afg-20240930.xsd#afg_SeniorNotesDueInApril2030Member"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DebtInstrumentNameDomain_c76deb24-0cf2-4e6a-8d88-b39241953b13" xlink:to="loc_afg_SeniorNotesDueInApril2030Member_09aa922b-f990-4088-854d-5a5259376570" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_LongtermDebtTypeAxis_2cc392ed-d4a1-4f59-901d-f9d85b3fba82" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_LongtermDebtTypeAxis"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/hypercube-dimension" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DebtInstrumentTable_77371ca7-2617-49fe-9a83-aaa2bcfedbcc" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_LongtermDebtTypeAxis_2cc392ed-d4a1-4f59-901d-f9d85b3fba82" xlink:type="arc" order="4"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_LongtermDebtTypeDomain_2cc392ed-d4a1-4f59-901d-f9d85b3fba82_default" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_LongtermDebtTypeDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-default" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_LongtermDebtTypeAxis_2cc392ed-d4a1-4f59-901d-f9d85b3fba82" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_LongtermDebtTypeDomain_2cc392ed-d4a1-4f59-901d-f9d85b3fba82_default" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_LongtermDebtTypeDomain_eb097a66-9f50-498c-aff7-4f555ec2166d" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_LongtermDebtTypeDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-domain" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_LongtermDebtTypeAxis_2cc392ed-d4a1-4f59-901d-f9d85b3fba82" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_LongtermDebtTypeDomain_eb097a66-9f50-498c-aff7-4f555ec2166d" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_SeniorNotesMember_41449156-213a-44b6-ba4d-ded1839d0730" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_SeniorNotesMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_LongtermDebtTypeDomain_eb097a66-9f50-498c-aff7-4f555ec2166d" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_SeniorNotesMember_41449156-213a-44b6-ba4d-ded1839d0730" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_LongTermDebtByMaturityAbstract_4947b6a7-5310-4a25-ab6e-131d452eca99" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_LongTermDebtByMaturityAbstract"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DebtInstrumentLineItems_587cf9a6-9727-44ab-a599-35460ea168e2" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_LongTermDebtByMaturityAbstract_4947b6a7-5310-4a25-ab6e-131d452eca99" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_LongTermDebtMaturitiesRepaymentsOfPrincipalRemainderOfFiscalYear_92046efe-b2cd-42ef-aed6-2d1480638b7f" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_LongTermDebtMaturitiesRepaymentsOfPrincipalRemainderOfFiscalYear"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_LongTermDebtByMaturityAbstract_4947b6a7-5310-4a25-ab6e-131d452eca99" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_LongTermDebtMaturitiesRepaymentsOfPrincipalRemainderOfFiscalYear_92046efe-b2cd-42ef-aed6-2d1480638b7f" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_LongTermDebtMaturitiesRepaymentsOfPrincipalInNextTwelveMonths_97c530f2-afcf-444a-a46b-a6c15a6baafb" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_LongTermDebtMaturitiesRepaymentsOfPrincipalInNextTwelveMonths"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_LongTermDebtByMaturityAbstract_4947b6a7-5310-4a25-ab6e-131d452eca99" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_LongTermDebtMaturitiesRepaymentsOfPrincipalInNextTwelveMonths_97c530f2-afcf-444a-a46b-a6c15a6baafb" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_LongTermDebtMaturitiesRepaymentsOfPrincipalInYearTwo_d1616eaa-a490-416f-ae99-d44a44814b66" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_LongTermDebtMaturitiesRepaymentsOfPrincipalInYearTwo"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_LongTermDebtByMaturityAbstract_4947b6a7-5310-4a25-ab6e-131d452eca99" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_LongTermDebtMaturitiesRepaymentsOfPrincipalInYearTwo_d1616eaa-a490-416f-ae99-d44a44814b66" xlink:type="arc" order="3"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_LongTermDebtMaturitiesRepaymentsOfPrincipalInYearThree_177d2306-afee-427d-9292-439f8a68782d" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_LongTermDebtMaturitiesRepaymentsOfPrincipalInYearThree"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_LongTermDebtByMaturityAbstract_4947b6a7-5310-4a25-ab6e-131d452eca99" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_LongTermDebtMaturitiesRepaymentsOfPrincipalInYearThree_177d2306-afee-427d-9292-439f8a68782d" xlink:type="arc" order="4"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_LongTermDebtMaturitiesRepaymentsOfPrincipalInYearFour_0ae0ae4c-f590-4165-8a0f-6177594ff06f" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_LongTermDebtMaturitiesRepaymentsOfPrincipalInYearFour"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_LongTermDebtByMaturityAbstract_4947b6a7-5310-4a25-ab6e-131d452eca99" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_LongTermDebtMaturitiesRepaymentsOfPrincipalInYearFour_0ae0ae4c-f590-4165-8a0f-6177594ff06f" xlink:type="arc" order="5"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_LongTermDebtMaturitiesRepaymentsOfPrincipalInYearFive_d77b1ad1-16b0-4b80-a5bc-77d47dcd49e5" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_LongTermDebtMaturitiesRepaymentsOfPrincipalInYearFive"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_LongTermDebtByMaturityAbstract_4947b6a7-5310-4a25-ab6e-131d452eca99" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_LongTermDebtMaturitiesRepaymentsOfPrincipalInYearFive_d77b1ad1-16b0-4b80-a5bc-77d47dcd49e5" xlink:type="arc" order="6"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_LongTermDebtMaturitiesRepaymentsOfPrincipalAfterYearFive_0a9edbc4-f5b8-4f1c-99a6-38901d4e2126" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_LongTermDebtMaturitiesRepaymentsOfPrincipalAfterYearFive"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_LongTermDebtByMaturityAbstract_4947b6a7-5310-4a25-ab6e-131d452eca99" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_LongTermDebtMaturitiesRepaymentsOfPrincipalAfterYearFive_0a9edbc4-f5b8-4f1c-99a6-38901d4e2126" xlink:type="arc" order="7"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_DebtInstrumentRepurchasedFaceAmount_f147029c-bdc1-4a77-9ed8-175ebc0fd9fc" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_DebtInstrumentRepurchasedFaceAmount"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DebtInstrumentLineItems_587cf9a6-9727-44ab-a599-35460ea168e2" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_DebtInstrumentRepurchasedFaceAmount_f147029c-bdc1-4a77-9ed8-175ebc0fd9fc" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_DebtInstrumentInterestRateStatedPercentage_7bcaf08e-e0f3-4ee2-a386-ab8674d23d95" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_DebtInstrumentInterestRateStatedPercentage"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DebtInstrumentLineItems_587cf9a6-9727-44ab-a599-35460ea168e2" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_DebtInstrumentInterestRateStatedPercentage_7bcaf08e-e0f3-4ee2-a386-ab8674d23d95" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_DebtInstrumentRepurchaseAmount_f2e1f334-7579-48b3-947e-f5ac92e03c37" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_DebtInstrumentRepurchaseAmount"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DebtInstrumentLineItems_587cf9a6-9727-44ab-a599-35460ea168e2" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_DebtInstrumentRepurchaseAmount_f2e1f334-7579-48b3-947e-f5ac92e03c37" xlink:type="arc" order="3"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_LineOfCreditFacilityMaximumBorrowingCapacity_5c7008aa-a360-461a-afee-7158cc43dcdb" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_LineOfCreditFacilityMaximumBorrowingCapacity"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DebtInstrumentLineItems_587cf9a6-9727-44ab-a599-35460ea168e2" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_LineOfCreditFacilityMaximumBorrowingCapacity_5c7008aa-a360-461a-afee-7158cc43dcdb" xlink:type="arc" order="4"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_DebtInstrumentBasisSpreadOnVariableRate1_a6988abb-4603-486e-85db-a13baea3bef5" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_DebtInstrumentBasisSpreadOnVariableRate1"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DebtInstrumentLineItems_587cf9a6-9727-44ab-a599-35460ea168e2" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_DebtInstrumentBasisSpreadOnVariableRate1_a6988abb-4603-486e-85db-a13baea3bef5" xlink:type="arc" order="5"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_DebtInstrumentVariableInterestRateTypeExtensibleEnumeration_cc5a7d17-4b99-4eb2-bfde-2ab2cd613f74" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_DebtInstrumentVariableInterestRateTypeExtensibleEnumeration"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DebtInstrumentLineItems_587cf9a6-9727-44ab-a599-35460ea168e2" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_DebtInstrumentVariableInterestRateTypeExtensibleEnumeration_cc5a7d17-4b99-4eb2-bfde-2ab2cd613f74" xlink:type="arc" order="6"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_LineOfCredit_c861085a-1932-48f1-ad2e-190742d653f2" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_LineOfCredit"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DebtInstrumentLineItems_587cf9a6-9727-44ab-a599-35460ea168e2" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_LineOfCredit_c861085a-1932-48f1-ad2e-190742d653f2" xlink:type="arc" order="7"/>
  </link:definitionLink>
  <link:roleRef roleURI="http://www.afginc.com/role/LongTermDebtScheduleoflongtermdebtDetails" xlink:type="simple" xlink:href="afg-20240930.xsd#LongTermDebtScheduleoflongtermdebtDetails"/>
  <link:definitionLink xlink:role="http://www.afginc.com/role/LongTermDebtScheduleoflongtermdebtDetails" xlink:type="extended">
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_DebtInstrumentLineItems_60a98638-7cf2-42e0-85ce-6e30c8831afc" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_DebtInstrumentLineItems"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_DebtInstrumentTable_40a12ecc-dbc6-47a8-b1e8-526c1215ac85" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_DebtInstrumentTable"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/all" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DebtInstrumentLineItems_60a98638-7cf2-42e0-85ce-6e30c8831afc" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_DebtInstrumentTable_40a12ecc-dbc6-47a8-b1e8-526c1215ac85" xlink:type="arc" order="1" xbrldt:closed="true" xbrldt:contextElement="segment"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_LongtermDebtTypeAxis_f479f41a-c9ad-4dac-a616-d95b2f0abfe7" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_LongtermDebtTypeAxis"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/hypercube-dimension" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DebtInstrumentTable_40a12ecc-dbc6-47a8-b1e8-526c1215ac85" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_LongtermDebtTypeAxis_f479f41a-c9ad-4dac-a616-d95b2f0abfe7" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_LongtermDebtTypeDomain_f479f41a-c9ad-4dac-a616-d95b2f0abfe7_default" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_LongtermDebtTypeDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-default" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_LongtermDebtTypeAxis_f479f41a-c9ad-4dac-a616-d95b2f0abfe7" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_LongtermDebtTypeDomain_f479f41a-c9ad-4dac-a616-d95b2f0abfe7_default" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_LongtermDebtTypeDomain_d031bd6c-f696-42d4-9f57-a7facc72f582" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_LongtermDebtTypeDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-domain" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_LongtermDebtTypeAxis_f479f41a-c9ad-4dac-a616-d95b2f0abfe7" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_LongtermDebtTypeDomain_d031bd6c-f696-42d4-9f57-a7facc72f582" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_SeniorNotesMember_a1f33440-4939-4282-8324-a35995753461" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_SeniorNotesMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_LongtermDebtTypeDomain_d031bd6c-f696-42d4-9f57-a7facc72f582" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_SeniorNotesMember_a1f33440-4939-4282-8324-a35995753461" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_SubordinatedDebtMember_a2ee3c0f-9f3e-4800-b7c0-aa79a2ba4e05" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_SubordinatedDebtMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_LongtermDebtTypeDomain_d031bd6c-f696-42d4-9f57-a7facc72f582" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_SubordinatedDebtMember_a2ee3c0f-9f3e-4800-b7c0-aa79a2ba4e05" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_DebtInstrumentAxis_1d7c9c3a-75d8-4412-841c-3b37390571c8" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_DebtInstrumentAxis"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/hypercube-dimension" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DebtInstrumentTable_40a12ecc-dbc6-47a8-b1e8-526c1215ac85" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_DebtInstrumentAxis_1d7c9c3a-75d8-4412-841c-3b37390571c8" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_DebtInstrumentNameDomain_1d7c9c3a-75d8-4412-841c-3b37390571c8_default" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_DebtInstrumentNameDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-default" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DebtInstrumentAxis_1d7c9c3a-75d8-4412-841c-3b37390571c8" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_DebtInstrumentNameDomain_1d7c9c3a-75d8-4412-841c-3b37390571c8_default" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_DebtInstrumentNameDomain_70970c8a-e80c-4544-9640-80098422bfec" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_DebtInstrumentNameDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-domain" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DebtInstrumentAxis_1d7c9c3a-75d8-4412-841c-3b37390571c8" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_DebtInstrumentNameDomain_70970c8a-e80c-4544-9640-80098422bfec" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_SeniorNotesDueInJune2047Member_106e6c43-cae2-4f63-a17c-0f65a528dca7" xlink:href="afg-20240930.xsd#afg_SeniorNotesDueInJune2047Member"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DebtInstrumentNameDomain_70970c8a-e80c-4544-9640-80098422bfec" xlink:to="loc_afg_SeniorNotesDueInJune2047Member_106e6c43-cae2-4f63-a17c-0f65a528dca7" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_SeniorNotesDueInApril2030Member_2d376cef-ae2c-45d4-9dd3-e0aab3485852" xlink:href="afg-20240930.xsd#afg_SeniorNotesDueInApril2030Member"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DebtInstrumentNameDomain_70970c8a-e80c-4544-9640-80098422bfec" xlink:to="loc_afg_SeniorNotesDueInApril2030Member_2d376cef-ae2c-45d4-9dd3-e0aab3485852" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_OtherLongtermDebtMember_29936221-6cd9-462e-a659-3c309b37bc31" xlink:href="afg-20240930.xsd#afg_OtherLongtermDebtMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DebtInstrumentNameDomain_70970c8a-e80c-4544-9640-80098422bfec" xlink:to="loc_afg_OtherLongtermDebtMember_29936221-6cd9-462e-a659-3c309b37bc31" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_SubordinatedDebenturesDueInSeptember2060Member_37589b6e-d845-4ce1-badf-4efabd2dd5e0" xlink:href="afg-20240930.xsd#afg_SubordinatedDebenturesDueInSeptember2060Member"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DebtInstrumentNameDomain_70970c8a-e80c-4544-9640-80098422bfec" xlink:to="loc_afg_SubordinatedDebenturesDueInSeptember2060Member_37589b6e-d845-4ce1-badf-4efabd2dd5e0" xlink:type="arc" order="3"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_SubordinatedDebenturesdueinDecember2059Member_e79e0dd7-cb27-42d7-b8ab-5e6db729dbf9" xlink:href="afg-20240930.xsd#afg_SubordinatedDebenturesdueinDecember2059Member"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DebtInstrumentNameDomain_70970c8a-e80c-4544-9640-80098422bfec" xlink:to="loc_afg_SubordinatedDebenturesdueinDecember2059Member_e79e0dd7-cb27-42d7-b8ab-5e6db729dbf9" xlink:type="arc" order="4"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_SubordinatedDebenturesDueInJune2060Member_c6901e3d-556e-4e95-a144-445e4b05baa1" xlink:href="afg-20240930.xsd#afg_SubordinatedDebenturesDueInJune2060Member"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DebtInstrumentNameDomain_70970c8a-e80c-4544-9640-80098422bfec" xlink:to="loc_afg_SubordinatedDebenturesDueInJune2060Member_c6901e3d-556e-4e95-a144-445e4b05baa1" xlink:type="arc" order="5"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_SubordinatedDebenturesDueInMarch2059Member_4f0b76d7-1d90-498d-8f70-31d75acf5ffd" xlink:href="afg-20240930.xsd#afg_SubordinatedDebenturesDueInMarch2059Member"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DebtInstrumentNameDomain_70970c8a-e80c-4544-9640-80098422bfec" xlink:to="loc_afg_SubordinatedDebenturesDueInMarch2059Member_4f0b76d7-1d90-498d-8f70-31d75acf5ffd" xlink:type="arc" order="6"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesAxis_da79f909-a3b5-4dac-89ab-53ff9b855d49" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/srt/2024/elts/srt-2024.xsd#srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesAxis"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/hypercube-dimension" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DebtInstrumentTable_40a12ecc-dbc6-47a8-b1e8-526c1215ac85" xlink:to="loc_srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesAxis_da79f909-a3b5-4dac-89ab-53ff9b855d49" xlink:type="arc" order="3"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesDomain_da79f909-a3b5-4dac-89ab-53ff9b855d49_default" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/srt/2024/elts/srt-2024.xsd#srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-default" xlink:from="loc_srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesAxis_da79f909-a3b5-4dac-89ab-53ff9b855d49" xlink:to="loc_srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesDomain_da79f909-a3b5-4dac-89ab-53ff9b855d49_default" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesDomain_f7612125-c7c5-4d20-b580-4d099f119a81" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/srt/2024/elts/srt-2024.xsd#srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-domain" xlink:from="loc_srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesAxis_da79f909-a3b5-4dac-89ab-53ff9b855d49" xlink:to="loc_srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesDomain_f7612125-c7c5-4d20-b580-4d099f119a81" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_srt_ParentCompanyMember_cfb044e5-7ccd-4374-8262-67b22ac95346" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/srt/2024/elts/srt-2024.xsd#srt_ParentCompanyMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesDomain_f7612125-c7c5-4d20-b580-4d099f119a81" xlink:to="loc_srt_ParentCompanyMember_cfb044e5-7ccd-4374-8262-67b22ac95346" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_DebtInstrumentInterestRateStatedPercentage_407f4a66-85a1-4af4-9968-4144e8202397" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_DebtInstrumentInterestRateStatedPercentage"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DebtInstrumentLineItems_60a98638-7cf2-42e0-85ce-6e30c8831afc" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_DebtInstrumentInterestRateStatedPercentage_407f4a66-85a1-4af4-9968-4144e8202397" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_SummaryOfCarryingValueOfLongTermDebtAbstract_17eba615-054b-4039-83c0-81477f96fc19" xlink:href="afg-20240930.xsd#afg_SummaryOfCarryingValueOfLongTermDebtAbstract"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DebtInstrumentLineItems_60a98638-7cf2-42e0-85ce-6e30c8831afc" xlink:to="loc_afg_SummaryOfCarryingValueOfLongTermDebtAbstract_17eba615-054b-4039-83c0-81477f96fc19" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_DebtInstrumentCarryingAmount_e6920e54-093c-4f02-aa89-d2e9e2b15bc4" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_DebtInstrumentCarryingAmount"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_afg_SummaryOfCarryingValueOfLongTermDebtAbstract_17eba615-054b-4039-83c0-81477f96fc19" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_DebtInstrumentCarryingAmount_e6920e54-093c-4f02-aa89-d2e9e2b15bc4" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_DeferredFinanceCostsNet_66c27b32-07f8-477e-9a3c-bf6acae46d69" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_DeferredFinanceCostsNet"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_afg_SummaryOfCarryingValueOfLongTermDebtAbstract_17eba615-054b-4039-83c0-81477f96fc19" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_DeferredFinanceCostsNet_66c27b32-07f8-477e-9a3c-bf6acae46d69" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_LongTermDebt_7cdcc41e-9f9d-4d1e-a56d-0cb9821bc9d6" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_LongTermDebt"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_afg_SummaryOfCarryingValueOfLongTermDebtAbstract_17eba615-054b-4039-83c0-81477f96fc19" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_LongTermDebt_7cdcc41e-9f9d-4d1e-a56d-0cb9821bc9d6" xlink:type="arc" order="3"/>
  </link:definitionLink>
  <link:roleRef roleURI="http://www.afginc.com/role/ShareholdersEquityPreferredstockauthorizedforissuanceDetails" xlink:type="simple" xlink:href="afg-20240930.xsd#ShareholdersEquityPreferredstockauthorizedforissuanceDetails"/>
  <link:definitionLink xlink:role="http://www.afginc.com/role/ShareholdersEquityPreferredstockauthorizedforissuanceDetails" xlink:type="extended">
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_ClassOfStockLineItems_355cda92-0374-4c25-8955-08044ad04c6f" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_ClassOfStockLineItems"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfStockByClassTable_641eff0f-b36f-49d2-8727-398fd90df4df" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_ScheduleOfStockByClassTable"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/all" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ClassOfStockLineItems_355cda92-0374-4c25-8955-08044ad04c6f" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfStockByClassTable_641eff0f-b36f-49d2-8727-398fd90df4df" xlink:type="arc" order="1" xbrldt:closed="true" xbrldt:contextElement="segment"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_StatementClassOfStockAxis_a27d2bc9-0e00-48b2-9327-3b402f4f6509" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_StatementClassOfStockAxis"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/hypercube-dimension" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfStockByClassTable_641eff0f-b36f-49d2-8727-398fd90df4df" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_StatementClassOfStockAxis_a27d2bc9-0e00-48b2-9327-3b402f4f6509" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_ClassOfStockDomain_a27d2bc9-0e00-48b2-9327-3b402f4f6509_default" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_ClassOfStockDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-default" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_StatementClassOfStockAxis_a27d2bc9-0e00-48b2-9327-3b402f4f6509" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_ClassOfStockDomain_a27d2bc9-0e00-48b2-9327-3b402f4f6509_default" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_ClassOfStockDomain_b5c02f73-0b32-4c33-ba8e-0dc00eb172e2" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_ClassOfStockDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-domain" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_StatementClassOfStockAxis_a27d2bc9-0e00-48b2-9327-3b402f4f6509" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_ClassOfStockDomain_b5c02f73-0b32-4c33-ba8e-0dc00eb172e2" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_VotingPreferredStockMember_566a6666-3a9c-442e-b406-c15256812bae" xlink:href="afg-20240930.xsd#afg_VotingPreferredStockMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ClassOfStockDomain_b5c02f73-0b32-4c33-ba8e-0dc00eb172e2" xlink:to="loc_afg_VotingPreferredStockMember_566a6666-3a9c-442e-b406-c15256812bae" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_NonvotingPreferredStockMember_54f3da36-3916-4b9f-8e87-1ff8be6ee61c" xlink:href="afg-20240930.xsd#afg_NonvotingPreferredStockMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ClassOfStockDomain_b5c02f73-0b32-4c33-ba8e-0dc00eb172e2" xlink:to="loc_afg_NonvotingPreferredStockMember_54f3da36-3916-4b9f-8e87-1ff8be6ee61c" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_PreferredStockSharesAuthorized_81112940-375a-441b-901e-dbf658d32830" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_PreferredStockSharesAuthorized"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ClassOfStockLineItems_355cda92-0374-4c25-8955-08044ad04c6f" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_PreferredStockSharesAuthorized_81112940-375a-441b-901e-dbf658d32830" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_PreferredStockNoParValue_24ab4dd5-2b67-4efe-86b3-e0d85eea0ea8" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_PreferredStockNoParValue"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ClassOfStockLineItems_355cda92-0374-4c25-8955-08044ad04c6f" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_PreferredStockNoParValue_24ab4dd5-2b67-4efe-86b3-e0d85eea0ea8" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
  </link:definitionLink>
  <link:roleRef roleURI="http://www.afginc.com/role/ShareholdersEquityProgressionofthecomponentsofaccumulatedothercomprehensiveincomeDetails" xlink:type="simple" xlink:href="afg-20240930.xsd#ShareholdersEquityProgressionofthecomponentsofaccumulatedothercomprehensiveincomeDetails"/>
  <link:definitionLink xlink:role="http://www.afginc.com/role/ShareholdersEquityProgressionofthecomponentsofaccumulatedothercomprehensiveincomeDetails" xlink:type="extended">
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_AccumulatedOtherComprehensiveIncomeLossLineItems_d75e4c76-a719-42b0-859c-f0199b15f02f" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_AccumulatedOtherComprehensiveIncomeLossLineItems"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_AccumulatedOtherComprehensiveIncomeLossTable_b9b35273-cac1-4f0f-82b2-7083e7e3094f" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_AccumulatedOtherComprehensiveIncomeLossTable"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/all" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_AccumulatedOtherComprehensiveIncomeLossLineItems_d75e4c76-a719-42b0-859c-f0199b15f02f" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_AccumulatedOtherComprehensiveIncomeLossTable_b9b35273-cac1-4f0f-82b2-7083e7e3094f" xlink:type="arc" order="1" xbrldt:closed="true" xbrldt:contextElement="segment"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_StatementEquityComponentsAxis_29edbfd8-99b2-46e1-9f19-774a30adfc62" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_StatementEquityComponentsAxis"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/hypercube-dimension" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_AccumulatedOtherComprehensiveIncomeLossTable_b9b35273-cac1-4f0f-82b2-7083e7e3094f" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_StatementEquityComponentsAxis_29edbfd8-99b2-46e1-9f19-774a30adfc62" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_EquityComponentDomain_29edbfd8-99b2-46e1-9f19-774a30adfc62_default" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_EquityComponentDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-default" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_StatementEquityComponentsAxis_29edbfd8-99b2-46e1-9f19-774a30adfc62" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_EquityComponentDomain_29edbfd8-99b2-46e1-9f19-774a30adfc62_default" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_EquityComponentDomain_75d3d50f-9c9d-4a18-ada5-41fca0552748" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_EquityComponentDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-domain" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_StatementEquityComponentsAxis_29edbfd8-99b2-46e1-9f19-774a30adfc62" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_EquityComponentDomain_75d3d50f-9c9d-4a18-ada5-41fca0552748" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_AccumulatedOtherComprehensiveIncomeMember_e29b9742-8ff7-4faf-9187-23e86c946d1c" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_AccumulatedOtherComprehensiveIncomeMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_EquityComponentDomain_75d3d50f-9c9d-4a18-ada5-41fca0552748" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_AccumulatedOtherComprehensiveIncomeMember_e29b9742-8ff7-4faf-9187-23e86c946d1c" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_AccumulatedNetUnrealizedInvestmentGainLossMember_4681a396-451c-4f7e-abff-e207c4bc3a11" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_AccumulatedNetUnrealizedInvestmentGainLossMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_AccumulatedOtherComprehensiveIncomeMember_e29b9742-8ff7-4faf-9187-23e86c946d1c" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_AccumulatedNetUnrealizedInvestmentGainLossMember_4681a396-451c-4f7e-abff-e207c4bc3a11" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_AccumulatedGainLossNetCashFlowHedgeParentMember_b5fc3a44-fcc1-4fbf-97eb-2f5cb32839f7" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_AccumulatedGainLossNetCashFlowHedgeParentMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_AccumulatedOtherComprehensiveIncomeMember_e29b9742-8ff7-4faf-9187-23e86c946d1c" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_AccumulatedGainLossNetCashFlowHedgeParentMember_b5fc3a44-fcc1-4fbf-97eb-2f5cb32839f7" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_AccumulatedTranslationAdjustmentMember_9977d280-4ebb-4ed9-b3a3-f98dd0890b1f" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_AccumulatedTranslationAdjustmentMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_AccumulatedOtherComprehensiveIncomeMember_e29b9742-8ff7-4faf-9187-23e86c946d1c" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_AccumulatedTranslationAdjustmentMember_9977d280-4ebb-4ed9-b3a3-f98dd0890b1f" xlink:type="arc" order="3"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_AccumulatedDefinedBenefitPlansAdjustmentMember_c8a35b7e-33f0-46c5-84ba-5cef662a264d" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_AccumulatedDefinedBenefitPlansAdjustmentMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_AccumulatedOtherComprehensiveIncomeMember_e29b9742-8ff7-4faf-9187-23e86c946d1c" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_AccumulatedDefinedBenefitPlansAdjustmentMember_c8a35b7e-33f0-46c5-84ba-5cef662a264d" xlink:type="arc" order="4"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_AOCIAttributableToParentNetOfTaxRollForward_a745195d-9c97-46e2-a3e5-a6102386d5af" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_AOCIAttributableToParentNetOfTaxRollForward"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_AccumulatedOtherComprehensiveIncomeLossLineItems_d75e4c76-a719-42b0-859c-f0199b15f02f" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_AOCIAttributableToParentNetOfTaxRollForward_a745195d-9c97-46e2-a3e5-a6102386d5af" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_AccumulatedOtherComprehensiveIncomeLossNetOfTax_e2b5461e-42b1-48f2-a296-6cc80b096596" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_AccumulatedOtherComprehensiveIncomeLossNetOfTax"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_AOCIAttributableToParentNetOfTaxRollForward_a745195d-9c97-46e2-a3e5-a6102386d5af" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_AccumulatedOtherComprehensiveIncomeLossNetOfTax_e2b5461e-42b1-48f2-a296-6cc80b096596" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_OtherComprehensiveIncomeLossBeforeTax_a8d02d71-4b7d-4559-b128-43b61aafd756" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_OtherComprehensiveIncomeLossBeforeTax"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_AOCIAttributableToParentNetOfTaxRollForward_a745195d-9c97-46e2-a3e5-a6102386d5af" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_OtherComprehensiveIncomeLossBeforeTax_a8d02d71-4b7d-4559-b128-43b61aafd756" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_OtherComprehensiveIncomeLossTax_51ee7f33-8244-419b-9530-56b1ac64d84f" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_OtherComprehensiveIncomeLossTax"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_AOCIAttributableToParentNetOfTaxRollForward_a745195d-9c97-46e2-a3e5-a6102386d5af" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_OtherComprehensiveIncomeLossTax_51ee7f33-8244-419b-9530-56b1ac64d84f" xlink:type="arc" order="3"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_OtherComprehensiveIncomeLossNetOfTax_1ac1e4cf-ad9a-4dcd-aee6-88631141c16a" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_OtherComprehensiveIncomeLossNetOfTax"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_AOCIAttributableToParentNetOfTaxRollForward_a745195d-9c97-46e2-a3e5-a6102386d5af" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_OtherComprehensiveIncomeLossNetOfTax_1ac1e4cf-ad9a-4dcd-aee6-88631141c16a" xlink:type="arc" order="4"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_AccumulatedOtherComprehensiveIncomeLossNetOfTax_e8307e0c-11e2-4006-97ae-ac3e0a49bc97" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_AccumulatedOtherComprehensiveIncomeLossNetOfTax"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_DebtSecuritiesUnrealizedGainLossAbstract_b9d90a5a-b64f-44ba-94f0-1a6fa156d6b7" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_DebtSecuritiesUnrealizedGainLossAbstract"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_AccumulatedOtherComprehensiveIncomeLossLineItems_d75e4c76-a719-42b0-859c-f0199b15f02f" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_DebtSecuritiesUnrealizedGainLossAbstract_b9d90a5a-b64f-44ba-94f0-1a6fa156d6b7" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_OtherComprehensiveIncomeUnrealizedHoldingGainLossOnSecuritiesArisingDuringPeriodBeforeTax_5f4798c3-3c2d-4101-8a37-846c2f71e78f" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_OtherComprehensiveIncomeUnrealizedHoldingGainLossOnSecuritiesArisingDuringPeriodBeforeTax"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DebtSecuritiesUnrealizedGainLossAbstract_b9d90a5a-b64f-44ba-94f0-1a6fa156d6b7" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_OtherComprehensiveIncomeUnrealizedHoldingGainLossOnSecuritiesArisingDuringPeriodBeforeTax_5f4798c3-3c2d-4101-8a37-846c2f71e78f" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_OtherComprehensiveIncomeUnrealizedHoldingGainLossOnSecuritiesArisingDuringPeriodTax_1c504ed6-6bf7-4f2d-803d-57f23535862a" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_OtherComprehensiveIncomeUnrealizedHoldingGainLossOnSecuritiesArisingDuringPeriodTax"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DebtSecuritiesUnrealizedGainLossAbstract_b9d90a5a-b64f-44ba-94f0-1a6fa156d6b7" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_OtherComprehensiveIncomeUnrealizedHoldingGainLossOnSecuritiesArisingDuringPeriodTax_1c504ed6-6bf7-4f2d-803d-57f23535862a" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_OtherComprehensiveIncomeUnrealizedHoldingGainLossOnSecuritiesArisingDuringPeriodNetOfTax_c3d36503-ae49-47a6-aff5-8de041189e73" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_OtherComprehensiveIncomeUnrealizedHoldingGainLossOnSecuritiesArisingDuringPeriodNetOfTax"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DebtSecuritiesUnrealizedGainLossAbstract_b9d90a5a-b64f-44ba-94f0-1a6fa156d6b7" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_OtherComprehensiveIncomeUnrealizedHoldingGainLossOnSecuritiesArisingDuringPeriodNetOfTax_c3d36503-ae49-47a6-aff5-8de041189e73" xlink:type="arc" order="3"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_OtherComprehensiveIncomeLossReclassificationAdjustmentFromAOCIForSaleOfSecuritiesBeforeTax_22587350-7f93-4eba-998d-4e6f0c51d09c" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_OtherComprehensiveIncomeLossReclassificationAdjustmentFromAOCIForSaleOfSecuritiesBeforeTax"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DebtSecuritiesUnrealizedGainLossAbstract_b9d90a5a-b64f-44ba-94f0-1a6fa156d6b7" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_OtherComprehensiveIncomeLossReclassificationAdjustmentFromAOCIForSaleOfSecuritiesBeforeTax_22587350-7f93-4eba-998d-4e6f0c51d09c" xlink:type="arc" order="4"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_OtherComprehensiveIncomeLossReclassificationAdjustmentFromAOCIForSaleOfSecuritiesTax_3b502572-d432-44dc-8224-a6e39ace6c2c" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_OtherComprehensiveIncomeLossReclassificationAdjustmentFromAOCIForSaleOfSecuritiesTax"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DebtSecuritiesUnrealizedGainLossAbstract_b9d90a5a-b64f-44ba-94f0-1a6fa156d6b7" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_OtherComprehensiveIncomeLossReclassificationAdjustmentFromAOCIForSaleOfSecuritiesTax_3b502572-d432-44dc-8224-a6e39ace6c2c" xlink:type="arc" order="5"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_OtherComprehensiveIncomeLossReclassificationAdjustmentFromAOCIForSaleOfSecuritiesNetOfTax_45c4aa1c-d99d-464a-9a52-c1ac980de5e1" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_OtherComprehensiveIncomeLossReclassificationAdjustmentFromAOCIForSaleOfSecuritiesNetOfTax"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DebtSecuritiesUnrealizedGainLossAbstract_b9d90a5a-b64f-44ba-94f0-1a6fa156d6b7" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_OtherComprehensiveIncomeLossReclassificationAdjustmentFromAOCIForSaleOfSecuritiesNetOfTax_45c4aa1c-d99d-464a-9a52-c1ac980de5e1" xlink:type="arc" order="6"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_OtherComprehensiveIncomeLossAvailableForSaleSecuritiesAdjustmentBeforeTax_854bafe4-39e9-45ca-8a02-c4e908a31eac" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_OtherComprehensiveIncomeLossAvailableForSaleSecuritiesAdjustmentBeforeTax"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DebtSecuritiesUnrealizedGainLossAbstract_b9d90a5a-b64f-44ba-94f0-1a6fa156d6b7" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_OtherComprehensiveIncomeLossAvailableForSaleSecuritiesAdjustmentBeforeTax_854bafe4-39e9-45ca-8a02-c4e908a31eac" xlink:type="arc" order="7"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_OtherComprehensiveIncomeLossAvailableForSaleSecuritiesTax_676b89fa-f07c-4ebd-ad85-840ad339363e" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_OtherComprehensiveIncomeLossAvailableForSaleSecuritiesTax"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DebtSecuritiesUnrealizedGainLossAbstract_b9d90a5a-b64f-44ba-94f0-1a6fa156d6b7" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_OtherComprehensiveIncomeLossAvailableForSaleSecuritiesTax_676b89fa-f07c-4ebd-ad85-840ad339363e" xlink:type="arc" order="8"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_OtherComprehensiveIncomeLossAvailableForSaleSecuritiesAdjustmentNetOfTax_cfa22533-cc8f-44e4-8038-918f31b1be36" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_OtherComprehensiveIncomeLossAvailableForSaleSecuritiesAdjustmentNetOfTax"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DebtSecuritiesUnrealizedGainLossAbstract_b9d90a5a-b64f-44ba-94f0-1a6fa156d6b7" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_OtherComprehensiveIncomeLossAvailableForSaleSecuritiesAdjustmentNetOfTax_cfa22533-cc8f-44e4-8038-918f31b1be36" xlink:type="arc" order="9"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_ReclassificationOfCashFlowHedgeGainLossAbstract_571e9043-08fa-45e9-bd18-2d78c2e7a429" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_ReclassificationOfCashFlowHedgeGainLossAbstract"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_AccumulatedOtherComprehensiveIncomeLossLineItems_d75e4c76-a719-42b0-859c-f0199b15f02f" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_ReclassificationOfCashFlowHedgeGainLossAbstract_571e9043-08fa-45e9-bd18-2d78c2e7a429" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_OtherComprehensiveIncomeLossCashFlowHedgeGainLossBeforeReclassificationAndTax_8a45a8ba-54e2-49d7-979d-53442af954ef" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_OtherComprehensiveIncomeLossCashFlowHedgeGainLossBeforeReclassificationAndTax"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ReclassificationOfCashFlowHedgeGainLossAbstract_571e9043-08fa-45e9-bd18-2d78c2e7a429" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_OtherComprehensiveIncomeLossCashFlowHedgeGainLossBeforeReclassificationAndTax_8a45a8ba-54e2-49d7-979d-53442af954ef" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_OtherComprehensiveIncomeLossCashFlowHedgeGainLossBeforeReclassificationTax_b507d7ce-b615-4a5e-ab94-7b31d4fc382f" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_OtherComprehensiveIncomeLossCashFlowHedgeGainLossBeforeReclassificationTax"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ReclassificationOfCashFlowHedgeGainLossAbstract_571e9043-08fa-45e9-bd18-2d78c2e7a429" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_OtherComprehensiveIncomeLossCashFlowHedgeGainLossBeforeReclassificationTax_b507d7ce-b615-4a5e-ab94-7b31d4fc382f" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_OtherComprehensiveIncomeLossCashFlowHedgeGainLossBeforeReclassificationAfterTax_04968c76-e30a-4e82-879d-777a71537286" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_OtherComprehensiveIncomeLossCashFlowHedgeGainLossBeforeReclassificationAfterTax"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ReclassificationOfCashFlowHedgeGainLossAbstract_571e9043-08fa-45e9-bd18-2d78c2e7a429" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_OtherComprehensiveIncomeLossCashFlowHedgeGainLossBeforeReclassificationAfterTax_04968c76-e30a-4e82-879d-777a71537286" xlink:type="arc" order="3"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_OtherComprehensiveIncomeLossCashFlowHedgeGainLossReclassificationBeforeTax_91a178fb-e40c-4afa-9a57-6ae312b05d25" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_OtherComprehensiveIncomeLossCashFlowHedgeGainLossReclassificationBeforeTax"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ReclassificationOfCashFlowHedgeGainLossAbstract_571e9043-08fa-45e9-bd18-2d78c2e7a429" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_OtherComprehensiveIncomeLossCashFlowHedgeGainLossReclassificationBeforeTax_91a178fb-e40c-4afa-9a57-6ae312b05d25" xlink:type="arc" order="4"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_OtherComprehensiveIncomeLossCashFlowHedgeGainLossReclassificationTax_27e0567e-a60e-4e3e-acef-ee9c9bd42e1d" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_OtherComprehensiveIncomeLossCashFlowHedgeGainLossReclassificationTax"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ReclassificationOfCashFlowHedgeGainLossAbstract_571e9043-08fa-45e9-bd18-2d78c2e7a429" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_OtherComprehensiveIncomeLossCashFlowHedgeGainLossReclassificationTax_27e0567e-a60e-4e3e-acef-ee9c9bd42e1d" xlink:type="arc" order="5"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_OtherComprehensiveIncomeLossCashFlowHedgeGainLossReclassificationAfterTax_0afec262-1a7e-49b1-b03a-90c13382515c" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_OtherComprehensiveIncomeLossCashFlowHedgeGainLossReclassificationAfterTax"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ReclassificationOfCashFlowHedgeGainLossAbstract_571e9043-08fa-45e9-bd18-2d78c2e7a429" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_OtherComprehensiveIncomeLossCashFlowHedgeGainLossReclassificationAfterTax_0afec262-1a7e-49b1-b03a-90c13382515c" xlink:type="arc" order="6"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_OtherComprehensiveIncomeLossCashFlowHedgeGainLossAfterReclassificationBeforeTax_21943ccf-266e-4845-8de5-e4a6642bd2c0" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_OtherComprehensiveIncomeLossCashFlowHedgeGainLossAfterReclassificationBeforeTax"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ReclassificationOfCashFlowHedgeGainLossAbstract_571e9043-08fa-45e9-bd18-2d78c2e7a429" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_OtherComprehensiveIncomeLossCashFlowHedgeGainLossAfterReclassificationBeforeTax_21943ccf-266e-4845-8de5-e4a6642bd2c0" xlink:type="arc" order="7"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_OtherComprehensiveIncomeLossCashFlowHedgeGainLossAfterReclassificationTax_1987c68c-b602-4e9e-b082-da5436a11a44" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_OtherComprehensiveIncomeLossCashFlowHedgeGainLossAfterReclassificationTax"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ReclassificationOfCashFlowHedgeGainLossAbstract_571e9043-08fa-45e9-bd18-2d78c2e7a429" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_OtherComprehensiveIncomeLossCashFlowHedgeGainLossAfterReclassificationTax_1987c68c-b602-4e9e-b082-da5436a11a44" xlink:type="arc" order="8"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_OtherComprehensiveIncomeLossCashFlowHedgeGainLossAfterReclassificationAndTax_7c1b5f86-c664-47b7-b3f8-7dcccbe1aad3" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_OtherComprehensiveIncomeLossCashFlowHedgeGainLossAfterReclassificationAndTax"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ReclassificationOfCashFlowHedgeGainLossAbstract_571e9043-08fa-45e9-bd18-2d78c2e7a429" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_OtherComprehensiveIncomeLossCashFlowHedgeGainLossAfterReclassificationAndTax_7c1b5f86-c664-47b7-b3f8-7dcccbe1aad3" xlink:type="arc" order="9"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_OtherComprehensiveIncomeLossForeignCurrencyTransactionAndTranslationAdjustmentBeforeTax_6a24d4b0-3ba4-47b9-8608-8d23a67b2a87" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_OtherComprehensiveIncomeLossForeignCurrencyTransactionAndTranslationAdjustmentBeforeTax"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_AccumulatedOtherComprehensiveIncomeLossLineItems_d75e4c76-a719-42b0-859c-f0199b15f02f" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_OtherComprehensiveIncomeLossForeignCurrencyTransactionAndTranslationAdjustmentBeforeTax_6a24d4b0-3ba4-47b9-8608-8d23a67b2a87" xlink:type="arc" order="3"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_OtherComprehensiveIncomeLossForeignCurrencyTranslationAdjustmentTax_e8e93172-1f31-47bb-9b87-2dbf84423c07" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_OtherComprehensiveIncomeLossForeignCurrencyTranslationAdjustmentTax"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_AccumulatedOtherComprehensiveIncomeLossLineItems_d75e4c76-a719-42b0-859c-f0199b15f02f" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_OtherComprehensiveIncomeLossForeignCurrencyTranslationAdjustmentTax_e8e93172-1f31-47bb-9b87-2dbf84423c07" xlink:type="arc" order="4"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_OtherComprehensiveIncomeLossForeignCurrencyTransactionAndTranslationAdjustmentNetOfTax_b1bdfb7c-49c1-4c80-946d-ab70d686ae5e" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_OtherComprehensiveIncomeLossForeignCurrencyTransactionAndTranslationAdjustmentNetOfTax"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_AccumulatedOtherComprehensiveIncomeLossLineItems_d75e4c76-a719-42b0-859c-f0199b15f02f" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_OtherComprehensiveIncomeLossForeignCurrencyTransactionAndTranslationAdjustmentNetOfTax_b1bdfb7c-49c1-4c80-946d-ab70d686ae5e" xlink:type="arc" order="5"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_OtherComprehensiveIncomeLossPensionAndOtherPostretirementBenefitPlansAdjustmentBeforeTax_f6576af7-01e9-4a8d-a38d-a6d4c8ffec3b" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_OtherComprehensiveIncomeLossPensionAndOtherPostretirementBenefitPlansAdjustmentBeforeTax"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_AccumulatedOtherComprehensiveIncomeLossLineItems_d75e4c76-a719-42b0-859c-f0199b15f02f" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_OtherComprehensiveIncomeLossPensionAndOtherPostretirementBenefitPlansAdjustmentBeforeTax_f6576af7-01e9-4a8d-a38d-a6d4c8ffec3b" xlink:type="arc" order="6"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_OtherComprehensiveIncomeLossPensionAndOtherPostretirementBenefitPlansTax_17ea8558-8b76-479a-b0b4-443953558a3d" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_OtherComprehensiveIncomeLossPensionAndOtherPostretirementBenefitPlansTax"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_AccumulatedOtherComprehensiveIncomeLossLineItems_d75e4c76-a719-42b0-859c-f0199b15f02f" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_OtherComprehensiveIncomeLossPensionAndOtherPostretirementBenefitPlansTax_17ea8558-8b76-479a-b0b4-443953558a3d" xlink:type="arc" order="7"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_OtherComprehensiveIncomeLossPensionAndOtherPostretirementBenefitPlansAdjustmentNetOfTax_345dd132-69f0-43e6-82b6-d930d6452fc4" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_OtherComprehensiveIncomeLossPensionAndOtherPostretirementBenefitPlansAdjustmentNetOfTax"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_AccumulatedOtherComprehensiveIncomeLossLineItems_d75e4c76-a719-42b0-859c-f0199b15f02f" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_OtherComprehensiveIncomeLossPensionAndOtherPostretirementBenefitPlansAdjustmentNetOfTax_345dd132-69f0-43e6-82b6-d930d6452fc4" xlink:type="arc" order="8"/>
  </link:definitionLink>
  <link:roleRef roleURI="http://www.afginc.com/role/ShareholdersEquityNarrativeDetails" xlink:type="simple" xlink:href="afg-20240930.xsd#ShareholdersEquityNarrativeDetails"/>
  <link:definitionLink xlink:role="http://www.afginc.com/role/ShareholdersEquityNarrativeDetails" xlink:type="extended">
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_ShareBasedCompensationArrangementByShareBasedPaymentAwardLineItems_2aa4e5f1-a7b8-454d-a069-df37f02f7f6e" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_ShareBasedCompensationArrangementByShareBasedPaymentAwardLineItems"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfShareBasedCompensationArrangementsByShareBasedPaymentAwardTable_8154eb67-da6e-4957-90bb-c413bd4d6547" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_ScheduleOfShareBasedCompensationArrangementsByShareBasedPaymentAwardTable"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/all" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ShareBasedCompensationArrangementByShareBasedPaymentAwardLineItems_2aa4e5f1-a7b8-454d-a069-df37f02f7f6e" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfShareBasedCompensationArrangementsByShareBasedPaymentAwardTable_8154eb67-da6e-4957-90bb-c413bd4d6547" xlink:type="arc" order="1" xbrldt:closed="true" xbrldt:contextElement="segment"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_AwardTypeAxis_501ebacf-ba57-44e8-8bd1-c5290659b8f8" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_AwardTypeAxis"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/hypercube-dimension" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfShareBasedCompensationArrangementsByShareBasedPaymentAwardTable_8154eb67-da6e-4957-90bb-c413bd4d6547" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_AwardTypeAxis_501ebacf-ba57-44e8-8bd1-c5290659b8f8" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_ShareBasedCompensationArrangementsByShareBasedPaymentAwardAwardTypeAndPlanNameDomain_501ebacf-ba57-44e8-8bd1-c5290659b8f8_default" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_ShareBasedCompensationArrangementsByShareBasedPaymentAwardAwardTypeAndPlanNameDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-default" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_AwardTypeAxis_501ebacf-ba57-44e8-8bd1-c5290659b8f8" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_ShareBasedCompensationArrangementsByShareBasedPaymentAwardAwardTypeAndPlanNameDomain_501ebacf-ba57-44e8-8bd1-c5290659b8f8_default" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_ShareBasedCompensationArrangementsByShareBasedPaymentAwardAwardTypeAndPlanNameDomain_8390e04b-7710-4f6f-8275-ece56a8234e9" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_ShareBasedCompensationArrangementsByShareBasedPaymentAwardAwardTypeAndPlanNameDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-domain" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_AwardTypeAxis_501ebacf-ba57-44e8-8bd1-c5290659b8f8" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_ShareBasedCompensationArrangementsByShareBasedPaymentAwardAwardTypeAndPlanNameDomain_8390e04b-7710-4f6f-8275-ece56a8234e9" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_RestrictedStockMember_623b116a-854a-467e-8acb-e593998b770f" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_RestrictedStockMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ShareBasedCompensationArrangementsByShareBasedPaymentAwardAwardTypeAndPlanNameDomain_8390e04b-7710-4f6f-8275-ece56a8234e9" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_RestrictedStockMember_623b116a-854a-467e-8acb-e593998b770f" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_StockCompensationPlanMember_a3a813f6-2d8e-45c8-9e50-598f3c52b541" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_StockCompensationPlanMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ShareBasedCompensationArrangementsByShareBasedPaymentAwardAwardTypeAndPlanNameDomain_8390e04b-7710-4f6f-8275-ece56a8234e9" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_StockCompensationPlanMember_a3a813f6-2d8e-45c8-9e50-598f3c52b541" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_StockIssuedDuringPeriodSharesRestrictedStockAwardGross_71e1c81d-6c40-4dcd-baf6-6e4a8a8e8d44" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_StockIssuedDuringPeriodSharesRestrictedStockAwardGross"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ShareBasedCompensationArrangementByShareBasedPaymentAwardLineItems_2aa4e5f1-a7b8-454d-a069-df37f02f7f6e" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_StockIssuedDuringPeriodSharesRestrictedStockAwardGross_71e1c81d-6c40-4dcd-baf6-6e4a8a8e8d44" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_ShareBasedCompensationArrangementByShareBasedPaymentAwardEquityInstrumentsOtherThanOptionsGrantsInPeriodWeightedAverageGrantDateFairValue_b48cf0da-9678-4df9-b1e3-fd5121c7651f" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_ShareBasedCompensationArrangementByShareBasedPaymentAwardEquityInstrumentsOtherThanOptionsGrantsInPeriodWeightedAverageGrantDateFairValue"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ShareBasedCompensationArrangementByShareBasedPaymentAwardLineItems_2aa4e5f1-a7b8-454d-a069-df37f02f7f6e" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_ShareBasedCompensationArrangementByShareBasedPaymentAwardEquityInstrumentsOtherThanOptionsGrantsInPeriodWeightedAverageGrantDateFairValue_b48cf0da-9678-4df9-b1e3-fd5121c7651f" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_AllocatedShareBasedCompensationExpense_5f3d6f1b-113d-4e7e-a4a0-e7091985c503" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_AllocatedShareBasedCompensationExpense"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ShareBasedCompensationArrangementByShareBasedPaymentAwardLineItems_2aa4e5f1-a7b8-454d-a069-df37f02f7f6e" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_AllocatedShareBasedCompensationExpense_5f3d6f1b-113d-4e7e-a4a0-e7091985c503" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
  </link:definitionLink>
  <link:roleRef roleURI="http://www.afginc.com/role/InsuranceRecoverablesfromreinsuranceprogressionofallowanceforexpectedcreditlossesDetails" xlink:type="simple" xlink:href="afg-20240930.xsd#InsuranceRecoverablesfromreinsuranceprogressionofallowanceforexpectedcreditlossesDetails"/>
  <link:definitionLink xlink:role="http://www.afginc.com/role/InsuranceRecoverablesfromreinsuranceprogressionofallowanceforexpectedcreditlossesDetails" xlink:type="extended">
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_InsuranceLineItems_405f2741-ef38-41b9-a755-73d9bdb91959" xlink:href="afg-20240930.xsd#afg_InsuranceLineItems"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_InsuranceTable_b5c2a1c0-a48c-4383-937e-04fc0cac4f8e" xlink:href="afg-20240930.xsd#afg_InsuranceTable"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/all" xlink:from="loc_afg_InsuranceLineItems_405f2741-ef38-41b9-a755-73d9bdb91959" xlink:to="loc_afg_InsuranceTable_b5c2a1c0-a48c-4383-937e-04fc0cac4f8e" xlink:type="arc" order="1" xbrldt:closed="true" xbrldt:contextElement="segment"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionAxis_0cdcd4cf-293a-4070-a878-44ab8d33001a" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionAxis"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/hypercube-dimension" xlink:from="loc_afg_InsuranceTable_b5c2a1c0-a48c-4383-937e-04fc0cac4f8e" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionAxis_0cdcd4cf-293a-4070-a878-44ab8d33001a" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionAcquireeDomain_0cdcd4cf-293a-4070-a878-44ab8d33001a_default" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionAcquireeDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-default" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionAxis_0cdcd4cf-293a-4070-a878-44ab8d33001a" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionAcquireeDomain_0cdcd4cf-293a-4070-a878-44ab8d33001a_default" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionAcquireeDomain_be47a119-6388-43ed-95fc-5078450cc842" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionAcquireeDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-domain" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionAxis_0cdcd4cf-293a-4070-a878-44ab8d33001a" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionAcquireeDomain_be47a119-6388-43ed-95fc-5078450cc842" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_CropRiskServicesMember_2f9c48a6-8edf-4b23-94b0-972b82f15865" xlink:href="afg-20240930.xsd#afg_CropRiskServicesMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionAcquireeDomain_be47a119-6388-43ed-95fc-5078450cc842" xlink:to="loc_afg_CropRiskServicesMember_2f9c48a6-8edf-4b23-94b0-972b82f15865" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_ReinsuranceRecoverableAllowanceForCreditLossRollForward_66a0b8e9-3e65-46e0-9d81-951456492bd7" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_ReinsuranceRecoverableAllowanceForCreditLossRollForward"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_afg_InsuranceLineItems_405f2741-ef38-41b9-a755-73d9bdb91959" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_ReinsuranceRecoverableAllowanceForCreditLossRollForward_66a0b8e9-3e65-46e0-9d81-951456492bd7" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_ReinsuranceRecoverablesAllowance_effc0a86-e6c1-41fd-8489-e7635054f237" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_ReinsuranceRecoverablesAllowance"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ReinsuranceRecoverableAllowanceForCreditLossRollForward_66a0b8e9-3e65-46e0-9d81-951456492bd7" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_ReinsuranceRecoverablesAllowance_effc0a86-e6c1-41fd-8489-e7635054f237" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_ReinsuranceRecoverableAllowanceForCreditLossPeriodIncreaseDecrease_c67fa55d-c157-4ecb-9851-2f521c8120f3" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_ReinsuranceRecoverableAllowanceForCreditLossPeriodIncreaseDecrease"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ReinsuranceRecoverableAllowanceForCreditLossRollForward_66a0b8e9-3e65-46e0-9d81-951456492bd7" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_ReinsuranceRecoverableAllowanceForCreditLossPeriodIncreaseDecrease_c67fa55d-c157-4ecb-9851-2f521c8120f3" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_ReinsuranceRecoverableCreditLossExpenseReversal_b11f67d5-1c24-4705-965c-d53f8e1c07a3" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_ReinsuranceRecoverableCreditLossExpenseReversal"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ReinsuranceRecoverableAllowanceForCreditLossRollForward_66a0b8e9-3e65-46e0-9d81-951456492bd7" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_ReinsuranceRecoverableCreditLossExpenseReversal_b11f67d5-1c24-4705-965c-d53f8e1c07a3" xlink:type="arc" order="3"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_ReinsuranceLossOnUncollectibleAccountsInPeriodAmount_1674dd0a-09ee-4922-a0cb-34d3f85abec5" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_ReinsuranceLossOnUncollectibleAccountsInPeriodAmount"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ReinsuranceRecoverableAllowanceForCreditLossRollForward_66a0b8e9-3e65-46e0-9d81-951456492bd7" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_ReinsuranceLossOnUncollectibleAccountsInPeriodAmount_1674dd0a-09ee-4922-a0cb-34d3f85abec5" xlink:type="arc" order="4"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_ReinsuranceRecoverablesAllowance_78988c61-0c0d-4116-9923-9c3b3ffb397b" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_ReinsuranceRecoverablesAllowance"/>
  </link:definitionLink>
  <link:roleRef roleURI="http://www.afginc.com/role/InsurancePremiumsreceivableprogressionofallowanceforexpectedcreditlossesDetails" xlink:type="simple" xlink:href="afg-20240930.xsd#InsurancePremiumsreceivableprogressionofallowanceforexpectedcreditlossesDetails"/>
  <link:definitionLink xlink:role="http://www.afginc.com/role/InsurancePremiumsreceivableprogressionofallowanceforexpectedcreditlossesDetails" xlink:type="extended">
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_InsuranceLineItems_dd31018e-c7ec-40df-a4a3-b43573d2266f" xlink:href="afg-20240930.xsd#afg_InsuranceLineItems"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_InsuranceTable_67bf4410-949e-413f-a158-12e6749f4d82" xlink:href="afg-20240930.xsd#afg_InsuranceTable"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/all" xlink:from="loc_afg_InsuranceLineItems_dd31018e-c7ec-40df-a4a3-b43573d2266f" xlink:to="loc_afg_InsuranceTable_67bf4410-949e-413f-a158-12e6749f4d82" xlink:type="arc" order="1" xbrldt:closed="true" xbrldt:contextElement="segment"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionAxis_852d89d7-ae68-4355-a9c3-f507ab144a08" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionAxis"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/hypercube-dimension" xlink:from="loc_afg_InsuranceTable_67bf4410-949e-413f-a158-12e6749f4d82" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionAxis_852d89d7-ae68-4355-a9c3-f507ab144a08" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionAcquireeDomain_852d89d7-ae68-4355-a9c3-f507ab144a08_default" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionAcquireeDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-default" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionAxis_852d89d7-ae68-4355-a9c3-f507ab144a08" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionAcquireeDomain_852d89d7-ae68-4355-a9c3-f507ab144a08_default" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionAcquireeDomain_f012c6f5-d38a-4919-bf58-bff66ae1c625" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionAcquireeDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-domain" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionAxis_852d89d7-ae68-4355-a9c3-f507ab144a08" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionAcquireeDomain_f012c6f5-d38a-4919-bf58-bff66ae1c625" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_CropRiskServicesMember_71a31231-2eb5-45be-9827-f6c8fc2fe247" xlink:href="afg-20240930.xsd#afg_CropRiskServicesMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionAcquireeDomain_f012c6f5-d38a-4919-bf58-bff66ae1c625" xlink:to="loc_afg_CropRiskServicesMember_71a31231-2eb5-45be-9827-f6c8fc2fe247" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_PremiumsReceivableAllowanceForDoubtfulAccountsRollForward_e4b669c9-58f7-4292-952a-3249463697b8" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_PremiumsReceivableAllowanceForDoubtfulAccountsRollForward"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_afg_InsuranceLineItems_dd31018e-c7ec-40df-a4a3-b43573d2266f" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_PremiumsReceivableAllowanceForDoubtfulAccountsRollForward_e4b669c9-58f7-4292-952a-3249463697b8" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_PremiumsReceivableAllowanceForDoubtfulAccounts_ec7e4e45-22cc-4b57-821a-a9f133fbbbd9" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_PremiumsReceivableAllowanceForDoubtfulAccounts"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_PremiumsReceivableAllowanceForDoubtfulAccountsRollForward_e4b669c9-58f7-4292-952a-3249463697b8" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_PremiumsReceivableAllowanceForDoubtfulAccounts_ec7e4e45-22cc-4b57-821a-a9f133fbbbd9" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_PremiumsReceivableAllowanceForDoubtfulAccountsPeriodIncreaseDecrease_efbe079f-3677-432e-83fe-cfd35b0cffd0" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_PremiumsReceivableAllowanceForDoubtfulAccountsPeriodIncreaseDecrease"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_PremiumsReceivableAllowanceForDoubtfulAccountsRollForward_e4b669c9-58f7-4292-952a-3249463697b8" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_PremiumsReceivableAllowanceForDoubtfulAccountsPeriodIncreaseDecrease_efbe079f-3677-432e-83fe-cfd35b0cffd0" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_PremiumReceivableCreditLossExpenseReversal_cc591096-2df9-4137-b098-b551fe0e8a6e" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_PremiumReceivableCreditLossExpenseReversal"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_PremiumsReceivableAllowanceForDoubtfulAccountsRollForward_e4b669c9-58f7-4292-952a-3249463697b8" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_PremiumReceivableCreditLossExpenseReversal_cc591096-2df9-4137-b098-b551fe0e8a6e" xlink:type="arc" order="3"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_PremiumsReceivableAllowanceForDoubtfulAccountsWriteOffsAgainstAllowance_ef3e2d2c-1089-4c38-b9bd-b89a2c09c375" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_PremiumsReceivableAllowanceForDoubtfulAccountsWriteOffsAgainstAllowance"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_PremiumsReceivableAllowanceForDoubtfulAccountsRollForward_e4b669c9-58f7-4292-952a-3249463697b8" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_PremiumsReceivableAllowanceForDoubtfulAccountsWriteOffsAgainstAllowance_ef3e2d2c-1089-4c38-b9bd-b89a2c09c375" xlink:type="arc" order="4"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_PremiumsReceivableAllowanceForDoubtfulAccounts_f0c9a407-acdd-4e85-9159-8237d7e5b9c0" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_PremiumsReceivableAllowanceForDoubtfulAccounts"/>
  </link:definitionLink>
  <link:roleRef roleURI="http://xbrl.sec.gov/ecd/AwardTypeOnly" xlink:type="simple" xlink:href="https://xbrl.sec.gov/ecd/2024/ecd-2024.xsd#AwardTypeOnly"/>
  <link:definitionLink xlink:role="http://xbrl.sec.gov/ecd/AwardTypeOnly" xlink:type="extended">
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_ShareBasedCompensationArrangementsByShareBasedPaymentAwardAwardTypeAndPlanNameDomain" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_ShareBasedCompensationArrangementsByShareBasedPaymentAwardAwardTypeAndPlanNameDomain"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_RestrictedStockMember" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_RestrictedStockMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ShareBasedCompensationArrangementsByShareBasedPaymentAwardAwardTypeAndPlanNameDomain" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_RestrictedStockMember" xlink:type="arc" order="3"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_StockCompensationPlanMember" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_StockCompensationPlanMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ShareBasedCompensationArrangementsByShareBasedPaymentAwardAwardTypeAndPlanNameDomain" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_StockCompensationPlanMember" xlink:type="arc" order="4"/>
  </link:definitionLink>
  <link:roleRef roleURI="http://fasb.org/us-gaap/role/eedm/ExtensibleEnumerationLists" xlink:type="simple" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-roles-2024.xsd#eedm"/>
  <link:definitionLink xlink:role="http://fasb.org/us-gaap/role/eedm/ExtensibleEnumerationLists" xlink:type="extended">
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_LiabilitiesCurrentAbstract" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_LiabilitiesCurrentAbstract"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_OtherLiabilities" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_OtherLiabilities"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_LiabilitiesCurrentAbstract" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_OtherLiabilities" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_AssetsAbstract" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_AssetsAbstract"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtSecurities" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2024/elts/us-gaap-2024.xsd#us-gaap_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtSecurities"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_AssetsAbstract" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtSecurities" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
  </link:definitionLink>
</link:linkbase>
